Advocate reports nonprofit hospitals gain more in tax breaks than they give

A new report says nonprofit hospitals' tax breaks often exceed their contributions to community health, but hospitals dispute the methods used by the organization that conducted the research. (Photo by John Partipilo/Tennessee Lookout)
A new report argues that nearly three out of four Wisconsin nonprofit hospitals don’t give back community benefits in proportion to what they gain from their tax-exempt status.
Hospital representatives contend the report’s math paints a distorted picture, leaving out some costs that should be included.
The report’s publisher, the Lown Institute, defends its choices, limiting the benefits it includes in the calculations to “direct spending on the community,” in the words of an institute official.
Lown published its 2026 “Hospital Fair-Share Spending” report Tuesday, with data from across the country. The report is based on published information from fiscal year 2023.
According to the report, slightly more than half of nonprofit hospitals nationwide — 52% — gave back less than they received in their total tax exemptions that year.
In Wisconsin, the gap was wider, with 70% of hospitals getting more in tax breaks than they give in community benefits as Lown calculates them.
“Wisconsin families are footing the bill for massive tax breaks given to nonprofit hospitals, yet a handful of wealthy hospital systems guard resources while patients drown in preventable medical debt,” said Bobby Peterson, executive director of ABC for Health, citing the Lown report’s Wisconsin data. ABC for Health is a public interest law firm that assists low- and moderate-income people with medical debt and in navigating the healthcare system.
The Wisconsin Hospital Association pushed back on the findings, calling the report “a misleading and incomplete picture of the contributions Wisconsin’s nonprofit hospitals make to their communities.”
Lown’s definitions of community benefits omit “billions of dollars in very real costs hospitals absorb while caring for Wisconsin patients, particularly those covered by Medicare and Medicaid,” the WHA said.
Focus on healthcare social responsibility
The nonprofit Lown Institute was founded by cardiologist Dr. Bernard Lown in 1973 as the Lown Cardiovascular Health Research Foundation. It originally focused on research and education around heart disease and advocating for preventive medicine, non-invasive management and compassionate healing.
It became the Lown Institute in 2012 and refocused its work on the overuse and underuse of medical treatment and a range of other health policy issues, many of them centered on healthcare social responsibility.
Lown’s hospital spending report draws data from hospitals’ filings with the federal Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services and their nonprofit 990 reports to the Internal Revenue Service.
In return for the federal, state and local tax exemptions that nonprofit hospitals receive, “they are expected to provide free and discounted care and invest in programs that improve community health,” the report states in its introduction.
The report finds a gap between some wealthy and well-known hospitals with community benefits that fall short of the value of their tax breaks and other facilities that “contribute well beyond what they receive,” according to the report.
“Some of America’s wealthiest hospitals fall hundreds of millions short of giving back what they receive from their communities, leaving those with fewer resources to pick up the slack,” said Dr. Vikas Saini, the Lown Institute president. “Tax exemptions aren’t a gift — they’re an expectation, and regulators need to make sure all hospitals hold up their end of the bargain.”
ABC for Health reviewed the Lown report and concluded that in 2023, Wisconsin hospitals collectively provided $633 million less in community benefits than they received in tax exemptions — “an amount the Lown Institute estimates could eliminate medical debt for 341,815 residents,” ABC for Health stated.
To calculate a hospital’s total tax break, the report adds up the hospital’s savings from not paying taxes and from paying lower interest on bonds because they’re tax exempt, and from tax-exempt charitable donations.
The report limits its definition of community investments — including expenses that, in Lown’s analysis, directly contribute to better community health and excluding expenses that do not.
One omission: a hospital’s Medicaid shortfall — the gap between what the hospital receives from Medicaid and the cost of care that it reports.
Judith Garber, a senior policy analyst at Lown, said hospitals use the shortfall numbers to justify higher prices for other payers; to qualify for bonus payments that hospitals can receive if they serve a large number of Medicaid patients and patients without insurance; and to support their case for federally required discounts on drugs from drug manufacturers.
“Then they want to count it a fourth time as a community benefit,” Garber said. “We exclude it for that reason and because it simply does not reflect direct spending on the community. If we were to include Medicaid shortfall, wouldn’t it need to be offset by the amount they collect above cost for private pay?”
ABC for Health singled out three hospitals associated with large Wisconsin hospital groups — emblematic, the organization said, of how the differences between tax breaks and community benefits were “concentrated in major systems.”
At Froedtert West Bend Hospital the report calculated 2023 community benefits were $80.8 million less than tax exemptions. At Aurora St. Luke’s Medical Center in Milwaukee, it reported benefits $79 million less than tax exemptions and at Aurora BayCare Medical Center in Green Bay the report calculated benefits were $38.7 million less than tax exemptions.
ABC for Health noted that 37 Wisconsin hospitals provided community benefits that exceeded their tax breaks, and singled out St. Croix Regional Medical Center and Mile Bluff Medical Center, in Juneau County. Each reported total benefits that exceeded their tax breaks by more than $11 million.
Hospital systems find fault
Along with the Wisconsin Hospital Association, Froedtert and Aurora both criticized the report’s findings.
Because of how Lown calculates benefits, “the report does not capture the full scope of these investments and their impact,” an Aurora statement declared.
Citing its own 2025 report , Aurora — which operates hospitals in 18 locations in eastern Wisconsin, not just the two singled out by ABC for Health — said its community benefits totaled $1.93 billion in 2025. That figure includes activities “hospitals are required to report to the IRS and that health systems across the country regularly include when assessing their community benefit,” according to the statement.
A spokesperson for Froedtert ThedaCare issued a statement that said the Lown Institute “has used selective methodology and isolated data points to produce its report as appears to be the case here.” At the hospital system, “We continue to follow all appropriate processes regarding exemption status, as we work to advance the health of the communities we serve.”
A statement from the hospital association charged that Lown was “selectively defining what counts as a community benefit,” in the process omitting “billions of dollars in very real costs hospitals absorb while caring for Wisconsin patients, particularly those covered by Medicare and Medicaid.”
The result “is simply not a fair or accurate assessment,” the WHA statement asserted.
The hospital association argued that in 2023 — the year covered by the new report — $1.6 billion in Medicaid reimbursement shortfalls and $3.3 billion in Medicare shortfalls should be included as “real costs of caring for patients that are excluded from Lown’s definition of community investment.”





























