❌

Reading view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.

Report examines opportunities, shortcomings of Wisconsin treatment courts 

Gavel courtroom sitting vacant

Treatment court offers a path to recovery and and alternative to a punitive criminal justice approach. But just over half of participants in Wisconsin make it through the process. (Getty Images creative)

The Wisconsin Examiner’s Criminal Justice Reporting Project shines a light on incarceration, law enforcement and criminal justice issues with support from the Public Welfare Foundation.

Treatment courts are intended to offer accountability and encouragement for people who have a substance abuse issue and also a pending criminal charge.

The carrot for those who complete the requirements of the court, show progress toward sobriety, is the criminal charge will be avoided or there will be leniency.

Treatment courts, also called drug court or wellness court, veteran courts and OWI court, are well-established in many Wisconsin counties.

A new report prepared by the Wisconsin Policy Forum, commissioned by Vital Strategies, a global health nonprofit, examines the 104 treatment courts in the state, including 61 that receive Treatment Alternatives and Diversion (TAD) funding from the state that require data reporting from each court.

Besides the TAD courts, the report obtained data from 53 treatment court coordinators in 43 counties and treatment court information available in manuals and web sites.

The report notes that drug and narcotics violations were involved in nearly 25% of arrests in 2023, highlighting the importance of treatment courts to address the deeper problem of addiction and substance abuse.

At a press conference Tuesday, the report’s authors discussed some of its notable findings. One interesting fact is that only 54% of those in TAD treatment courts between 2019-2024 successfully graduated.

“It’s worth noting that sometimes there’s a misconception that treatment court is easy or that it doesn’t ask a lot of participants,” said Jason Stein, president of Wisconsin Policy Forum, “and you can see here that the data tell a different story, in terms of who makes it through to the end.”

 Stein said data from the National Treatment Court Resource Center report the graduation rate nationwide is higher, at 60.7%.

“Treatment court is the hardest thing participants have ever done,” said Milwaukee County Circuit Judge Carl Ashley at the press conference. “They appear regularly before a judge. They are drug tested. They attend treatment. They must be honest, and when they fall short, they have to recognize that. What they also get for the first time in their lives is a team that believes they can change: a judge, a prosecutor, a defense attorney, treatment provider, law enforcement, case managers, and for veterans, mentors who have worn that same uniform. That combination of accountability and support is what makes the difference.”

Stein noted that TAD data shows a racial disparity: 82% of people referred   to treatment court are white, versus 7.6% for Blacks and 6.9% for Native Americans. As the process moves forward into eligibility and then admittance to graduation the percentage of white participation expands but for both Blacks and Native Americans it declines.

“These desperate outcomes make this an important area for policymakers, treatment court teams and the general public to keep track of,” he said of the racial disparity.

He also noted 26 of 40 treatment coordinators said there are fewer people in their treatment courts today versus 2019, but 11 said they had more than in 2019.

 He also noted at 60 of 61 TAD courts use jail as sanction for participants such as when a treatment court participant is re-arrested or when they re-use.

“Most court officials say they do not use jail as a response to a positive drug test alone, but 10 of 45 respondents, or one-fifth, did use short-term sanctions in that circumstance,” said Stein. “It’s worth noting the importance of that because individuals when released from jail are at a heightened risk of an overdose.”

He added, “On this point of when to employ jail as a sanction, a broader discussion within the state treatment court community could be valuable given that the National All Rise Adult Treatment Court best practice standards stress the importance of using jail as a tool for protecting public safety rather than as a response to substance abuse.”

From the report findings, Adrienne Hurst of Vital Strategies made several recommendations.

First, she said, punishment for drug use is not treatment and more should be done to avoid “punitive systems that punish predictable setbacks for people in drug treatment.”

She added, “More than 20% of reviewed treatment court manuals report using jail-based sanctions in response to a positive urine test. More courts apply a jail-based sanction if a participant reported no use, but a urine test comes back positive; 29% of survey responses said that reoccurring use was a reason to terminate treatment court participation. And let’s be clear: termination of participation means return to jail.”

Second, she encouraged deferring prosecution versus requiring a conviction or a guilty plea to be qualified for treatment court.

“Deferring prosecution could also mitigate some of the knock-on effects of a criminal record that make achieving lasting recovery difficult,” she said

She also said courts should “strengthen” their “evaluation and oversight to reinforce best practices,” but be wary of adding too many regulations that results in “rigidity that reduces access and increases punitive responses…While I applaud the idea that stronger practice requirements and additional oversight will result in evidence-based practices that promote wellness, treatment courts should avoid policies that increase the intensity of court requirements on participants.”

Fourth, she recommended the use of methadone and buprenorphine for opioid treatment.

“Most courts who responded to the survey allow methadone or buprenorphine, which are the standards for treatment for opioid use disorder,” she said. “Naltrexone is FDA approved but is significantly less protective against overdose than buprenorphine and methadone. Medication choice should be based on a discussion between a medical provider and the participant and requires the availability of all options.”

 She also recommended that treatment courts evaluate fines and fees so they don’t create barriers to participation, and to consider those at high-risk for recidivism because research has shown they could benefit the most from “intensive programs like treatment court.”

“In addition, 41% of survey respondents report the courts exclude people who sell drugs, but low-level drug sales is a common form of survival economics for people with substance use disorder,” Hurst said, “and the exclusion of these offenses is a missed opportunity to support individuals who could benefit from the treatment court model, especially the employment and other social determinant of health supports Wisconsin courts provide.”

Eli Corbin, harm reduction coordinator for the Bad River Band of Lake Superior Chippewa, said at the press release that treatment court had helped him turn his life around because his relationship with the key players – judge, district attorney and others – went from a punitive relationship to positive interaction that provided accountability and a community of support.

Judge Ashley said treatment courts reduce recidivism by as 58% and save up to $6,000 per individual with fewer arrests and court cases and days in jail.

“That is money we can return to the community,” he said, “but the real savings are harder to count: the crime that never happens; the overdose call that never comes; the child who never enters foster care.”

Good Samaritan Coalition says saving a life should take priority over punishment

Narcan was handed out by Andrew Garr during a meeting of the Good Samaritan Coalition in Eau Claire. Garr encourage all the participants to carry Narcan to save a life. (Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

The Wisconsin Examiner’s Criminal Justice Reporting Project shines a light on incarceration, law enforcement and criminal justice issues with support from the Public Welfare Foundation.

In 2009, Jennifer Olson was on parole, out of prison and under community supervision for a felony conviction, when she stopped at a friend’s house on the way to the mall. When Olson arrived, the friend was overdosing, and the friend’s brother was panicking, unsure what to do.

After attempting CPR and placing her friend in a cold shower to revive her, Olson called 911 to save her friend’s life.

The friend was placed in a medically induced coma for 37 days and lived, but during those 37 days, Olson was held in the Waukesha County Jail, incarcerated because, as a condition of her parole, she wasn’t supposed to be around criminal activity or drugs, and it didn’t matter that she had no drugs in her system, having been clean for two months after she went to rehab.

While in jail, Olson said, she lost custody of her children, and she lost her apartment and her job.

“Would I have gone to jail for calling 911 for someone having a heart attack? No.” she said. 

The Wisconsin Good Samaritan Coalition is advocating to change Wisconsin’s law to prioritize saving a life without fear of consequences for those seeking help.

Jennifer Olson recounted calling 911 to save a friend’s life who was overdosing and then later spending 37 days in jail for violating conditions of her parole. (Photo by Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

Opioid overdose deaths in Wisconsin have dropped from a peak of 1459, or about four per day, in 2022, to 815 in 2024, according to state health department statistics.  “Many of those deaths could be prevented if people did not fear calling 911 to save a life,” the coalition says in a statement advocating for strengthening the state’s Good Samaritan law to offer protection from prosecution for people who survive an overdose and the people who help save their lives by calling for help on the scene. 

On Monday night, Sept. 28, the coalition met in Eau Claire at Hope United Methodist Church. A large contingent of University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire nursing students attended.

The Good Samaritan Coalition was the main organizer of the event, with support from ProSay, an advocacy organization for formerly incarcerated people  on community supervision, and WISDOM, a faith-based organization with 12 affiliates addressing systemic injustice, and WISDOM affiliates Free and Jonah, with Jonah hosting the event.

“Currently, Wisconsin law deters people from calling 911 in an overdose emergency and Good Samaritan Coalition feels everyone should feel safe to call 911,” said Lynn Buske, a representative of the coalition. Wisconsin has a Good Samaritan law, “but it offers very few protections, leaving people nervous,” she added.

Juli Bliefnick of ProSay said the issue was “deeply personal” to her because she had her supervision revoked and was sent to jail, losing her job and housing after she called 911 to save a life.

Several nursing students from the University of Wisconsin- Eau Claire attended the meeting. (Photo by Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

“People should not be forced to choose between their freedom and someone else’s life,” she said.

Bliefnick recounted the history of  Wisconsin’s  Good Samaritan law.

The current law, passed in 2013, grants immunity from prosecution for possession of a controlled substance to a person who summons or provides emergency medical assistance to another person suffering from an overdose. A 2017 update of the law, which is no longer in effect, also granted immunity from having parole, probation, or extended supervision revoked. The protections for people on parole, probation or supervision expired under a sunset clause in 2020.

The No. 1 reason people cite for not calling 911 in overdose cases is fear of arrest.

Mark Rice of WISDOM talked about why his organization supports the goals of the Wisconsin Good Samaritan Coalition. (Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

“I’ve experienced the grief of losing someone that I care about due to an overdose, an overdose death that could have been prevented if help had arrived in time,” said Mark Rice, the Transformational Justice Campaign Coordinator for WISDOM.

Rice said WISDOM’s goals of reducing the prison population and changing the culture and laws that result in “permanent punishment of people who have conviction records” align with the Coalition’s efforts.

“So many people fear calling 911 because of fear of arrest,” he said.  “…  the Good Samaritan Coalition is aiming to strip that fear away and to replace fear with health-centered care, and so definitely this is something that WISDOM strongly supports.”

Sarah Ferber, a regional organizer for Free, said she had several friends die of an overdose, and she had also been in situations where she had to call 911 to save a life, but she had not faced any repercussions for seeking help; however, she knew others who had called 911 and did face consequences.

Kelly Green said that when her partner overdosed, she applied six vials of Narcan to save his life, but she never called 911 out of fear of what might happen after first responders arrived.

Kelly Green said she was fearful of calling 911 when her partner overdosed and she saved him using six vials of Narcan. (Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

“Calling 911 meant bringing police and emergency services to my house, and once they were there, I couldn’t control what happened next,” she said. “What would they see? What would they ask? What would Child Protective Services see or if they would get involved? What would happen to my kids? Could I lose them? Those thoughts were going through my head while someone I loved was overdosing in front of me, and I know how that sounds after the fact. Of course you call 911. Someone might die, but that’s not what fear looks like when you’re actually living it.”

Andrew Garr, executive director of Wisconsin Milkweed Alliance (a non-profit using the lived experience of members with mental health and substance abuse to “uplift and empower”) recounted his experiences of administering naloxone (Narcan is the brand name) to revive someone he knew who was overdosing and explained how to administer it. Following that, there were discussions about advocating for an update of Wisconsin’s Good Samaritan law.

Buske encouraged participants to sign a petition, talk to others about the subject and press legislators to change the law.

Bliefnick noted that other states, even some that are more conservative than Wisconsin, including Iowa, have broader, more protective Good Samaritan laws.

She also recounted recent attempts to change the law that stalled in the state Assembly, where Speaker Robin Vos didn’t allow it to come up for a vote.

More information on the Wisconsin Good Samaritan Coalition and its effort to change the law is available on the group’s website. 

 

 

❌