❌

Reading view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.

State Superintendent Jill Underly requests $2.75 billion, new school funding system

“It's time to fix Wisconsin’s school funding formula,” Underly said in a two-minute video posted to social media Friday. Underly speaks to reporters after delivering her sixth State of Education address. (Photo by Baylor Spears/Wisconsin Examiner)

Wisconsin State Superintendent Jill Underly is proposing that the state spend an additional $2.75 billion on Wisconsin’s schools and make major changes to the education funding formula to take the burden of paying for  schools off local property taxpayers.

“It’s time to fix Wisconsin’s school funding formula,” Underly said in a two-minute video posted to social media Friday. “The era of operating referendums needs to come to an end. Our schools shouldn’t have to go back to their communities time and time again, asking property taxpayers for more money because of a broken school funding formula.” 

Wisconsin public schools have relied increasingly on property tax increases sought at the ballot box through referendum requests to meet an array of costs, including staff pay, course offering, electric and water bills.

According to a Wisconsin Policy Forum report published Friday, about 58% of 155 school referendum requests were approved in 2026 — a steep dropoff in approval rates during even-year elections. Typically, there is a higher rate of approvals during presidential and midterm election years, but this was the lowest approval rate in an even-year since 2010. 

The report also notes that a higher proportion of requests are operational rather than building capital requests. In previous years, there’s been about an even divide between the types of requests, but this year, about 80% of requests were for operations. The report concluded that the turn to operational referendums “signals the fiscal stress that some school districts are facing.” 

“It arises from multiple sources, including increased staffing to meet rising student needs, declining student enrollment, and a tight labor market and especially high inflation after the pandemic’s peak,” the report states. “State policy also has played a primary role.” 

Despite school districts’ needs, the approval rate for operational requests, 54%, was lower than the overall rate.

Underly is seeking to shift a larger portion of education costs to the state. 

Democratic state lawmakers and Gov.-elect David Crowley will write and approve the next state budget, but the process of drafting it starts with agencies putting forth their own proposals. 

Underly’s request for the 2027-29 budget includes a slate of changes to the way that schools are funded. 

Under her proposal, school districts would receive a significant increase to their school revenue limits, which cap the amount that districts can bring in through a combination of property taxes and state aid each year. There would be a boost of $1,108 per student in the first year of Underly’s budget and an additional $374 per student in the second year. 

The increases would be in addition to the $325 per student annual increases that school districts received through Gov. Tony Evers’ 400-year budget veto in the 2023 budget. The agency says that the increases are meant to help schools catch up with inflation. Inflationary increases to revenue limits were eliminated in 2009 during the recession, and since then, increases to revenue limits have been based on lawmakers’ appetite to provide them.

Underly’s proposal would once again tie future increases to the rate of inflation. 

The state’s special education reimbursement rate would be raised to 50% in the first year of the DPI  budget proposal and 60% in the second year. 

Another shift Underly proposed is making special education support a “sum sufficient” allocation, meaning that the state would guarantee a set reimbursement rate even if costs changed, as opposed to a “sum certain” allocation, where the state offers is a fixed amount of money that might or might not meet its projected rate of reimbursement, depending on costs.

Wisconsin Public Education Network Executive Director Heather DuBois Bourenane said in a statement that Underly’s proposal “takes a serious step toward addressing the root of the problem with Wisconsin’s unfair and inadequate funding formula.” 

“Wisconsin voters signaled last week that it’s time for Wisconsin to catch up to the rest of the nation and stop playing politics with school budgets while our kids and local taxpayers pay the price,” DuBois Bourenane said. 

Republicans have controlled of the state Legislature since Underly took office in 2021, and  often ignored her budget proposals and declined to invite her to make presentations to the legislative budget committee. 

Underly’s proposal this year could get more serious consideration from Crowley and Democrats who will be leading the budget writing process, but it will be in competition with a variety of other priorities and it’s unclear how much of Underly’s $2.75 billion proposal will make it into the final budget. 

The plan also seeks to help disadvantaged districts by shifting nearly $2 billion to Wisconsin’s equalization aid formula.

The equalization aid formula considers a number of factors including number of students, operational and debt service costs, and local property valuations. 

Equalization aid tends to provide districts with lower property wealth with more aid. Under the plan, districts that could potentially lose aid would be provided with a one-time payment.

The agency is also proposing that the state apply an additional 20% funding weight for economically disadvantaged students and English learners.

The Wisconsin Policy Forum report noted that “the same voter concerns about affordability widely seen as a major factor in sweeping Democrats into power appear to have played a material role in depressing referendum approval rates.”

DPI’s budget presentation asserts that the plan could be implemented without increasing the statewide property tax levy.

Affordability is a top priority for Crowley and incoming Democratic lawmakers. The state will enter 2027 with a $3 billion budget surplus, which could be tapped to address affordability  issues. It’s a much different financial position than in 2009, the last time Democrats had control of the state Senate, Assembly and governor’s office and the state had a $6 billion budget deficit.

Democrats have said that investing in schools could help bring down property taxes. Incoming Assembly Speaker Greta Neubauer has said that they want to stop the cycle of referendum requests to property taxpayers, make changes to the funding formula and provide free schools to help bring down families’ grocery costs.

“I think it’s possible that we will propose some changes in the school funding formula, but our No. 1 priority is to get kids and families the resources that they need,” Neubauer said. 

However, other Democrats, including incoming Senate Majority Leader Dianne Hesselbein, have discussed wanting to study potential changes to education funding and Gov.-elect Crowley has suggested he might appoint a blue ribbon commission to look at taxation.

In her video, Underly said the state does not need to study the issue further. 

“We don’t need to start from scratch. We don’t need another committee. We don’t need more rounds of studies or a series of proposals,” Underly said. “We know what needs to change, and we have the framework to do it. Now, we need state leaders to come together and put the solution into action.”

School referendum passage declines amid public school advocates’ high hopes for new state government

A hallway in La Follette High School in Madison. (Baylor Spears/Wisconsin Examiner)

Wisconsin voters approved about 55% of school referendum requests across the state — a majority passage rate that still marked a significant decline from previous years. Of 79 referendum questions on ballots last week, 44 referendum were approved and 35 failed.

In April, 61% of referendum requests passed. According to the Wisconsin Policy Forum, in 2024, there was a 70% approval rate; in 2022, there was an 80% approval rate; and in 2020, there was a 85% approval rate.

Schools have come to depend on ballot measures asking local property taxpayers to meet their costs including paying electric bills, building maintenance and program offerings as well as  providing pay and benefits to teachers and staff.

Wisconsin Public Education Network Executive Director Heather DuBois Bourenane called the results a “mixed bag.” 

“Green Bay desperately needed that referendum. Dodgeville, you know, had to go to referenda four times in order to pass one, and I mean the referendum they passed still leaves them in a pretty precarious fiscal situation, but at least they aren’t facing the same kind of cuts and shortfalls that they would have otherwise,” DuBois Bourenane said. “Most of them did pass, but the ones that didn’t are just gutting.” 

Schools in districts where  referendum requests failed she said, will be considering cuts to services and staff or consolidating schools or even dissolving their districts.

The latter option became a reality for one school district in Wisconsin right after the elections. 

The State Board approved a dissolution request for Hustisford School District in Dodge County. The tiny district had struggled financially in part due to a lack of state funding and repeated failed referendum requests. After the fifth failed referendum in April, it started the dissolution process.

State Superintendent Jill Underly said in a statement that dissolution “is a casualty of decades of an antiquated, broken school funding formula that has failed to keep pace with the costs of educating our children.” 

State support for public schools has declined dramatically over the last 15 years. Ahead of the election, 62% of Wisconsin public schools received notice from the state Department of Public Instruction that they would receive less aid for 2026-27 school year than in the prior year. The current state budget did not provide any increase in funding for 2026 or 2027.

Underly said in a statement that following Tuesday’s elections she is hopeful that the state is in a position to make “meaningful change” to the way Wisconsin funds its schools. 

“While I am optimistic about what the outcomes of yesterday’s election mean for the future of public education in Wisconsin, that optimism does not undermine the reality that too many communities are forced to make an unfair decision,” Underly said. “The school funding formula is broken, and it has failed our children, our schools, and entire communities for decades. Wisconsin’s public schools cannot continue to rely on referenda to provide the educational opportunities all students deserve.”

Underly said she looks forward to working with Wisconsin’s elected leaders as Democratic Gov.-elect David Crowley and members of a Democratic-controlled state Assembly and Senate prepare to take office.

“There’s just like a lot of energy right now about the possibility of a more democratic co-governance that could be possible,” DuBois Bourenane said. The Democrats who will lead state government “seem truly committed to listening to people and to delivering a budget that reflects their needs,” she said. “That’s something we haven’t seen in this state in a really long time. We can fix school funding for real. We can actually get to the root of the problem and set this course straight and undo the damage that’s been done in previous administrations.” 

Among the actions DuBois Bourenane hopes to see from the new administration and Legislature are the repeal of Wisconsin’s union-busting law, Act 10, and making the cost of the state’s school voucher program public on property taxpayers’ bills. She said Crowley and lawmakers could also get to work on funding issues before the next state budget, suggesting  that a bill to provide 60% funding to special education could be among the first that Crowley signs. 

“The fact that about half of the referend this all didn’t pass means we’re going to see a ton of referenda in the spring again, and we shouldn’t have to wait for another budget to go into action to help the schools that are struggling now,” she said. 

It’s unclear how fast Democrats plan to move on education funding. 

Crowley campaigned on increasing funding to the state’s public schools, including moving the state toward reimbursing districts for 90% of the cost of special education, but he has said that he would want to bring together a blue ribbon commission to examine Wisconsin’s taxation system, including the role of property taxes in school funding. 

Crowley is not the only Democratic leader to suggest there could be additional study on changes to school funding. 

Senate Democratic Leader Dianne Hesselbein (D-Middleton), who will likely become the next Senate majority leader, said in late September that Democrats will increase school funding in the next state budget, but added that though she said changing the state’s school funding formula could be a “multi-year” process.

“We’re also looking at a long-term goal of seeing what other states are doing and how they are funding their public schools,” she said. “But that’s going to take probably a multi-year task to try to figure that all out and talking to our friends in Minnesota, Michigan, Illinois.”

Crowley also said he supports repealing Act 10, but he wants his administration to look at the impact on taxes.

“We’re going to couple all of this with a blue ribbon commission bringing Democrats, Republicans, tax experts, local units of government, business leaders, as well as labor unions to the table to focus on that long-term fix,”  Crowley recently told WISN-12. “We know that there are going to be a lot of people who continue to attack our workers across the state of Wisconsin, but our job is to make sure that this is a place they can see a future that they can afford.” 

DuBois Bourenane was not enthusiastic about the idea of another blue ribbon commission on school funding, saying it is the “last thing” Wisconsin needs. 

“We know exactly what the problem is. There is no mystery here. There is no need for additional research. There is no need to study this problem further, we have been studying and documenting what the problem is for decades,” DuBois Bourenane said, noting that Crowley was in the Legislature during the last blue ribbon commission. 

The last bipartisan blue ribbon commission on school funding was conducted nearly 10 years ago and took two years to complete its work. It provided a slate of recommendations to address the issues in the school funding system including indexing per pupil funding to inflation. Many of the recommendations went unaddressed by the Republican-led state Legislature. 

“Those recommendations sit unfulfilled on a dusty shelf, and he could just blow the dust off of that and put those into action if he wants. Those are still good recommendations,” DuBois Bourenane said. “We need to do a lot more than piecemeal solutions. We need to really overhaul the school finding formula, and we know how to do that.”

Underly says it’s urgent to fix the school funding formula but timing will depend on the election

“The formula used for funding our schools, for years, has failed our children, schools and entire communities,” Underly said during her address. Underly speaks to reporters after delivering her sixth State of Education address. (Photo by Baylor Spears/Wisconsin Examiner)

Wisconsin State Superintendent Jill Underly called for the state to overhaul the school funding formula in her sixth State of Education address Thursday, saying that the state “simply cannot afford to wait any longer.” 

Underly delivered the address less than six weeks before the November election, when Wisconsin voters will decide who she will be working with in the governor’s office and in the state Legislature on the next state budget. She will need their support to get the funding for the budget proposals she has begun to formulate.

The Department of Public Instruction so far has only submitted the first part of its budget request, which covered funding for libraries, support for children who are deaf and blind, public libraries, cybersecurity, technology modernization and the investigation of alleged educator misconduct. The agency said last week that it would release the second part of its request, for “categorical aid programs and other critical supports” for Wisconsin’s public schools, in November. The election is scheduled for Nov. 3. 

“The formula used for funding our schools, for years, has failed our children, schools and entire communities,” Underly said during her address. “The reasons are varied and complex, but you don’t need to be familiar with every detail of the funding formula to know that it’s simply not working. The evidence is all around us.” 

More than 75 school referendum requests carrying a total cost of $1.5 billion will go before voters in November. It’s just the latest round in a now-familiar ritual as school districts across the state  seek approval to raise property taxes to make up for a shrinking pool of  state aid. School districts that can’t pass a referendum have had to cut costs including by eliminating programs, staff and in some cases closing or consolidating schools. Districts on a streak of failed referendum requests have faced dissolution. 

Underly noted that the classrooms of the Hustisford School District “sat empty” on the first day of school this year. The district started the dissolution process after its referendum failed in April.

“Every kid felt the impact,” Underly said. “Kindergarteners, who should have been walking through the doors of the school their family chose when they made this beautiful community home, instead traveled to a neighboring town. Meanwhile, seniors who spent the past 12 years as Hustisford Falcons started their last year of school in an unfamiliar building,” Underly continued. “This is what happens when we turn our back on our schools. And when schools close, the impact doesn’t stop with students. It ripples through entire communities.”

Underly said the state funding formula “places value on the wrong things,” including enrollment, district spending and property value, instead of on student needs. 

“It fails to ask the most essential question: How much does it actually cost to educate the students who live in a district so that they have an equal opportunity to succeed? A student’s opportunity for success should not depend on their zip code,” she said. 

School funding will depend on who’s in office. Republican candidate Tom Tiffany and Democratic candidate David Crowley are running to be governor and control of the state Senate and Assembly are up for grabs. 

Some lawmakers have argued that rather than increase funding for schools the state needs to explore more school consolidation given declining enrollment. Asked about when school closure is the appropriate answer to declining enrollment, Underly told reporters she thinks “it deserves some study and conversation to figure out what’s best for kids.”

Underly pointed to the 2019 bipartisan Blue Ribbon Commission while speaking to reporters. The commission, which was created by Assembly Speaker Robin Vos and then-Senate Majority Leader Scott Fitzgerald in 2017, developed a report offering ideas to address school funding issues, as a guiding document for what the state should be doing. She said that the reports showed that there are kids who need additional support including those in poverty and who have special needs. She said money also needs to be invested in career and technical education, mental health supports and speech and language pathology.

“All these things have been in my past budget requests, and that’s what we will be able to expect in the next one, too,” Underly said. The agency’s 2024 state budget request totaled over  $4 billion. 

Urgent, but possibly not very fast

While Underly delivered her message with urgency, the timeline for changes could look vastly different depending on who wins in November.

Senate Minority Leader Dianne Hesselbein (D-Middleton), who could become the Senate Majority leader depending on the results of the November elections, has said Democrats will increase school funding in the next state budget, but changing the state’s school funding formula could be a “multi-year” process. 

“We’re also looking at a long-term goal of seeing what other states are doing and how they are funding their public schools, but that’s going to take probably a multi-year task to try to figure that all out and talking to our friends in Minnesota, Michigan, Illinois,” Hesselbein said. 

Crowley has been supportive of increasing school funding, including moving the state toward reimbursing districts for 90% of the cost of special education, instead of the current rate of 38% , but he has also suggested throughout his campaign for governor that there may need to be another Blue Ribbon Commission to study tax issues including school and local government funding. The last Blue Ribbon Commission on school funding took two years to complete. 

Tiffany has said he wants some increases to school funding, but also promises to freeze property taxes if elected. He hasn’t provided clarity on how much he would invest or how he would balance the two issues. Tiffany has focused on issues of accountability and ensuring “high standards” as opposed to school funding when discussing education issues.

Underly has had a strained relationship with Republicans on the Joint Finance Committee, who have declined to invite her to testify in front of the committee, and it’s unclear whether a working relationship between her and Tiffany would be an improvement. Tiffany recently described the state superintendent’s position as a constitutional office as a “problem” at a Moms For Liberty Town Hall in Richfield. He said he would use the state budget, which determines the state’s spending for a two-year period, to try to steer the superintendent  to make the decisions he wants her to make.

Underly said responding to the comments that independence is positive.  

“When you think about my office, my office is nonpartisan. It’s independent. It is not at the whim of any governor and I think that actually strengthens public education,” Underly said. “I think his comments stand on their own.”

In her speech, Underly called for people to look at the candidates’ records on school issues, not their talking points, when making their decisions at the ballot box this November. 

“We have people running for office who have spent a decade or more in government, in positions to make school funding decisions — or who have left state government for another level and now want to return — whose records include repeatedly voting against investments in Wisconsin’s children,” Underly said, apparently referring to Tiffany, who as a state lawmaker served on the budget committee before he was elected to Congress. “Past actions are the best evidence we have of what someone will do when given power again. Wisconsin does not need more people who tell us they support children while their votes tell a different story. We need people in positions of decision-making power who are pro-public school, pro-child and pro-Wisconsin.” 

Middleton referendum discussion highlights tension between property taxes and school funding 

Bob Hesselbein and Middleton community members discuss the upcoming school referendum request that will appear on ballots. (Photo by Baylor Spears/Wisconsin Examiner)

Kate Murrain, a realtor and mother of two Middleton-Cross Plains School District students, said she has a couple of questions before she makes her mind up whether to vote for the district’s $118.5 million referendum request. 

Murrain told the Wisconsin Examiner that she wants to see a side-by-side comparison of budgets, one of if the referendum passes and one if it fails. Her questions reflect the competing concerns that surfaced in a recent public discussion of rising property taxes and the school district’s troubles meeting rising costs. 

“At this point, without any information and being as educated as I need to be I would vote no,” Murrain said, adding she noticed that the meeting was attended by a relatively small group of neighbors who appeared to be pro-referendum. “I was surprised. I expected to walk into 100 people having questions to get better educated. I’m just shocked that this is the turnout.”

Murrain was one of about 20 who gathered in the performing arts center of Middleton High School on Sept. 17 to listen to district leaders explain the request and take questions. The district is holding at least four of these sessions open to the public leading up to the Nov. 3 election.

Middleton’s request is part of a wave of more than 70 school district referendum requests this fall seeking $1.6 billion in support from property taxpayers. Under Wisconsin’s school funding system, there is a cap on how much school districts can bring in through a combination of state aid and property taxes. To exceed the caps, Wisconsin school districts have to go to voters for approval. 

Among the requests 17 are for one-time building costs, eight are recurring, to provide permanent support for operating costs, and the remaining are non-recurring, slated to help with operating costs but for a set number of years.

By the end of the year, the total number of referendum requests appearing on spring and fall ballots will total more than 150. Eight of the school districts asking voters for more money in November are trying for the second time this year after a spring request failed. 

In April, 75 referendum requests went before voters. According to the Wisconsin Policy Forum, 46 of those passed — a 61.3% approval rate. The Policy Forum found that a similar result in November would represent “a substantial decrease from the 70.1% approval rate in 2024” and the “lowest approval rate of any even-numbered year since 2010, when voters approved 52.7% of referenda.”

The Middleton-Cross Plains School District request is the second largest referendum ask  on ballots in November behind Green Bay Area School District, which is seeking $158 million over four years and is currently a party in a lawsuit suing the state over the school funding formula.

Middleton is considered “property rich,” meaning it gets less state aid than other school districts and relies more heavily on property taxes for its budget. According to school leaders, about 80% of the district budget comes from property taxes. The other 20% comes from state aid. 

The request would be split to provide $24.9 million in year one of the referendum. That amount would continue the funding the district is currently receiving through a 2022 nonrecurring referendum. The next three years the funding would rise by about 3% each year to account for inflation, so $27.9 million in year two, $31.1 million in year three and $34.6 million in year four.

Bob Hesselbein, the school board president, told the Examiner that the district considered about six different referendum scenarios.

“Like a lot of districts within Wisconsin since 2010, we have been forced to find operational funding with our own community because the state each year is giving us in real dollars less in buying power,” Hesselbein said. “We recognize with the economics going on now in the country, we didn’t want to ask for more because everyone’s hurting.”

The district conducted surveys while working to develop the question. In one survey of about 1,800 community members, 66% said that they would probably or definitely vote for a 2026 referendum. Those who opposed the referendum cited property-tax fatigue, spending reductions and a preference for state level solutions. 

Hesselbein said the district hasn’t had a “No Vote” committee form. In other districts, “No Vote” and “Yes Vote” committees will form and can come into contention with one another as residents concerned about rising property taxes are pitted against those who want their schools to be able to meet costs.

One attendee at the recent meeting in Middleton asked for clarification on the actual cost to individual taxpayers of the referendum and said he was worried about how the additional taxes would affect seniors on a fixed income.

An explanatory page provided by the district shows that property taxpayers could expect to pay no additional money in the first year, $21 in the second, $40 in the third and $59 in the fourth. However, the numbers are pegged to $100,000 of property. The district said it provided the information in the form it did so individuals could do the math easily depending on the cost of the house. 

“Who has a $100,000 house in Middleton?” the attendee said. “I’d rather see the average house in there, so people can get a feel as to what you’re looking at.” 

The average cost of a house is $500,000 in Middleton, meaning in the second year of the budget an average homeowner could expect to pay an additional $105 in property taxes in the second year of the referendum.

“You’re going to be squeezing me,” the attendee said. “You want to keep everything status quo. There’s room to cut.” 

If the referendum fails the district will have to cut its budget by about 20%. 

Whether the referendum passes or not, the district plans to cut $5 million from its budget, though conversations are just beginning on where those cuts will come from. 

“We’re going to probably find ourselves cutting some of the enhancements to education, not the meat of what we do here,” Hesselbein told the Examiner, adding that it likely wouldn’t mean layoffs, but retirements may mean conversations about dividing work among current employees instead of a new hire. 

The same retiree who spoke up about the cost of the referendum asked why the district wasn’t turning to state lawmakers. 

“I called Sen. [Dianne] Hesselbein’s office last year, and asked, what have you done to get more money?” he said. “I got the typical political run around.”

Gov. Tony Evers and Republican lawmakers tried to pass a deal earlier this year that would have tapped the state surplus to give schools some additional funding and send rebate checks to property taxpayers. The bill failed in the Senate, where most Democrats opposed it, saying it didn’t do enough to help schools or spend money responsibly, along with a couple of Republicans, who opposed the spending. 

Since then, progress on school funding changes have been stalled as most politicians have turned their attention to the upcoming elections. 

Bob Hesselbein, who is married to the Democratic leader of the Senate, said he had some inside information for the disgruntled taxpayer at the Middleton meeting.

“I happen to know Sen. Hesselbein pretty well,” he said, drawing a few chuckles in the room. 

“You can yell and swear all you want,” he added. “In Dane County, we have very pro-education representation in both our Assembly and our Senate. Unfortunately, they’re a minority within the state of Wisconsin, and until the rest of the cities, Wisconsin, come to that realization that their public schools are being damaged, we can’t expect anything different from our local politicians, because that’s the constitutional laws of our state.”

Sen. Hesselbein has said that Democrats will pass legislation to fund public schools in January. 

“We are going to be fully there for our public schools, especially when it comes to special education reimbursement,” Sen. Dianne Hesselbein said at a press conference last week. “One thing that school administrators are telling us all across the state — principals as well — that they want to see something they can count on and they want to rely on it.” 

Sen. Hesselbein said that her caucus has started having conversations over the summer about what needs to happen, including putting more money into special education and general aid. She said Democrats are also looking at other states to understand how the school funding formula could be changed.

“We’re also looking at a long-term goal of seeing what other states are doing and how they are funding their public schools, but that’s going to take probably a multi-year task to try to figure that all out and talking to our friends in Minnesota, Michigan, Illinois,” Hesselbein said. 

Meanwhile, school districts continue to rely on taxpayers to help them meet costs. 

Jim Coursey, treasurer of the Middleton school board, explained the stakes to Murrain. 

“If we were to lose that 20% of the budget, there will be no question that classrooms will be impacted, that’s too much,” Coursey said. “That’s going to lead to larger class sizes because it’s going to lead to a reduction in the number of staff that we’re going to be able to have supporting. It’s going to lead to elimination of programs.” 

Murrain, who said she values the education her children are receiving, remained unconvinced.

“I don’t know, it’s tough… I would need to see exactly where those funds are being allocated,” she said.

❌