❌

Normal view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.
Today — 21 November 2026Wisconsin Examiner

Community looking for answers after DA declines to charge officer who shot Corey Ruiz

21 November 2026 at 02:09
Protesters gather at the intersection of Williamson and Baldwin streets in Madison in remembrance of Corey Ruiz. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

Protesters gather at the intersection of Williamson and Baldwin streets in Madison on Thursday, Nov. 19, in remembrance of Corey Ruiz. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

The decision Thursday by Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne not to charge Madison police officer Keil Baitinger-Peterson for fatally shooting 38-year-old Corey Ruiz in Madison in July drew passionate responses from the community and calls for systemic change. 

Attorney Ben Crump, who is representing the Ruiz family, said video depicting the shooting “cries out for a civil rights lawsuit.” But families bringing such cases in Wisconsin face an uphill battle in court. Meanwhile, local residents are navigating a crisis in trust in local government and in one another.

The Wisconsin Examiner’s Criminal Justice Reporting Project shines a light on incarceration, law enforcement and criminal justice issues with support from the Public Welfare Foundation.

Widely circulated video depicting the shooting was captured by bystanders using their phones in the early afternoon on July 22. Madison police officers do not have body cameras. Dash camera video from a Madison police car also shows Ruiz struggling with several officers in the middle of the intersection, causing a traffic backup. One of the officers used a taser on Ruiz. Then, while Ruiz was on the ground, Baitinger-Peterson fired three shots to Ruiz’s chest and head. Officers had pursued Ruiz after receiving reports of bicycle thefts and a burglary. 

Before firing, according to an investigative file by the Wisconsin DOJ’s Division of Criminal Investigation, Baitinger-Peterson claimed that he heard another officer tell Ruiz to “drop the knife or you’ll be shot in the head.” Baitinger-Peterson’s DCI interview was the only officer interview which described this warning.

Baitinger-Peterson and the other officers said that the knife made them fear for their own safety and that of their colleagues.

After Baintinger-Peterson fired, other officers immediately stepped away from Ruiz. One of the officers appeared to cover her mouth in shock. Baitinger-Peterson dropped to his knees and continued searching and restraining a motionless Ruiz. Baitinger-Peterson later said that Ruiz had a knife, which was photographed at the scene by investigator.

Use of force questioned

“There is nothing in the videos the district attorney showed us that justifies this officer stepping back, pulling his gun, and firing three shots at point-blank range at Corey Ruiz after he had been tased and was on the ground, hitting him once in the chest and with the kill shot to his head,” Crump said during a press conference after the charging decision was announced. “The medical examiner told the family that if the officer had not fired that shot to his head, Corey would have survived. It was clearly an excessive use of force. This police killing in Madison, Wisconsin, was unjustifiable, unreasonable, unnecessary, and unconstitutional.”

“The video of Corey’s killing is deeply troubling and raises serious questions about the force used against him,” Gov.-elect David Crowley said in a statement. “I recognize the pain and frustration many people are feeling following the District Attorney’s decision, especially in communities of color that have watched similar tragedies unfold for generations.” 

Protesters gather at the intersection of Williamson and Baldwin streets in Madison in remembrance of Corey Ruiz. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)
Signs at the intersection of Williamson and Baldwin streets in Madison on Thursday, Nov. 19, (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

“People have every right to be upset and to make their voices heard,” Crowley continued. “I encourage the community to continue speaking out and demanding answers, but to do so peacefully. More violence will not bring Corey back or change the District Attorney’s decision. It will only add to the pain of a community already carrying so much. As Wisconsin’s first Black governor-elect, I understand that these incidents are part of a much longer history that has left generations of Americans questioning whether our justice system values their lives equally and whether law enforcement officers are held to the same standards as everyone else.”

Other elected officials also released statements on the charging decision Thursday. “The death of Corey Ruiz this past summer has deeply affected our community, and I recognize the strong emotions surrounding the District Attorney’s decision,” said Dane County Executive Melissa Agard. “Corey’s life mattered, and my heart remains with his family and loved ones as they continue to grieve. They deserve our grace and compassion during this difficult time. We must continue working toward safer communities and a justice system that is effective and fair for all. I have faith in our community’s ability to express its emotions and convictions passionately and peacefully, while treating one another with respect.”

Protesters gather at the intersection of Williamson and Baldwin streets in Madison in remembrance of Corey Ruiz. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)
Protesters at the intersection of Williamson and Baldwin streets  (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

“The people calling for justice for Corey Ruiz know the truth: that he should still be alive today,” said Sen Dora Drake (D-Milwaukee), who will serve as the next president pro tempore of the state Senate and chair of the Legislative Black Caucus. “Since this summer, there were millions of views online of people watching multiple Madison Police Officers hold Mr. Ruiz down before one officer chose to shoot him from point-blank range. The Dane County District Attorney’s decision today is not only disturbing but continues to amplify the mistrust in our legal institutions. Continuing to deny victims of violence equal treatment under the law, regardless of who you are, will never allow our state to fully heal. Corey’s family was denied their day in court. Now, as elected leaders, it is our duty to reform this flawed system to ensure that the law is equally applied to everyone.” 

Rep. Sheila Stubbs (D-Madison) said in a statement, “I am shocked to have learned that there will be no criminal charges for the officer who took the life of a son, brother, father, and member of this community.” Stubbs, who joined the Ruiz family and Crump at the press conference Thursday, added that “this is not the decision this community was expecting, and it is one that will have lasting detrimental impacts on our city and the trust between residents of color and law enforcement.”

The challenges in bringing criminal charges against police 

Ozanne said in his decision that “a knife can be used as a dangerous weapon and may pose a grave danger of bodily harm and/or death to an individual.” Under Wisconsin law, he said, a person may threaten or use “force reasonably believed necessary” to stop a threat. “A person does not have to like and/or agree with the law, however, I am sworn to apply the law to the facts at hand,” said Ozanne. “The law applies equally to members of law enforcement and to those who are not.”

Steven Wright, a clinical professor at UW-Madison’s Law School and a former attorney for the U.S. Department of Justice, explained that police officers are afforded layers of legal protection that lawyers must overcome to bring a criminal charges. 

“The odds of making it to trial tend to be very, very slim,” Wright told the Wisconsin Examiner. Officers involved in shootings have qualified immunity, which often leads judges to dismiss lawsuits. “And so, lawyers spend a lot of time just trying to get over that immunity issue before anything else,” said Wright. “And many fail. The U.S. Supreme Court, I think it’s fair to say, keeps raising the bar for people to overcome qualified immunity. And so that’s why we see so few cases.”

Protesters gather at the intersection of Williamson and Baldwin streets in Madison in remembrance of Corey Ruiz. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)
Protesters gather at the intersection of Williamson and Baldwin streets (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

Local officials might also want  to “put this in the rearview mirror as quickly as possible,” Wright said, and move towards a settlement. A small number of police shootings have also been reviewed under Wisconsin’s John Doe law, which allows a local judge to review a case where prosecutors declined to file changes and decide whether probable cause exists to appoint special prosecutors for a second look. 

The dynamics of police shooting investigations also present challenges. In Wisconsin, although police departments cannot lead investigations into their own shootings, the local district attorney who routinely relies on those same officers decides whether charges should be filed. “There is the argument that there is a conflict of interest here,” said Wright.

Additionally, police officers who fatally shoot civilians often refuse to allow their interviews to be recorded. This was the case with Baitinger-Peterson and the other Madison officers involved in Ruiz’s killing. 

Without a recorded statement, officers can more easily change or adjust their recollection of a shooting. Even just getting through the discovery and document obtaining phase takes time. “By that time, people’s memories fade, people’s stories change,” Wright said. “And so, because there’s not the original recording in the document, it’s very hard to compare, ‘Well you said this immediately after the shooting, now you’re saying this.” 

“Police unions tend to be pretty powerful in many jurisdictions,” said Wright. “And among the rules that they have are that — and they train their members when these types of shootings happen — [to] ask for your representative and these rights.” 

Protesters gather at the intersection of Williamson and Baldwin streets in Madison in remembrance of Corey Ruiz. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)
(Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

“I don’t think that it comes as a giant surprise to many Americans that police investigations of police officers are often handled very differently and sometimes more kindly to other officers, as opposed to the rest of the community,” he added. “Those are things that can be fixed by legislation. Those are things that cities can choose to do, but again, you know, that’s a very tough political accomplishment, I think, to achieve these things.”

Crowley vowed that his office will “look beyond this one case and examine what we can do differently to prevent tragedies like this from happening again.”

 “That means reviewing how officer-involved deaths are investigated and how information is shared with families and the public,” he said. “It also means taking a hard look at use of force policies and training, while listening to communities most affected by these encounters.” 

Crowley added that he will work with lawmakers, law enforcement and community leaders “to identify meaningful changes that can make our justice system more transparent and help rebuild public trust.” 

“We cannot change what happened to Corey, but we can take responsibility for making sure his death leads to serious conversation about how we move forward so that every Wisconsinite can have confidence that they will be treated with dignity and fairness, regardless of their race or ZIP code. That is the standard our state must work toward, and I am committed to it,” Crowley said.

Community responds 

Community members gathered at the corner of Williamson and Baldwin on Thursday evening to protest the charging decision, chant and comfort each other.

Some in the crowd, distrusting media coverage of the shooting and its aftermath, confronted a group of television reporters and demanded that they leave. Overhead, two drones monitored the gathering for hours.

One participant was a combat veteran who said he was appalled by the behavior of officers. Another was a law student who argued that the laws regulating “reasonable” use of force  need to be changed. Yet another was an unhoused man who claimed to have known Ruiz, and said that although he was imperfect that he didn’t deserve what happened to him. 

A petition to recall  Ozanne as district attorney circulated through the group. Later in the evening a march was escorted by police. 

Protesters gather at the intersection of Williamson and Baldwin streets in Madison in remembrance of Corey Ruiz. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)
 (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

One young man named Kofi said he came out “to advocate against the consistent injustice that plagues our entire country, and that starts with taking out these cops, putting them in prison, giving them justice that families have been asking for, and that goes for countless Black victims.” 

Amanda Stein, an ordained elder in the United Methodist Church, said she joined the Ruiz family and others earlier Thursday to pray. “We just thought it was really important to be present throughout the day,” said Stein, “whether it was at the Center for Black Excellence, or at the church, or here on the street, for us to walk alongside, listen, be present, for people going through a lot of pain right now.” 

“This strikes really into the heart of the community when something like that happens in broad daylight, in front of passersby,” Stein said. “It’s unspeakable.” 

Stein said that she wants to hear more about the shooting and its aftermath from the candidates for  mayor of Madison. “I do think we need to be holding our elected officials to better accountability,” she said. “And I wouldn’t necessarily say even so much the legal aspect but coming as a person of faith: How is this affecting the heart and the lifeblood of our communities? Because there’s real pain and I think, often, our government and elected officials will lean into the legalities and the, for lack of a better term, just the formality of process and it would mean so much if we could actually have contact with one another in conversation rather than confrontation.”

❌
❌