❌

Normal view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.
Before yesterdayWisconsin Examiner

Election betting is booming as the midterms near. Do states have the power to curb it?

12 October 2026 at 08:20
A growing number of state officials fear prediction markets are opening the door to a new era of gambling on elections — a practice many states have long prohibited. In this photo, a voter casts a ballot during the March 3, 2026 primary in Little Rock, Arkansas. (Photo by Katie Adkins/Arkansas Advocate)

A growing number of state officials fear prediction markets are opening the door to a new era of gambling on elections — a practice many states have long prohibited. In this photo, a voter casts a ballot during the March 3, 2026 primary in Little Rock, Arkansas. (Photo by Katie Adkins/Arkansas Advocate)

On Friday morning, the prediction market platform Kalshi gave the Democratic candidate in Minnesota’s U.S. Senate race an 87% chance of winning. The volume of trading on the outcome exceeded $1.8 million.

This is exactly the type of activity Minnesota and numerous other states want to shut down.

“They jeopardize people’s trust in government and government decision-making. They jeopardize people’s trust in elections,” said Minnesota state Rep. Emma Greenman, a member of the state’s Democratic-Farmer-Labor Party. She helped spearhead Minnesota’s first-in-the-nation near-total ban on prediction markets earlier this year.

Prediction markets have emerged as a flashpoint in state and federal relations, as a host of states struggle with the Trump administration over who has authority to regulate the platforms and whether state laws restricting gambling apply to them. While much of the fight centers on the future of sports betting, a growing number of state officials fear the sites are opening the door to a new era of gambling on elections — a practice many states have long prohibited.

Some state election officials have warned their residents in recent months that using prediction markets to place money on elections is illegal. Others are locked in litigation with the platforms. At least one state, Arizona, has filed criminal charges against Kalshi.

But the prediction markets remain widely available as Election Day approaches, with the industry maintaining that the federal government has authority over the platforms, not the states.

Betting on control of Congress

On the two leading prediction market sites, Kalshi and Polymarket, individuals can put money down on the outcome of a wide array of races and related questions, like whether Kansas or Nebraska’s U.S. Senate races will have a larger margin of victory. 

That includes which party will control Congress following the midterm elections. On Friday morning, the Democratic Party had a 90% chance of winning the U.S. House on Polymarket.

Money changing hands over the outcome of elections is corrosive to democracy and amounts to an attempt to bypass existing bans on election betting, civic organizations and some public officials say. Twenty-three states completely ban election betting, according to data from the National Conference of State Legislatures analyzed by the Pew Research Center.

“It’s supposed to be a civic duty where people are deciding what candidate they actually think is best for a leadership position, not what candidate can make them the most money if they bet the right way,” said Benjamin Schiffrin, director of securities policy at Better Markets, a nonprofit watchdog group advocating for consumer and investor financial protections.

The prediction markets and their supporters say the sites offer contracts that pay out if a given event or outcome occurs. Under that view, the contracts are essentially swaps, a financial product often traded by sophisticated investors to hedge against economic risk. 

Critics of the platforms say the contracts effectively function as wagers. Unlike swaps, which investors use to help offset the effects of events like rising interest rates, contracts on sporting events, elections and other non-financial questions serve no legitimate hedging purpose, they say.

CFTC and prediction markets

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the federal regulator that oversees markets for swaps, has asserted authority to regulate the platforms under the federal Commodity Exchange Act.

In a statement, Polymarket said it maintains that “prediction markets are regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission under a federal framework, not a patchwork of state rules.”

Kalshi didn’t respond to a request for comment. In a March court filing in a federal lawsuit, lawyers for Kalshi wrote that its events contracts are swaps and that election and sports contracts “fit comfortably” within that definition.

“The outcomes of political events such as elections are connected to obvious financial consequences,” the court filing says.

The Trump administration has firmly sided with the prediction markets. The CFTC is made up of five members, but currently only has a single commissioner, Michael Selig, who was appointed by President Donald Trump in 2025.

Selig has taken a favorable stance toward the industry, and in June the CFTC proposed a rule that would set up a new framework for how the commission regulates events contracts. The rule would continue to allow trading on elections.

On Friday, the CFTC unveiled another new rule that would expressly define events contracts — including those centered on politics — as swaps.

In a July 27 letter to the CFTC, 16 civic watchdog groups, including Better Markets, Common Cause and Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, warned that the rule ignores concerns about the harm the contracts could cause to elections.

“Event contracts that involve elections allow individuals to bet on elections, which is illegal under many state laws. This election betting would incentivize election interference and has the potential to undermine the integrity of our democracy,” the groups wrote, urging the commission to prohibit election-related events contracts because they go against the public interest.

The CFTC didn’t respond to questions from States Newsroom.

“Americans use event contracts to hedge risks, speculate, and provide the public with information about the outcome of future events,” Selig said in a news release on Friday. “These products are commodity derivatives squarely within the CFTC’s regulatory remit under the Commodity Exchange Act and are within the agency’s exclusive jurisdiction.”

Maryland issues public warning

In Maryland, Jared DeMarinis, the state administrator of elections, said that in his view, the election contracts on prediction markets violate the plain meaning of his state’s prohibition on election gambling. 

The Maryland State Board of Elections, which oversees an office run by DeMarinis, issued a public warning about betting on elections in March and said that even though prediction market sites are accessible to residents, the activity on them may still conflict with state law.

DeMarinis argued that it’s important to take a strong position against election betting while the prediction market industry remains in its infancy. By 2028, a presidential election year, he fears betting on elections could become a more firmly entrenched practice.

“This is kind of like a watershed moment. You can kind of end it before it proliferates,” DeMarinis said. 

DeMarinis in July asked the Maryland Office of the State Prosecutor, which investigates violations of state election law, to examine the legality of election-related wagering on the platforms. Maryland State Prosecutor Charlton Howard wrote in an email that the agency doesn’t comment on the existence or status of an investigation unless it results in criminal charges.

Wisconsin advisory, Arizona criminal charges

In Wisconsin, the state Elections Commission issued a public advisory in July warning voters against gambling on elections, including on Kalshi and Polymarket. The commission cautioned that residents who bet on an election and then vote in the contest could have their ability to vote challenged in the future.

The Wisconsin Elections Commission declined to make its administrator, Meagan Wolfe, available for an interview. But in a statement in July, Wolfe said that “it’s important for voters to understand the consequences if they bet on an election outcome.”

Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes, a Democrat, filed state criminal charges against Kalshi in March. Mayes alleged the company had accepted bets from Arizona residents in violation of state law, including on sports and election wagering related to the 2028 presidential race, along with state-level contests in Arizona in 2026.

Kalshi preemptively sued over the prosecution in federal court and obtained an order halting the case from U.S. District Court Judge Michael T. Liburdi, a Trump appointee. He ruled that Kalshi was likely to show that a federal law granting the CFTC the authority to regulate swaps preempted Arizona’s gambling laws.

Liburdi wrote in his order that the CFTC had consistently treated weather-based financial products as swaps because weather events produce commercial consequences for a wide range of market participants. Contracts based on sports and elections function the same way, the judge wrote.

“That these event contracts can be used to offset financial exposure confirms the association between the event and commercial consequences to stakeholders,” Liburdi wrote.

Battles in the courts

The fight over who has power over prediction markets — and therefore, potentially, election contracts — is unlikely to be settled until the U.S. Supreme Court takes action.

The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, which covers much of the western United States, and the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals, which covers Delaware, New Jersey and Pennsylvania, have issued contradictory decisions. 

The 9th Circuit has sided with the states, finding that federal law doesn’t preempt state-level gambling restrictions, while the 3rd Circuit upheld the CFTC’s exclusive power to regulate events contracts.

In September, New Jersey filed a petition asking the Supreme Court to decide whether federal law preempts states from regulating sports bets offered on markets registered with the CFTC — in other words, the prediction markets. The justices haven’t decided whether to take the case, but the high court is generally seen as more likely to intervene when lower courts are divided.

New Jersey’s petition is framed around the uncertainty over sports betting, but the outcome could provide clarity on election contracts as well. In 2024 the CFTC attempted to block Kalshi from offering contracts about which party would control Congress, but an appeals court in the final weeks before Election Day allowed the company to continue.

Schiffrin said the election contracts are essentially the same as the sports contracts. 

“You’re betting on the outcome of a contest. It should be considered gambling, no different than if you’re betting on the outcome of a sporting event,” he said.

In Minnesota, a federal judge halted the state’s ban on prediction markets before it took effect this summer after the CFTC, Kalshi and Polymarket sued the state. U.S. District Court Judge Katherine Menendez, an appointee of President Joe Biden, ruled that federal law likely preempts the state’s ban on many contracts offered on prediction markets.

Minnesota bans gambling on elections and hasn’t legalized sports betting. Greenman, the Minnesota state lawmaker, said decisions about whether to allow betting should be made by people in the state.

“We should be rebuilding trust in government decision-making, that the public’s heart — the public’s interest — are what sit at the center,” Greenman said.

Prediction markets spend millions to influence state, federal governments

5 October 2026 at 07:51
Online prediction markets such as Kalshi and Polymarket are attracting scrutiny from state lawmakers, who argue the platforms are undermining state gambling regulations. (Photo by Alyssa Chen/Minnesota Reformer)

Online prediction markets such as Kalshi and Polymarket are attracting scrutiny from state lawmakers, who argue the platforms are undermining state gambling regulations. (Photo by Alyssa Chen/Minnesota Reformer)

Kalshi, Polymarket and the Coalition for Prediction Markets have spent at least $3 million this year on lobbying and campaign contributions across the federal and state levels, according to a new report from the government watchdog group OpenSecrets.

Prediction market platforms say they are like commodity markets that offer contracts to speculate on the future price of corn or oil — not sportsbooks that allow gamblers to place bets. But many states reject those justifications, arguing the platforms offer a backdoor to skirt state gambling regulations, particularly on sports.

The issue has sparked action from state regulators, new legislation, and a flurry of lawsuits from states, prediction markets, and the Trump administration, which has sought to sideline state oversight.

Kalshi, by far the largest prediction market platform, has targeted much of its political spending on governors and state attorneys general.

OpenSecrets found that Kalshi poured more than $300,000 combined into the two major political organizations dedicated to electing and supporting AGs: The Republican Attorneys General Association and the Democratic Attorneys General Association.

Likewise, Kalshi donated $100,000 to the Republican Governors Association and $150,000 to the Democratic Governors Association in the first half of the year.

“Like many U.S. regulated companies, we support candidates on both sides of the aisle,” Dani Lever, a spokesperson for Kalshi, told OpenSecrets in a statement.

The analysis found Kalshi has hired at least one lobbyist in 41 states, focusing much of that effort on California and New York. That means the company has a  lobbying presence in every state that has introduced prediction-market-specific legislation.

State lawmakers of both parties are growing increasingly frustrated with prediction markets, arguing they are avoiding state gambling regulations or gambling bans, gambling taxes and consumer protections.

This summer, Sara Slane, Head of Corporate Development at Kalshi, told lawmakers that the company was committed to building relationships with the states. But she said the prediction markets are not subject to state oversight, as they are regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, which regulates derivatives such as futures contracts on stocks.

That five-member commission currently has four vacancies. But it has aggressively defended prediction markets and its right to oversee them  — going so far as to sue nine states that attempted to regulate the industry. Donald Trump Jr., the president’s eldest son, has financial stakes in both Kalshi and Polymarket.

With litigation flying on the issue, many observers expect the U.S. Supreme Court to ultimately decide what role states can play in regulating prediction markets.

In addition to its political spending in states, OpenSecrets found the industry remains committed to federal lobbying, with Kalshi alone spending nearly $1 million in the first half of the year. Those efforts focused on the CFTC, the White House, the Securities & Exchange Commission and both chambers of Congress.

Brad Lipton, director of the Roosevelt Institute’s corporate power and financial regulation program, told OpenSecrets the lobbying push was evidence of the “existential question” facing prediction markets.

“It’s not at all clear to me that their business model can compete if they are going to comply with state law,” Lipton said. “They’re really trying to create a situation, I think, where they have enough political power to overcome the legal deficiencies in their arguments.”

Stateline reporter Kevin Hardy can be reached at khardy@stateline.org. 

This story was originally produced by Stateline, which is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network which includes Wisconsin Examiner, and is supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity.

Congressional stock trading is not a good issue for Bryan Steil

2 October 2026 at 08:30

Wisconsin Republican U.S. Rep. Bryan Steil leaves the office of House Speaker Mike Johnson in November, 2025. Steil, who has nearly doubled his net worth since he was first elected to Congres, is running as a watchdog on congressional stock trading. (Photo by Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)

U.S. Rep. Bryan Steil’s investments helped make him millionaire, nearly doubling his net worth from $812,000 to nearly $1.9 million since he went to Congress, Wisconsin Watch reports. According to the financial data tracking platform Unusual Whales, Steil’s stock portfolio was the fourth most profitable among members of Congress in 2025, outperforming the S&P 500 by 62.5%. Yet Steil is running as a watchdog on congressional stock trading. 

“You deserve a Congress you can trust, that’s working for you. … I’m leading the charge to ban members of Congress from trading stocks,” Steil says in a campaign ad now running in Wisconsin’s suddenly competitive 1st Congressional District.

The ad refers to Steil’s Stop Insider Trading Act, which failed in the Senate this week. Steil blamed Democrats for blocking his attempt at “ethics reform” and vowed to keep fighting.  But Wisconsin’s Democratic Sen. Tammy Baldwin called the bill a “sham,” pointing out that there are much stronger bills that, unlike Steil’s, require members to divest their stock holdings.

Steil’s bill allows members of Congress to keep and sell stocks. It places no restrictions on their purchases of cryptocurrency holdings, betting in prediction markets or trades in industry-specific mutual funds or private stock offerings from corporations. 

These giant loopholes drew the attention of Steil’s colleague U.S. Rep. Joe Neguse of Colorado, who grilled Steil on the shortcomings in his bill during a House Rules Committee hearing on July 20. 

“There are many bills that have been introduced … that would ensure that the sale and the purchase of stocks is banned, and this bill does not do that,” Neguse pointed out. He and Steil debated whether a disclosure rule in Steil’s bill is a sufficient safeguard (Neguse didn’t think so), and why the bill didn’t cover prediction markets. 

The Senate unanimously passed a ban on members and staff participating in prediction markets, just one week after a U.S. special forces soldier was charged with using classified information to bet on the capture of the Venezuelan president. Members of Congress have access to all kinds of sensitive information they could use for personal gain by placing bets on wars, economic crises or elections, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer warned. Why can’t the House pass the same ban, Neguse asked. Steil replied that he has been working on a separate bill concerning prediction markets, which are a “new and novel technology.” 

“It took the Senate a day!” Neguse shot back. “It’s a one-page resolution. It literally is a paragraph. It just says members of the Senate are banned from participating in prediction markets.” Neguse suggested that the House adopt the Senate’s language and pass the same resolution immediately. 

Instead, Steil has crafted a narrow bill that imposes fines on members and their families if they bet on specific government policy matters that come to their attention through their congressional work. Like his narrow stock-trading bill, which avoids making members give up lucrative investments, the Stop Lawmakers from Predicting Act takes a permissive view of members interested in playing in prediction markets unless there is a specific, demonstrable conflict of interest that a member’s colleagues on the House ethics panel deem worthy of a fine.

At best, that’s a different goal than the “Congress you can trust” Steil talks about in his campaign ad. Instead of protecting the public from corrupt public officials who seek to profit from their privileged perch, Steil is intent on not making things too uncomfortable for his fellow members sitting on cushy portfolios.

It says a lot that Steil’s prediction market bill and his Stop Insider Trading Act both have the full support of President Donald Trump. As Baldwin points out, Trump is exempt from Steil’s proposed restrictions on stock trading, even though Trump made 21,000 stock trades and added $2.2 billion to his personal wealth in just the first year of his second term.

This is the real hole in Steil’s claim to be an ethics watchdog in Congress. His compromised reform proposals don’t come close to making up for the heavy lifting he has been doing in office carrying water for Trump. He has been a chief enabler for a president who is setting new records for unethical behavior as he uses his office to enrich himself. Along with his weak efforts at “ethics reform,” Steil has been pushing new voting restrictions dear to Trump’s heart. His proposed national Voter ID Act is even more restrictive than Wisconsin’s toughest-in-the-nation voter ID law, barring the use of student IDs to vote and potentially disenfranchising millions of eligible voters who don’t meet the requirements. 

Steil does not present as a rage-filled MAGA warrior. Like his mentor, former House Speaker Paul Ryan, he has repeatedly won reelection by comfortable margins while projecting a friendly, thoughtful image in his home district, even as his work in Washington diverges from his constituents’ interests. But as crises pile up, it’s getting harder to put a pleasant gloss on loyalty to an administration that is rapaciously devouring the nation’s wealth while trying to disenfranchise its citizens. 

Wisconsin’s 1st CD has attracted national attention recently as the political landscape gets tougher for Republicans even in solidly red House districts. The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee added Steil’s reelection race to its Red to Blue list and an internal DCCC poll conducted Sept. 21-23 — with a margin of error of 4.4% — found the race is a dead heat between Steil and his challenger, former VA hospital nurse Mitchell Berman, with the two candidates tied 48-48 among likely voters, a plurality of whom identified as Republicans.

A new Berman campaign ad, paid for in part by the DCCC, which now sees Steil as a target, emphasizes Steil’s stock portfolio. In it, Berman declares, “Public service shouldn’t be about getting rich.” Steil couldn’t have said it better himself.

❌
❌