❌

Reading view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.

Trump’s DOJ ends California suit over suspected noncitizen voters after midterm losses

San Francisco sheriffs walk past voting booths at City Hall on Nov. 3, 2026 in San Francisco, California.  (Photo by Benjamin Fanjoy/Getty Images)

San Francisco sheriffs walk past voting booths at City Hall on Nov. 3, 2026 in San Francisco, California.  (Photo by Benjamin Fanjoy/Getty Images)

The U.S. Department of Justice is dismissing a lawsuit that tried to force California to set aside the ballots of suspected noncitizen voters, marking the formal end of the Trump administration’s most aggressive effort to control vote counting in the lead-up to the midterm elections.

The Justice Department filed a notice in court Friday night that it was abandoning the lawsuit. The decision ended what had been a dramatic weeks-long battle between the federal government and state and local election officials over control of California’s elections.

The filing came less than a week after the U.S. Supreme Court, hours before Election Day, ruled against an emergency request by the Justice Department — and after Republicans suffered crushing electoral losses nationwide. President Donald Trump will enter the final two years of his term facing a Congress controlled by Democrats.

Ballots from 20,000 people

The DOJ had asked the Supreme Court to stop election officials from processing and counting ballots from roughly 20,000 people the Trump administration suspected were noncitizens. The justices instead quickly rejected the request in a one-sentence order.

While the Supreme Court rebuffed the Justice Department, a federal judge in California had scheduled a hearing for Nov. 13 that would have given the Trump administration another chance at an order requiring election officials to set aside the ballots. 

The hearing, which may have included witnesses, would have potentially revealed new information about how the list was developed. California election officials had heavily criticized the accuracy of the list, which was compiled by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security.

In the Friday court filing, Assistant U.S. Attorney Julie A. Hamill wrote that the Justice Department was dropping the lawsuit because by Nov. 13, ballots from individuals on the list would be “commingled” with other ballots.

“There is then no way to get the challenged ballots segregated,” Hamill wrote.

Bill Essayli, first assistant U.S. attorney for the Central District of California, wrote on social media that the Justice Department’s efforts “to restore confidence and integrity in elections continue.”

“We will pursue every civil and criminal remedy to ensure only eligible American citizens vote in American elections,” Essayli wrote.

Californians defend ‘well-defined standards’

Dean Logan, the top election official in Los Angeles County, which had been sued by the Justice Department, in a statement said he welcomed the dismissal of the lawsuit. As Los Angeles County’s registrar-recorder/county clerk, Logan’s office had warned that setting aside the ballots could throw the election into chaos and effectively halt ballot counting.

Lawyers for California and Los Angeles County had emphasized during the lawsuit that noncitizen voting is illegal under state law and the state takes preventive measures. Voters must sign their ballot envelopes and those signatures are checked by election workers. Voters must also attest under penalty of perjury that they are U.S. citizens.

“At each stage of this election, and in response to the Department of Justice, we have been clear that state and federal law sets well-defined standards for verifying and challenging voter eligibility,” Logan said.

The lawsuit against California had been one in a series of steps taken by the Trump administration ahead of Election Day aimed at asserting power over elections, which are run by states under the U.S. Constitution.

Homeland Security has arrested dozens of noncitizens over alleged election crimes in recent weeks. And DHS conducted election-related field operations that were temporarily paused by a federal judge over concerns that they were intimidating naturalized citizens.

The Justice Department sent federal grand jury subpoenas to election officials in Los Angeles County and raised the prospect that election officials would face prosecution if they tabulated the ballots of noncitizens. A federal judge issued an order prohibiting the DOJ from threatening election workers, but the order was paused by the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.

Legal action in more states

The Justice Department preemptively sued Alaska over the certification of its U.S. Senate race. Trump said he ordered the action, angry that the ballot included a candidate with the same name as Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan. A federal judge tossed the lawsuit.

As of Monday, the race remained too close to call, with Democrat Mary Peltola holding a lead of a few hundred votes.

The DOJ also demanded Washington state set aside the ballots of about 400 people it alleged were suspected noncitizens. A federal judge issued an order preventing the DOJ from forcing the state to comply.

Day before election, Trump’s DOJ asks US Supreme Court to rule in California voting case

The U.S. Department of Justice logo is displayed on a speaker’s podium. (Photo by Seth Tupper/South Dakota Searchlight)

The U.S. Department of Justice logo is displayed on a speaker’s podium. (Photo by Seth Tupper/South Dakota Searchlight)

The U.S. Department of Justice on Monday asked the U.S. Supreme Court to require California to set aside the ballots of suspected noncitizen voters in a last-ditch appeal by the Trump administration to exert control over the state’s vote counting.

The request came on the eve of Election Day and as more than 5 million mail ballots have already been cast in California, a state where voters are expected to elect dozens of Democrats to the U.S. House.

California’s election could be thrown into chaos if the Supreme Court grants the request. State and local election officials have previously warned that they have no easy way to quickly identify and set aside the ballots of individuals on the list.

In the Trump administration’s emergency application, U.S. Solicitor General D. John Sauer noted that federal law prohibits voting by noncitizens, who still do sometimes vote “despite that prohibition,” he wrote. 

“Once California commingles the challenged ballots with lawful ones, there is no way to get the challenged ballots back,” Sauer added.

Logistically difficult

As a universal vote-by-mail state, every voter in California is sent a mail ballot. While millions of these ballots have already been returned, millions more may be dropped off on Tuesday or arrive by mail in the coming days.

Aman Bhullar, an assistant Los Angeles County registrar-recorder/county clerk, warned in a court declaration in October that the Trump administration’s request could wreak havoc on elections.

“The potential consequences of implementing DOJ’s demand are severe and range from halting all counting; halting in-person voters’ ability to cast votes; or otherwise interfering with the ability to accurately count votes,” Bhullar wrote.

Already a week ago, Shelby Wayment, staff attorney at the University of California, Los Angeles Safeguarding Democracy Project, questioned the feasibility of the DOJ’s demands. Ballots have already been mailed out and were being processed, she said.

“Just logistically, I don’t think it’s possible at this point,” Wayment said in a late October interview.

No widespread fraud

The Justice Department sued California in October, alleging that the U.S. Department of Homeland Security had identified 20,000 suspected noncitizen voters. California officials raised concerns about the veracity of the list, and declined to take action based on it.

An immigrant rights group, the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights, has raised serious concerns about the list after a judge forced the Trump administration to share a copy with the organization. 

The group said in a court filing Saturday that an analysis by data experts found that 42% of the names weren’t found on California’s current voter file. At least 22 names on the list match names of U.S. citizens compiled by the organization, the analysis found.

“There is no widespread voter fraud. The federal government has no right to interfere in California’s elections,” California Attorney General Rob Bonta, a Democrat, said in a statement on Saturday.

11th hour challenge

The Justice Department has said the Department of Homeland Security compiled the list by checking a public copy of California’s voter file against federal records and information from the research service Lexis Nexis.

A district court judge and the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals have both ruled against the Trump administration in the case. State and local officials have argued the Justice Department exceeded its authority because states administer elections under the U.S. Constitution.

Even though the 9th Circuit issued a decision on Friday, the Justice Department didn’t ask the Supreme Court to intervene until midday Monday, less than 24 hours before Election Day. 

The Justice Department has asked for an administrative stay that would require California to begin segregating ballots of voters on the list while the Trump administration prepares a full appeal. While it’s unknown how the Supreme Court will rule, in general the justices frown on federal courts ordering major last-minute changes to elections.

Because the case arises out of the 9th Circuit, Justice Elena Kagan, one of the court’s three liberals, will be the first to review the application.

Walter Olsen, a senior fellow at the Cato Institute’s Robert A. Levy Center for Constitutional Studies, in a statement predicted the Supreme Court will reject the request. He argued that the Justice Department is asking California officials to violate their own state laws.

“The Supreme Court should and I believe will reject the administration’s nervy last-minute attempts to meddle in California’s elections, as lower courts have rejected them,” Olsen said.

Trump loses appeals over California ballots, Homeland Security operations

Election workers sort ballots at an election operations facility in Martinez, California, on May 27, 2026, ahead of California's statewide primary election. (Photo by Benjamin Fanjoy/Getty Images)

Election workers sort ballots at an election operations facility in Martinez, California, on May 27, 2026, ahead of California's statewide primary election. (Photo by Benjamin Fanjoy/Getty Images)

A federal appeals court on Friday denied a Trump administration demand that California set aside and not count the ballots of 20,000 suspected noncitizen voters, setting the stage for a possible appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

A three-judge panel of the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against a U.S. Department of Justice request for an emergency order that would have required state and local election officials to not tabulate the ballots of voters on a list developed by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security unless they could prove their citizenship.

A separate 9th Circuit panel on Friday also denied a Justice Department request to allow Homeland Security to restart election-related field operations that could sweep up U.S. citizens. Civil rights groups had warned the operations put naturalized citizens at risk of disenfranchisement.

The rulings marked the third and fourth courtroom losses in less than a week for President Donald Trump’s administration in its 11th-hour legal campaign to assert authority over elections, which under the U.S. Constitution are administered by states.

“Exercising the power endowed to it by the Constitution, California comprehensively administers its elections, including by regulating voter eligibility,” the panel wrote in an unsigned majority opinion over California’s ballot counting.

The Justice Department in October provided California election officials with a list of approximately 20,000 individuals that it said were likely noncitizens registered to vote in the state. The DOJ cited a federal misdemeanor crime against noncitizen voting in demanding their ballots be set aside.

The DOJ says Homeland Security compiled the list after obtaining a public copy of California’s voter roll and checking it against government records and information from the LexisNexis research service. Officials in California and Los Angeles County have questioned the list’s accuracy and warned against relying on it to prevent the tabulation of ballots.

The Trump administration has gone to extraordinary lengths to pressure California election officials to set aside the ballots. 

It sued just 48 hours after giving election officials the list of 20,000 voters and since then, DOJ lawyers have raised the possibility that state and local officials could face criminal prosecution if they count the ballots of noncitizens. Grand jury subpoenas have been sent to election officials in Los Angeles County.

Risks ‘uncertain,’ panel says

The appeals court’s decision in the California ballots case upheld a ruling from Judge David Carter, an appointee of President Bill Clinton in U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, against the Justice Department. In a blistering decision, Carter wrote that the Trump administration was attempting to coerce California that evidence existed of federal interference.

Carter also echoed concerns raised by election officials over the origin of the list. The 9th Circuit panel voiced similar worries in its Friday decision and said the Justice Department request risks disenfranchising voters.

“There is a public interest in maintaining the integrity of elections,” the opinion says. “But as discussed, the district court found that the risks that noncitizens are voting are, at best, uncertain, and also tempered by California’s established voter-eligibility procedures.”

The 9th Circuit also previously rejected a preemptive appeal filed by the Justice Department.

Appellate Judge Patrick Bumatay, a Trump appointee, wrote in a dissent that he would have granted the Justice Department’s request. He wrote that the DOJ was seeking “limited relief” and that the federal government and the states can work together.

“California decided long ago that aliens can’t vote in its elections. Today, the federal government merely seeks to safeguard that decision. We should have let them try,” Bumatay wrote.

The Justice Department didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment and a question about whether it would appeal.

“Every day, more ballots are processed by election officials. This ongoing emergency disenfranchises American citizens through dilution,” Bill Essayli, first assistant U.S. attorney for the Central District of California, said in an earlier statement.

California Attorney General Rob Bonta, a Democrat, said in a social media post that the Trump administration’s three court losses over the past week make clear it has “zero authority to interfere in California’s elections.”

DHS election-related operations blocked

Another 9th Circuit panel on Friday affirmed a district court judge’s decision prohibiting DHS from conducting operations that could sweep up U.S. citizens. The prohibition applies in California, Connecticut, Georgia, Missouri, Nevada, New York, Pennsylvania, Washington and Wisconsin until polls close on Election Day.

A Homeland Security Investigations internal memo dated Aug. 31 describes a “surge initiative” beginning Sept. 1 that includes conducting field interviews. The memo, which was filed in court, identifies those states as targets of the surge during September. Additional locations are redacted in the document.

In an unsigned opinion, the panel questioned the Trump administration’s timing in pursuing a surge in voter fraud enforcement just before Election Day. The federal law enforcement activity is ostensibly focused on past voter fraud, the judges wrote, meaning that DHS had more than a year to pursue investigations before the pre-election period.

“The Federal Defendants have not indicated why restrictions on the Surge now prevent them from conducting these operations,” the panel wrote. “Nor have they explained why an injunction enjoining specific aspects of the Surge through Election Day causes irreparable harm when implementation of the Initiative can resume on November 4, 2026” — the day after Election Day.

The original lawsuit was filed by San Francisco, Santa Clara, the California Nurses Association, National Nurses United and the Voto Latino Foundation. They alleged voters, especially naturalized citizens, are at risk of intimidation and fear they could be wrongly targeted, the groups warned.

“Last week, the district court held that DHS’s frantic, last-minute voter investigations are unlawful voter intimidation. Today, the government’s attempt to restart that campaign failed,” Beau Tremitiere, a lawyer at Protect Democracy, said in a statement.

“This was one more desperate attempt by the Trump administration to interfere in the midterm elections, and the courts have again said no.”

Supreme Court next?

How the Supreme Court would rule if the Justice Department appeals either of these cases is unknown. 

Conservatives hold six of its nine seats. The majority upended the electoral landscape earlier this year when it sharply weakened federal protections against racial gerrymandering, paving the way for Southern states to quickly redraw their congressional maps to favor Republicans.

But the Supreme Court has generally held that federal courts shouldn’t order dramatic changes just ahead of elections. For example, in September the justices repeatedly rejected requests to overturn a Missouri Supreme Court decision blocking a GOP gerrymander.

In the California ballots case, the 9th Circuit panel majority — which included Judge Mark Bennett, a Trump appointee, and Judge Gabriel Sanchez, an appointee of President Joe Biden — invoked that principle in denying the Trump administration’s request.

“Major concerns remain that granting the United States’s requested relief might … harm the public interest by risking the disenfranchisement of eligible voters and putting the entire tabulation process in jeopardy,” they wrote.

Trump’s DOJ threatens ‘criminal liability’ for California officials in vote counting suit

An election worker processes mail-in ballots for the California primary election at the Los Angeles County Ballot Processing Center on June 5, 2026 in City of Industry, California. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

An election worker processes mail-in ballots for the California primary election at the Los Angeles County Ballot Processing Center on June 5, 2026 in City of Industry, California. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

The U.S. Department of Justice in a federal court hearing Tuesday warned California election officials could be prosecuted if they count ballots cast by noncitizen voters, in a case brought by the Trump administration demanding that the state set aside the ballots of 20,000 suspected noncitizen voters.

The remark by a DOJ lawyer about “criminal liability” for election officials who process ballots drew a sharp rebuke from the judge presiding over the hearing.

“This court believes it would be wise — it would be wise that any threats to the state, county elected employees cease immediately,” Judge David Carter said from the bench.

The extraordinary argument from DOJ came as President Donald Trump’s last-minute push to assert authority over voting encounters skepticism and resistance from federal judges less than a week before Election Day. Trump faces political defeat if Republicans lose one or both chambers of Congress in the midterm elections.

Carter, an appointee of former President Bill Clinton in U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, held the hearing in the Justice Department’s lawsuit that seeks to force California election officials to segregate and not count ballots from the list of 20,000 unless they can prove their citizenship. 

Carter adjourned an hours-long hearing in Los Angeles by promising a decision Wednesday. Before adjourning, Carter urged the Justice Department to drop the menacing rhetoric.

Possibly heading to Supreme Court

Carter’s ruling — whatever he decides — will almost certainly be appealed to the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals and, possibly, the U.S. Supreme Court. A three-judge panel of the appeals court has already ruled against the Justice Department once in the case.

During the hearing, Bill Essayli, the first assistant U.S. attorney for the Central District of California, raised the prospect that election officials could be criminally exposed if they move forward with counting the ballots.

“What they cannot do is knowingly count ballots when they have specific information that these individuals are noncitizens. That they cannot do,” Essayli said, adding that “they would be criminally liable if they knowingly process a ballot of a noncitizen. They would have the same criminal liability of the person who voted.”

Anne Bellows, a lawyer for California Secretary of State Shirley Weber, a Democrat, said that even though the Justice Department refers to the list as “likely” noncitizens, the court heard Essayli “threaten elections officials with criminal prosecution if they tabulate the ballots of those on this list.”

Christopher Pelham, a lawyer for Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk Dean Logan, said the prospect that state and local election officials could face federal “trouble” for processing ballots “is chilling for them.”

List of suspected noncitizens

Earlier this month, the Justice Department provided a list of 20,000 California voters it said were suspected noncitizens and gave state and local officials 48 hours to review. When state and local election officials refused to act immediately, the DOJ sued to force election officials to segregate ballots from those voters and not count them unless they could prove their citizenship.

Carter appeared to signal he is skeptical of the Justice Department’s emergency request. At one point, he suggested he was inclined to set a hearing within the next couple weeks — likely after the election — for a deeper exploration of how the list of 20,000 people was compiled and its reliability. 

He indicated that would give time for a fuller examination of the issues at play but wrap up before Dec. 3, when California officials must certify election results.

Court documents filed by the Justice Department indicate the U.S. Department of Homeland Security developed the list based on a public California voter roll the agency obtained. 

In a court declaration filed Monday, Nicolas Bartelli, associate director of the Fraud Detection and National Security Directorate at U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, a sub-agency of DHS, wrote that the agency “enhanced” the voter data using the research service LexisNexis.

‘The stakes here are enormous’

Essayli told the court that the Justice Department’s case would rise and fall on the credibility of the evidence. He said that once California officials were informed about the likely noncitizen voters, they must act.

“It means something to be a United States citizen. It means something to participate in an election,” Essayli said. “We want to make sure those interests are safeguarded.”

Lawyers for Weber and Logan sharply criticized the Justice Department’s arguments during the hearing. They voiced deep reservations over how the list was compiled and cast the DOJ’s move as an encroachment on California’s authority to run its elections.

The U.S. Constitution assigns states the responsibility of administering elections. Congress can override state rules and regulations, but the executive branch has no unilateral power to intervene absent authority from Congress.

The DOJ has pointed to a federal misdemeanor crime against noncitizen voting as justification for segregating ballots. 

But attorneys for the election officials argued the prohibition doesn’t preempt California’s state election laws, which also include a ban on noncitizen voting. Voters in California must attest under penalty of perjury they are a citizen and qualified to vote.

Bellows described the consequences in the case as sweeping. Los Angeles County election officials have written in court declarations that segregating ballots would lead to potentially “catastrophic” problems.

“The stakes here are enormous,” Bellows said, arguing that the DOJ’s demand risks disenfranchising voters.

Trump thwarted in hunt for rare noncitizen voters as midterms near

Voters fill out ballots using touch screens during early voting at the Bismarck Event Center in Bismarck, North Dakota, on June 8, 2026. (Photo by Michael Achterling/North Dakota Monitor)

Voters fill out ballots using touch screens during early voting at the Bismarck Event Center in Bismarck, North Dakota, on June 8, 2026. (Photo by Michael Achterling/North Dakota Monitor)

Five weeks before Election Day, President Donald Trump’s sprawling effort to identify and remove noncitizen voters hasn’t produced the kind of large purges that could meaningfully affect the midterm elections.

Even a recent U.S. Supreme Court decision giving states access to a supercharged Department of Homeland Security computer program to verify voters’ citizenship will have a limited immediate impact, election experts say. 

As Republicans fight to retain control of Congress, Trump and his allies have spent the past year aggressively seeking to root out noncitizen voting. 

They have called into question the security of the upcoming elections, following the lead of the president, who has long made spurious claims of voter fraud to dismiss unfavorable results.

Those efforts are now colliding with federal law — and the reality long shown by studies and available data that noncitizen voting is rare.

Little impact seen from court ruling

The Supreme Court on Sept. 25 ruled in a 6-3 decision that states can access Homeland Security’s SAVE system, which draws upon citizenship information stored across the federal government to scour voter rolls in the hunt for possible noncitizens. A district court judge had blocked the program in June.

But the high court’s decision came during a quiet period under the National Voter Registration Act that prohibits most states from conducting mass purges of voters in the 90 days before a federal election. 

The timing limits election officials to only searching for information on individual voters, even though Homeland Security has touted SAVE to states as a tool that can quickly scan millions of names.

The Supreme Court’s conservative majority acknowledged as much, writing in its unsigned opinion that the quiet period “limits the potential impact” of the court’s decision. 

Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, writing for the court’s three liberals, agreed the decision would have minimal short-term effects but argued the possibility of disenfranchising even a few lawful voters outweighed any risk of harm to the government.

David Becker, executive director of the nonpartisan Center for Election Innovation & Research, in a statement emphasized that voters will continue to experience the same safe, secure and reliable voting process this year as in the past.

“This decision will not have any significant impact on the 2026 election, as systematic voter list maintenance is prohibited within 90 days of a federal election, which the Supreme Court explicitly confirmed,” Becker said.

Post-2026

The more significant fallout from the Supreme Court’s decision may come in the weeks and months after the election, when states can once again remove large numbers of voters from their rolls. 

The Supreme Court is also set to hold oral arguments in December in a case that involves the reach of the National Voter Registration’s Act’s quiet period — leaving open the possibility the justices could give states more leeway to purge voters ahead of elections.

But for now, the restrictions remain in place.

“Until the Supreme Court says, reinterprets otherwise, the quiet period is still the quiet period,” Aaron Blacksberg, federal policy counsel at the Institute for Responsive Government, said in an interview.

Separately, a U.S. district court judge on Monday blocked the Trump administration’s efforts to require states to use SAVE as a condition of receiving some Federal Emergency Management Agency grants. Judge Amir H. Ali, an appointee of President Joe Biden, wrote that FEMA exceeded its authority in imposing election-related requirements.

Is the data reliable?

SAVE’s critics, which include Democrats and privacy advocates, warn that the system relies on incomplete and sometimes outdated data, resulting in false positives. SAVE was previously used to check whether noncitizens were eligible for various government benefits before the Trump administration last year repurposed it into a tool to check citizenship.

When U.S. District Judge Sparkle Sooknanan, a President Joe Biden appointee for a district court based in Washington, D.C., ruled against the program in June, she highlighted sworn declarations by naturalized citizens that Texas had threatened to revoke their voter registrations because of inaccurate Social Security data in SAVE.

“SAVE was never designed to verify citizenship: it relies on outdated and inaccurate data that produces false matches, risks disenfranchising eligible voters, and exposes sensitive personal information to misuse and bad actors,” Tim Harper, a project lead focused on elections and democracy at the Center for Democracy & Technology, a nonpartisan organization focused on civil liberties in the digital age, said in a statement.

The Trump administration and some Republicans hail SAVE as a powerful tool to ensure the accuracy of voter rolls and identify noncitizens who shouldn’t be registered to vote. They note that its use by states is voluntary.

“It’s remarkable that we had to file an emergency petition in the Supreme Court just so we can use government data to stop noncitizens from voting illegally. American elections are for Americans,” James Percival, Homeland Security’s general counsel, said in a statement.

In an email to States Newsroom, White House spokeswoman Lauren Bis faulted Democrats for not voting for the SAVE America Act, a bill that would require voters to produce documents proving their citizenship before voting. The bill has stalled in the U.S. Senate amid bipartisan opposition.

“The American people overwhelmingly support this commonsense legislation that enacts basic election security measures like voter ID and ensures only Americans are electing America’s leaders. President Trump is absolutely right: we fix this now, or we lose our country,” Bis said..

How many instances of noncitizen voting?

The Trump administration’s intense focus on noncitizen voting — which also includes a legal effort to force states to turn over voter data to the Department of Justice — contrasts with the extremely rare nature of noncitizen voting, according to past studies and election experts.

The U.S. Census in August identified about 24,000 instances of noncitizen voting in the 2020 election out of roughly 160 million votes cast, or 0.015% of all votes. One study of the 2016 election placed the prevalence of noncitizen voting at 0.0001% of votes cast.

But Homeland Security has suggested large numbers of noncitizens may be registered to vote. In July, the department said it had identified over 250,000 potential noncitizens on the voter rolls in California, New Jersey, Nevada and Pennsylvania.

On Monday, U.S. Senate Democrats in a letter to Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin wrote that they couldn’t trust those numbers. For instance, DHS initially floated nearly 16,000 possible noncitizen voters in Nevada. In the end, the agency provided state officials with a list of 185 people that officials said were noncitizens. All turned out to be citizens.

“Federal law already prohibits noncitizens from voting in federal elections, and every eligible voter across America has the right to cast a ballot — and should be able to do so without fear of being wrongly purged from the voting rolls,” Sen. Dick Durbin, an Illinois Democrat, said in a statement following the Supreme Court’s decision.

The alleged scale of potential noncitizen voter registration by Homeland Security also doesn’t match the scope of the agency’s law enforcement actions. Earlier in September, Homeland Security Investigations, a DHS agency, reported making 160 recent arrests from 1,600 open voter fraud cases.

When noncitizens do end up on voter rolls, administrative errors are sometimes to blame. In July, New Jersey Gov. Mikie Sherrill, a Democrat, announced that a software glitch caused about 6,600 noncitizens to become registered to vote and that about 400 had cast ballots. 

And in April, then-Texas Secretary of State Jane Nelson, a Republican, wrote in a letter to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services that some noncitizens had been registered to vote because of a clerical error despite acknowledging on a voter application that they weren’t U.S. citizens.

“That is why we urge voter registrars to use all available sources to confirm a person’s citizenship status — including SAVE data and other information about the registrant — when they are investigating whether the person is eligible to be a registered voter,” Nelson wrote in an email obtained by Democracy Forward, a pro-democracy legal organization.

❌