❌

Normal view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.
Yesterday — 16 November 2026Main stream

900+ women criminally charged for their conduct during pregnancies

16 November 2026 at 09:00
In the first three years after the U.S. Supreme Court struck down the constitutional right to an abortion in June 2022, more than 900 women faced criminal charges for conduct related to their pregnancies, according to a new report. (Photo by Ross Williams/Georgia Recorder)

In the first three years after the U.S. Supreme Court struck down the constitutional right to an abortion in June 2022, more than 900 women faced criminal charges for conduct related to their pregnancies, according to a new report. (Photo by Ross Williams/Georgia Recorder)

In the first three years after the U.S. Supreme Court struck down the constitutional right to an abortion in June 2022, more than 900 women faced criminal charges for conduct related to their pregnancies, according to a new report.

Most state laws that prohibit or regulate abortion seek to penalize those who provide abortions, not the women who undergo them. Nevertheless, researchers from Pregnancy Justice, a nonprofit group that supports abortion rights, found 13 specific allegations related to obtaining, seeking to obtain, or researching how to get an abortion. The group would not provide additional details on those cases, saying it is still collecting data and hopes to publish a full analysis in 2028.

The vast majority of the charges — 876 of 955 — were for child abuse, neglect or endangerment, most related to substance use during pregnancy. Researchers found 871 separate allegations of substance use and 77 allegations that a woman had failed to obtain prenatal care.

The most prominent anti-abortion groups have long argued against prosecuting women for having abortions, a punishment that remains broadly unpopular. But the new report comes as a growing number of state legislators are pushing to enact such penalties: In the past two years, lawmakers have introduced bills in about a dozen states, and supporters expect that number to grow next year.

Members of the so-called abortion abolition movement believe that embryos and fetuses should have the same legal protections as people, and that women who have abortions should be criminally prosecuted to the furthest extent of the law — up to and including the death penalty.

“It sure sucks that someone who’s had a miscarriage has to be investigated, but that’s not the fault of the abolitionist legislation,” said T. Russell Hunter, founder of Oklahoma-based Abolitionists Rising. “That’s the fault of the people who would willfully break the law to abort babies. They would be the ones causing that situation.”

Hunter credits groups like his with pushing anti-abortion bills to be “a little more radical.”

Some prominent anti-abortion leaders are concerned that groups like Abolitionists Rising are gaining ground.

“It’s impossible to prosecute those abortions without enacting a police state,” said Eric Scheidler, president of the Pro-Life Action League. Scheidler and two prominent anti-abortion attorneys penned articles arguing against such prosecutions in the summer issue of Human Life Review.

“Every miscarriage would have to be investigated in order to treat these embryonic and fetal dead bodies the same way that we would treat a dead body at a hospital or in an old folks home or out in the street where a crime took place,” he said.

Most cases in three states

The Pregnancy Justice report found that 902 women faced a total of 955 charges in 23 states, but the vast majority of cases were in South Carolina (381), Oklahoma (222) and Alabama (204).

Those three states are among the 13 that have enacted near-total abortion bans since the high court dismantled the federal right to an abortion in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization.

And in all three states, courts have supported the concept of fetal personhood, or the idea that a fetus, embryo or fertilized egg has the same legal rights as a person who has been born.

South Carolina, which bans abortion after six weeks, explicitly prohibits prosecuting women for seeking or getting abortions. But lawmakers in South Carolina and at least eight other states (Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Kentucky, Missouri, North Dakota, Oklahoma and Texas) have introduced bills in recent years that would classify abortion as homicide, making violators in those states (except for North Dakota) eligible for the death penalty.

In South Carolina this year, a Senate committee approved a bill that included a penalty of up to two years in prison for a woman convicted of inducing her own abortion, but the legislation did not advance further.

South Carolina lobbyist Hayden Laye of Pro-Life Greenville said his group opposes penalizing women for abortion. But his group ended up backing the bill when the punishment was reduced to a misdemeanor and it appeared likely that the state Senate would remove the provision.

Laye said he expects the legislation to be reintroduced next year. He noted that the abolitionist groups have lobbied against anti-abortion legislation that does not penalize the pregnant person.

“The abolitionist groups put up just as much opposition to these bills as groups like Planned Parenthood and the ACLU does,” Laye said. “We are really having to fight both sides of this — the side that wants no abortion laws, and the side that wants all or nothing, which isn’t happening. It’s not happening here in South Carolina. It’s not happening anywhere.”

Since 2022, several states including California, Colorado, Minnesota and New Jersey have enacted laws protecting women from criminal or civil penalties for their conduct during a pregnancy or while receiving reproductive healthcare.

The only state where a woman can be charged for inducing her own abortion is Nevada, which enacted its law in 1911. A Winnemucca woman who miscarried in 2018 and was charged under the law pleaded guilty to manslaughter in 2019, but her conviction was vacated in 2021 for ineffective assistance of counsel. Earlier this month, Humboldt County, Nevada, paid $1.6 million to settle her claim that it violated her state and federal constitutional rights.

Next month, voters in Nevada will consider codifying abortion rights in their state constitution after voters initially approved the amendment in 2024.

Dissuaded from seeking care

Madalyn Wasilczuk, a law professor at the University of South Carolina and one of the authors of the ongoing Pregnancy Justice study, said the Dobbs decision “really has affected how willing law enforcement and prosecutors are to treat miscarriages and stillbirths and other newborn deaths immediately after delivery as culpable acts and as crimes rather than as medical tragedies.”

Wasilczuk said that even the fear of criminal charges can dissuade pregnant women from seeking care, especially if they are substance users.

“Seeking care becomes a place where they expect to be criminalized, and so people avoid healthcare, which really underscores why it’s so dangerous to treat the criminal legal system as if it can solve a public health problem,” she said. “These instances are times when women need healthcare, not handcuffs.”

Jennifer Girdish, communications director for If/When/How, an abortion rights organization, said women who live in states with abortion bans often call the group’s helpline because they are scared to go to the emergency room after they have a miscarriage or experience complications after taking abortion pills.

“You shouldn’t need a lawyer to stop the police from investigating you after pregnancy loss,” Girdish said. “You shouldn’t need a lawyer to convince the doctor that you need emergency abortion care. But more and more you do.”

In addition to South Carolina, Oklahoma and Alabama, the Pregnancy Justice report found that prosecutors also initiated pregnancy-related cases in Arizona, Arkansas, California, Florida, Idaho, Kentucky, Michigan, Missouri, Mississippi, Nebraska, New Mexico, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Dakota, Texas, Utah, Washington, Wisconsin, and Wyoming.

Stateline reporter Sofia Resnick can be reached at sresnick@stateline.org.

 

This story was originally produced by Stateline, which is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network which includes Wisconsin Examiner, and is supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity.

Before yesterdayMain stream

Gov. Evers grants first Wisconsin commutations in decades 

Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers announced he is commuting the sentences of 14 people, the first commutations in Wisconsin since 1995.(Photo by Caspar Benson/Getty Images)

The Wisconsin Examiner’s Criminal Justice Reporting Project shines a light on incarceration, law enforcement and criminal justice issues with support from the Public Welfare Foundation.

Gov. Tony Evers has granted commutations to 14 of the 24 people who came before his Commutation Advisory Board in August and September, his office announced Friday. They are the first commutations since the administration of former Gov. Tommy Thompson in 1995.

That doesn’t mean 14 people will be immediately released from prison. A commutation doesn’t necessarily mean a person will be released or have their sentence shortened, the governor’s office said. 

For one of the 14, Amanda Weaver, the commutation will allow for immediate release from confinement; she will have two years of extended supervision in the community. 

In 2008, Weaver was sentenced to 30 years of incarceration and 20 years of extended supervision in the community, the Examiner reported in August. She had been convicted of five counts of burglary. At Weaver’s sentencing hearing, the prosecution and defense recommended jointly that she receive five years of confinement and 12 years of extended supervision, according to the governor’s office. The others involved in the burglaries were sentenced to no more than three years of confinement, the governor’s office said. 

The rest of the 14 will not be immediately released, but they may see release sooner than they would have without a commutation. For example, Touissant Harley’s sentence was reduced “to reflect a mandatory transition to parole” by June 1, 2027.

Not all incarcerated people are eligible for parole. Under Wisconsin’s Truth-in-Sentencing laws, if a person committed a felony offense on or after Dec. 31, 1999 and is sentenced to at least a year in prison, the person will not be eligible for parole.

Some legislators are criticizing the commutations, with Sen. Eric Wimberger (R-Gillett) stating that Evers “is releasing 10 murderers, a burglar, an arsonist and a drug dealer — who all deserve their punishments,” and that this puts “our communities in physical danger.” Sen. Julian Bradley (R-New Berlin), who was recently elected to be the next Senate Minority Leader, also voiced opposition to the news. 

“So there’s no confusion, Tony Evers is commuting the sentences of 10 convicted murderers and he’s releasing it on a Friday afternoon, hoping nobody notices,” Bradley said in a Facebook post.

The ACLU of Wisconsin praised the commutations in a statement.

“Voters across the political spectrum support the use of commutations to end or shorten unjust prison sentences so that people can rejoin their communities and get a fair chance at life. Granting clemency is the right thing to do — and it’s also the popular thing to do,” the ACLU said. “We urge the governor to continue commuting sentences before he leaves office, and we hope Governor-elect Crowley builds on this by expanding the commutations process and making it a routine part of his administration, just like it is for many Republican and Democratic governors across the country. Wisconsin’s prison population is at record highs. This is a start, but so much more needs to be done.”

Who are the people receiving commutations? 

Mighty Howell, 50, who has served 33 years of a life sentence for first-degree intentional homicide, had his parole eligibility moved up from 2038 to September 2027.

Howell was 17 years old when convicted and sentenced in 1993 for the May 27, 1993 death of Roger Bucholz in Milwaukee during an attempted robbery.

He had applied for a commutation under the Juvenile Life Sentence Commutation because he was at least 19 at the time of his conviction.

In Evers’s announcement, it was noted that Howell had worked on rehabilitating himself and helping others, maintained continuous employment, and received 20 letters of support from family members and a retired correctional officer he had worked with in prison.

Michael Maldonado, 47, having served 31 years of a life sentence, had his sentence shortened to four more years of incarceration followed by parole.

Maldonado was sentenced in 1995 for first-degree intentional homicide (use of a dangerous weapon and party to a crime), for his part in the 1994 killing of Ruben Borchardt of Jefferson County when Maldonado was 15.

His first eligible parole hearing was set in the year 2044, but after an accomplice who had been given a shorter sentence took responsibility for the actual shooting, noting Maldonado had only supplied the weapon, Maldonado had his sentence modified in 2025, making him currently eligible for release from prison and parole by the Wisconsin Parole Commission.

As part of the commutation, Maldonado was recognized for his “rehabilitation efforts while incarcerated,” noting his educational achievements, including an associate’s degree in business and certifications, along with his extensive work history and volunteering efforts.

He also received several letters of support from family members and others who offered housing and support upon his release.

Daniel Cerney, 43, was sentenced with two concurrent life sentences for the 1999 shooting deaths of Wiliam Leis, 51 and his 85-year-old mother, Evelyn Leis, when Cerney was 16, and also sentenced for burglary-armed with a dangerous weapon and theft of movable property He had his parole eligibility moved from the year 2044 to 2030.

After serving 26 years in prison, it was noted that Cerney had participated in several rehabilitation programs, developed job skills, and worked productively for Badger State Industries in several capacities.

He also had several letters of support, including one from the victims’  family who had consistently visited Cerney in prison.

Sabir Wilcher, 46, having served 31 years of a life sentence given in 1995 when he was 15 years of age for the killing of Elvis Anderson, 20, in Milwaukee, had his sentence commuted to three more years of incarceration before he will be placed on parole.

Wilcher has been eligible for parole since 2025, and depending on a decision by the Wisconsin Parole Commission, he could be released earlier than the commutation release date.

Wilcher had obtained a bachelor’s degree and other certifications and also participated in several programs for rehabilitative development, and worked in several capacities, including as a certified peer specialist, helping other incarcerated people.

The victim’s son spoke on Wilcher’s behalf, and the prosecuting district attorney also supported Wilcher’s commutation.

Wazir El-Amin, formerly Wade A. Curtis, 55, having served 36 years of confinement for a life sentence given on November 21, 1990, for first-degree intentional homicide with a dangerous weapon in Racine County, was made immediately eligible for parole, with the parole commission to hold a hearing as soon as possible.

Previously, El-Amin had been eligible for parole in 2028.

Besides significant educational achievements and programs he had completed, he had also participated in a childhood trauma group and had spoken to at-risk youth.

In El-Amin’s application, it was noted that he had secured work with a construction company upon his release, and that he would also volunteer in a non-profit he had started with his wife to work with those who had been recently released from prison.

DeQuelvin Douglas, 47, who was convicted of first-degree intentional homicide and attempted first-degree intentional homicide in Kenosha County at age 15 and sentenced to life imprisonment when he was 16, resulting in 31 years in prison, had his parole eligibility commuted from the year 2056 to 2029.

Rep. Amanda Nedweski (R-Pleasant Prairie) criticized the commutation of Douglas, citing “significant opposition from the Kenosha County District Attorney’s Office.”

Douglas had received a letter of support from a former Department of Corrections sergeant who said, “of all the individuals I supervised, he stands out as someone who truly deserves a second chance.” 

Dawn Dobbs, 59, who has been incarcerated for 32 years, convicted of first-degree intentional homicide (party to a crime) in Milwaukee County and sentenced July 1, 1994, to life imprisonment for the killing of her life partner and father of their two sons, had the date of her parole eligibility changed from 2035 to November 2026.

In 2010, she helped the DOC make a suicide prevention video that is still being used, and she also has served as a peer mentor and volunteered to make masks during the COVID pandemic.  

The district attorney and her son each supported a commutation.

The other 10 people heard at the August and September hearings of the Commutation Advisory Board have been denied commutation, the governor’s office said. 

What’s next for commutations? 

Evers may issue more commutations before leaving office. The Commutation Advisory Board heard from other applicants seeking a commutation in October and November. The board also has hearings scheduled for Nov. 20 and Dec. 11. 

Evers shortens prison sentences for 14 people in Wisconsin’s first commutations in 25 years

Stone building behind bars
Reading Time: 4 minutes

Less than two months before leaving office, Gov. Tony Evers granted the first commutations in Wisconsin in 25 years, including for violent offenses. 

Of the 24 applicants whose cases the Commutations Advisory Board heard in August and September, Evers reduced the sentences of 14, according to a Friday announcement. Those selected include people convicted of crimes such as homicide, armed robbery and drug dealing. Five were convicted when they were under 18. 

One grantee, Michael Maldonado, was convicted of first-degree intentional homicide at age 15. He was sentenced to life in prison in 1995, with eligibility for parole in 2044. Maldonado’s sentence was modified in 2025 after new evidence showed he was not the gunman in the crime he was sentenced for, according to the governor’s office. Following his Friday commutation, Maldonado will spend a maximum of four more years in prison before transitioning to parole. 

Like Maldonado, most of the people who received commutations will remain incarcerated for months or years, as many of the commutations reduced lengths of confinement or moved up when someone will be eligible for parole. Only one person, a woman who was serving a 30-year sentence for a burglary conviction, was granted immediate release with two years of extended supervision. Evers recognized the length of her sentence and rehabilitation behind bars, including serving “as a kitchen worker, maintenance worker, chaplain’s assistant, library clerk, tutor, and community service worker.”

Hundreds of people have applied for commutations since Gov. Tony Evers reopened the process in April. No commutations have been issued since Gov. Tommy Thompson’s administration. 

Evers has issued a record 2,443 pardons, an official forgiveness available only to those who completed their full sentences, including any extended supervision, at least five years ago. By restoring certain civil rights and privileges, pardons can make it easier to get a job, housing or a professional license. 

While the governor’s office noted that some district attorneys supported the applications of a few individuals seeking commutations, others opposed action by the commutation board. Nathan Haberman, the Republican Calumet County district attorney in a July letter wrote that he objected to the commutation of Sammy Cole, one of the 14 grantees included in the Friday announcement, who was convicted of armed robbery with threat of force in 2001. 

“There have been four circuit court judges who have reviewed the sentencing in this case, along with the court of appeals on at least three occasions,” Haberman wrote. “Further review and second guessing by a less informed Commutation Advisory Board is not necessary nor appropriate in this case.” 

Citing “positive adjustments and rehabilitation while incarcerated,” Evers reduced Cole’s confinement from 35 to 28 years, which means he will remain incarcerated for another four years and then have 10 years of extended supervision once he is released. 

Among those who urged the governor to grant clemency is Shannon Ross, founder and CEO of The Community, a Milwaukee-based nonprofit which helps incarcerated and formerly incarcerated people pursue education and develop as leaders. 

He said he’s “really, really happy” for grantees who would otherwise have had to wait many years for the opportunity to apply for release — if they were allowed such an opportunity at all. “It’s a great thing for them and their families that there’s daylight now in a place that had no daylight,” Ross said.

But, he said, he and his fellow clemency advocates are also “very, very sad and grieving” about applicants they believe deserved the chance to “come home and help the community.”

And he’s worried about grantees who will need to go before the parole board. The board has granted parole to just seven people so far this year, a fraction of the 77 approved in 2025, Department of Corrections data shows.

“This year has been a really, really slow, if not nonexistent, parole process,” Ross said. “If that doesn’t change, these potentially could be hollow commutations. The hope now is that the way parole has been operating starts to go back to where it has been in previous years, where people are genuinely getting released when they’ve done all the things they’ve been asked to do by the system.”

Meanwhile, the number of prisoners in Wisconsin hit a record high in October. According to the Department of Corrections, the state’s prisons now house nearly 6,000 people more than they were designed for.

What’s next for commutations?

Decisions are still pending for the 23 prisoners who participated in the two more recent hearings. An Evers spokesperson said the governor intends to “at least approve or deny” every applicant who has received a hearing before he leaves office. 

The commutations board is scheduled to meet again on Nov. 20 and on Dec. 11 to hear another 25 applicants. It is not clear if there will be additional meetings before the end of Evers’ term on Jan. 4. 

Also unknown is how the commutations process will change when Milwaukee County Executive and Governor-elect David Crowley takes office in January. In April, Crowley told Wisconsin Watch he would work with the Legislature to “institutionalize” Evers’ commutations process but that he “would not allow commutations of murderers.” 

Under Evers’ executive orders, only those previously convicted of sexual assault, physical abuse or sexual exploitation of a child, trafficking of a child, incest or soliciting a child for prostitution are ineligible for commutations. 

Ross is optimistic that Crowley will continue what Evers started, and that those who don’t receive commutations under Evers might be eligible to apply again. He said he and other advocates will work with the new administration to create a policy that addresses the concerns of incarcerated people, crime survivors and the public as a whole. 

“I just don’t want anyone who sees their name or their loved one’s name on the ‘denied’ list to think that it’s all over with,” Ross said. “This is the beginning of what we are definitely aggressively working to have continue under the new governor. So, hopefully, this is Governor Evers providing an apparatus and an example that Governor Crowley can now continue, and we are actively pushing for that to be the case.”

Editor’s note: A previous version of this story incorrectly stated that the number of people released on parole this year.

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

Evers shortens prison sentences for 14 people in Wisconsin’s first commutations in 25 years is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

As ‘child predator hunters’ go viral, states grapple with the risks of civilian stings

11 November 2026 at 09:00
Harford County, Md., Sheriff Jeff Gahler speaks with Chris Hansen, the host of “Takedown with Chris Hansen” on the TruBlu streaming network. The sheriff’s office conducted several operations featured on the show to highlight how local investigators identify and apprehend suspected child predators. (Photo courtesy of Harford County Sheriff’s Office)

Harford County, Md., Sheriff Jeff Gahler speaks with Chris Hansen, the host of “Takedown with Chris Hansen” on the TruBlu streaming network. The sheriff’s office conducted several operations featured on the show to highlight how local investigators identify and apprehend suspected child predators. (Photo courtesy of Harford County Sheriff’s Office)

Across the country, dozens of civilian groups, or vigilantes, are posing as children online, arranging meetings with adults they suspect of seeking sex with minors and livestreaming the confrontations to thousands of viewers.

The groups say they are helping protect children and bring suspected predators to justice. But some law enforcement officials and legal experts warn that their tactics can jeopardize criminal investigations, complicate prosecutions and put public safety at risk. Public accusations can also have lasting consequences for people who are never charged with a crime, while some groups encourage their followers to pressure police to make arrests.

There is no definitive count of civilian predator-hunting groups, but dozens of groups operate across different parts of the country, including major cities. Stateline identified nearly 50 individuals or groups nationwide that have posted online content exposing suspected child predators.

For state lawmakers and law enforcement officials, the growing presence of these groups adds another layer of complexity to efforts to combat online child sexual exploitation while protecting children and preserving the integrity of criminal investigations.

“What is beyond dispute is we have a massive problem of child exploitation in this country that takes various forms,” said Mary Graw Leary, a law professor at the Catholic University of America whose work focuses on the exploitation of women and children. Graw Leary is a former state and federal prosecutor. “We cannot criminalize our way out of it only because there’s just too much of it.”

Catching and prosecuting people who sexually exploit children is important, experts say, but it addresses only part of the problem. Preventing abuse also requires teaching adults and children to recognize warning signs, creating environments where children feel safe speaking up and are heard, and holding institutions and online platforms accountable.

“The criminal justice response, I think, is appropriate, warranted, and important, but it’s not the only thing that we should be doing as a society or as communities,” said Stacy Vaughan, the vice president of growth and prevention at Childhelp, a nonprofit dedicated to preventing and responding to child abuse.

When a viral video isn’t enough

The scale of online child sexual exploitation is immense. 

The National Center for Missing & Exploited Children received 21.3 million reports through its CyberTipline in 2025, including about 1.4 million reports of online enticement of children for sexual acts — a 158% increase from 2024 –– and more than 19.5 million reports involving child sexual abuse material. 

Popularized by NBC’s Dateline series “To Catch a Predator,” which aired in the early 2000s, civilian predator-hunting groups use adult decoys posing as children or teenagers online to contact people they suspect of seeking sex with minors, then confront them on camera.

The accusations can make for compelling viral content. People accused of targeting children often have little public sympathy, and videos promising to expose and humiliate them can attract viewers with little interest in what happens after the camera shuts off.

Quotation

The best way for these groups to be helpful would be for them to involve law enforcement when they get the first nibble on their line.

– Matt Irvine, a retired detective who investigated sex crimes in California and Oregon

Some vigilante groups involve law enforcement only after a sting is complete, or if a confrontation turns violent. That can leave responding officers with an incomplete picture of what happened, how the encounter unfolded and whether the evidence supports criminal charges.

Digital evidence — the online conversations and promises — must be authenticated and preserved to establish its origin, integrity and handling. Recordings can also raise legal questions, experts say, including whether groups violated state wiretapping laws when capturing private conversations.

“The best way for these groups to be helpful would be for them to involve law enforcement when they get the first nibble on their line,” said Matt Irvine, a retired detective with 29 years of law enforcement experience who investigated sex crimes and cold-case sexual assaults in California and Oregon. 

When police are involved from the start, he said, detectives  can conduct a more thorough investigation, check a suspect’s criminal history and obtain search warrants.

The financial arrangements behind the videos can raise additional concerns if group members are called as witnesses in criminal cases. Some groups can earn advertising revenue from videos posted online, while others offer paid memberships through platforms such as YouTube, Rumble, Kick and Locals, where subscribers can get earlier or exclusive access than nonmembers to videos, updates, unedited footage and chat logs.

Those financial incentives could become relevant in court, particularly if prosecutors or defense attorneys question whether a witness had a financial interest in producing a confrontation or attracting viewers.

“If they are selling the confrontation videos and profiting from that, that would be an ethical issue in a criminal case,” said Kelly Callihan, the executive director of the Pennsylvania District Attorneys Association. “If we’re going to call them as a witness, that would have to be something that we would disclose to the defense.” 

Some predator-catching groups also criticize police or prosecutors when a person is not arrested or charged, encouraging viewers to contact and complain to officials about their decisions. 

“These predator groups now, I feel like, are escalating from shaming the alleged perpetrators of these acts to crossing a line where they’re shaming district attorneys who aren’t bringing these charges, even though they have valid reasons not to do so,” Callihan said.

Public confrontations

Videos of civilian predator-catching operations sometimes show violent confrontations. In one viral video from 2024, members of Dads Against Predators surround a man at an H-E-B grocery store in Austin, Texas, and strike him in the back of the head with a pumpkin.

The man, James Schellhase, filed a federal racketeering lawsuit against the Ohio-based group in September, alleging that its members assaulted him, tried to extort him and cost him his job as a chief executive. 

Schellhase had been communicating online with people who later claimed to be minors, according to the lawsuit. He said he believed the interaction was a prank or scam and wanted to confront them. The group accused him of trying to meet a child for sex.

Schellhase alleges that Dads Against Predators demanded $400,000 to keep the confrontation video from being released and that the footage was sent to his employer, according to the lawsuit. He says the encounter damaged his career. One of the group’s co-founders, Joshua Alvin Mundy, has denied wrongdoing.

Dads Against Predators has been linked to multiple suicides involving people the group filmed. The group has also faced scrutiny from law enforcement in California, Florida, North Carolina and Texas, where members have been arrested or authorities have urged them to stop their activities. In 2020, the Sandusky County Sheriff’s Office in Ohio warned the group that it could face prosecution if it continued its “vigilante efforts.”

But the concerns extend beyond physical safety. Public accusations may also target people who have committed no crime and jeopardize investigations by alerting suspects before police can gather evidence, identify additional victims or pursue other leads. 

In April of this year, livestreamer Vitaly Zdorovetskiy and his crew falsely accused a 25-year-old man of trying to meet a 16-year-old girl for sex during a confrontation at a Southern California park, prompting online harassment of the man and his family. Police detained the man, but released him after questioning, and Zdorovetskiy later apologized for the mistaken accusation, but clips of the confrontation continued circulating online.

Public confrontations can also expose civilian predator hunters themselves to potential criminal charges, especially if encounters turn violent or involve threats.

For some groups, that tension has changed how they operate. 

Brian Knepp founded 814 Pred Hunters in Pennsylvania in 2022 after learning that a man he had considered a friend had raped a child. The group initially focused on publicly confronting suspected predators and exposing them online, but frustration over local prosecutors’ inability to bring charges prompted Knepp to change course and seek closer cooperation with police and prosecutors.

“We wanted these guys to be held accountable, and just us exposing them, in my mind, wasn’t acceptable anymore,” Knepp said in an interview.

Josh Moody, chief operating officer of Alabama-based Covenant Rescue Group, a nonprofit that trains police, said effective undercover operations require preparation and coordination. The group’s training covers evidence handling, communication, intelligence gathering and surveillance, as well as avoiding conduct that could undermine a prosecution, including actions that could support an entrapment defense. The group generally does not post any content online.

“If we come in and do a one-off operation and arrest a few guys on the operation –– that’s great, but really, we want (law enforcement) to be able to continue the work,” Moody said. 

Some law enforcement agencies have adopted a different approach to publicizing undercover operations, partnering with television programs while maintaining control over investigations and evidence.

Sheriffs Chris Swanson of Genesee County, Michigan, and Jeff Gahler of Harford County, Maryland, whose investigations have been featured on the TruBlu series “Takedown with Chris Hansen,” described how their agencies conduct these operations. 

Swanson said G.H.O.S.T., the office’s specialized sex crimes unit, conducts investigations that can span months, involving background checks, surveillance, recorded online conversations and interviews. Investigators do not pursue people who chat online but never show up at a planned meeting location.

Since 2018, which is when the unit was founded, more than 270 people have been prosecuted in connection with these investigations, Swanson said.

He said the Chris Hansen segments take place in a controlled environment, and footage is not used in investigations. His office provides exculpatory video to both prosecutors and defense attorneys. He sees media partnerships such as the Chris Hansen show as a way to raise awareness and encourage victims to seek help. By contrast, he warned that civilian groups seeking viral content without coordinating with law enforcement can jeopardize investigations.

“We’re going to keep doing it, and we’re going to do it the right way,” Swanson said.

Gahler said his office has arrested at least 21 people in three separate operations in partnership with the show, adding that the public attention they generate serves as a strong deterrent.

“That’s part of why we do this job — to deter crime and prevent crime,” Gahler  said. 

Beyond the confrontation

Others disagree. Former detective Matt Irvine said public exposure can work against another important goal of an investigation: getting suspects to talk. In his experience investigating sex crimes and cold-case sexual assaults, interviews are more effective when investigators build rapport in a calm, controlled setting. 

Public confrontations designed to humiliate suspects can undermine those efforts, he said, making it harder to learn what happened or whether others may have been harmed.

High-profile sex abuse case brings test for new Ohio anti-grooming law

“Blowing somebody up and blasting them across the internet is the exact opposite of the sort of psychological environment you need to create if you want to get this person to talk to you,” Irvine said.

Texas-based former prosecutor and criminal defense attorney Veronica Chidester echoed concerns about the consequences of confronting suspects and collecting evidence without law enforcement oversight. 

Online confrontations can also create the impression of guilt before someone has been charged with a crime or had an opportunity to defend themselves in court.

Some people targeted by civilian predator hunter groups have pursued defamation lawsuits over the accusations made against them, though some cases have been dismissed or settled out of court.

But publicly accusing someone of a crime does not automatically amount to defamation. Generally, a person bringing a defamation claim must establish that a false statement of fact was communicated to others and caused reputational harm. Truth is a defense, and accurately documenting someone’s online conversations or appearance at an arranged meeting with a decoy may help groups defend against such claims. 

Chidester said the consequences extend beyond individual cases, warning of “the erosion of the criminal justice system.”

“Even if you catch somebody in this way, you may not have the elements or the evidence necessary to secure a conviction in a courtroom,” she said. She also warned that intense public hostility can make it harder to seat an impartial jury.

Laws lag behind

States generally rely on existing criminal laws to address civilian predator-hunting groups, rather than statutes specifically governing their activities. 

Some states, including Illinois, Maryland, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Tennessee, have laws declaring that only law enforcement officers can pose as a minor.  An interaction with a civilian posing as a minor may not qualify as a prosecutable offense under those specific statutes.

“Our unlawful contact of a minor statute is very clear. That’s why a lot of DAs are having difficulty with charging here,” said Callihan of the Pennsylvania District Attorneys Association. Instead, local prosecutors might only be able to charge suspects with lesser offenses, or none at all. 

Other states, including Delaware, Florida, Kansas, Michigan and Texas, do not explicitly specify who can pose as a minor in online undercover operations, potentially making it easier for civilian groups to assist law enforcement and prosecutors in bringing charges.

In 2023, Pennsylvania lawmakers considered legislation that would have allowed anyone to pose as a minor online for the purpose of identifying suspected predators. The bill stalled in committee and never reached a vote in either legislative chamber. Since then, no other states appear to have considered similar legislation, according to Stateline research.

Meanwhile, state lawmakers still face the challenge of addressing online exploitation as technology and offenders’ tactics evolve. 

“It’s almost impossible to keep up,” said Graw Leary, the law professor at the Catholic University of America.

Stateline reporter Amanda Watford can be reached at awatford@stateline.org.

This story was originally produced by Stateline, which is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network which includes Wisconsin Examiner, and is supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity.

Low-level arrests are rising despite national crime declines

9 November 2026 at 21:40
A homeless encampment under a bridge includes a tent and bags of belongings in Paterson, N.J. Arrests for vagrancy, an offense often associated with homelessness, rose 44% between 2024 and 2025, according to a new analysis by advocacy group FWD.us. (Photo by Anne-Marie Caruso/New Jersey Monitor)

A homeless encampment under a bridge includes a tent and bags of belongings in Paterson, N.J. Arrests for vagrancy, an offense often associated with homelessness, rose 44% between 2024 and 2025, according to a new analysis by advocacy group FWD.us. (Photo by Anne-Marie Caruso/New Jersey Monitor)

Arrests for low-level offenses, including vagrancy and drug possession, increased nationwide in 2025, even as violent crime continued to decline, according to a new analysis of federal data.

The analysis, which was released in late October by the criminal justice advocacy organization FWD.us, found that arrests for vagrancy, an offense often associated with homelessness, rose 44% between 2024 and 2025, while arrests for marijuana possession increased 6% and possession of other drugs rose 3%.

Arrests for immigration violations nearly tripled, rising 188% between 2024 and 2025, amid President Donald Trump’s crackdown on illegal immigration. The increase continued into 2026, with an average of 36,093 arrests per month through July — nearly four times the monthly average in 2024, according to the report.

The findings point to a shift toward more aggressive enforcement of lower-level offenses, particularly in states that have rolled back major changes to their criminal legal systems in recent years, according to the analysis. 

Voters in nearly a dozen states also backed tougher approaches to crime in this year’s midterm elections, approving statewide ballot measures that impose stricter penalties for certain offenses or tighten bail restrictions.

“There is at this point plenty of time to choose a different path from this one and to kind of redirect ourselves,” said Zoë Towns, the executive director of FWD.us.

The increases in arrests for low-level offenses also come as arrests for more serious offenses, including homicide, robbery and burglary, continue to decline, mirroring broader national crime trends.

Some of the sharpest increases in arrests for low-level offenses were concentrated in a handful of states.

Arizona, California, Hawaii and Nevada accounted for more than half of the nationwide increase in vagrancy arrests. FWD.us linked the trend in part to the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2024 decision in City of Grants Pass v. Johnson, which gave local governments greater latitude to enforce restrictions on sleeping outdoors.

Meanwhile, California and Oregon, which rolled back portions of earlier progressive drug policy changes in 2024, experienced increases in arrests for drug possession offenses other than marijuana. Those arrests rose 24% in California and 39% in Oregon.

In 2025, Black people were arrested for marijuana possession at more than four times the rate of white people. From 2024 to 2025, arrests of Black people rose nearly 10%, accounting for 83% of the national increase and 45% of all marijuana arrests in 2025.

But the analysis does not establish that the policy changes caused every increase in arrests or determine whether greater enforcement improved public safety.

The organization warned that continued growth in low-level arrests could reverse years of progress in reducing incarceration and racial disparities, particularly as states reconsider criminal justice policies amid ongoing debates over crime and public safety.

Stateline reporter Amanda Watford can be reached at awatford@stateline.org.

This story was originally produced by Stateline, which is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network which includes Wisconsin Examiner, and is supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity.

ICE releases detained Wisconsin State Trooper

9 November 2026 at 20:43
Federal immigration officers were at the Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport on March 23, 2026 to help with airport security as a partial governemnt shutdown continued. (Photo by Ross Williams/Georgia Recorder)

Federal immigration officers were at the Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport on March 23, 2026 to help with airport security as a partial governemnt shutdown continued. (Photo by Ross Williams/Georgia Recorder)

Federal immigration authorities have released a 21-year-old Wisconsin State Patrol trooper from Onalaska who was detained at an airport last week. Carel Aaron Van Der Merwe, who was born in South Africa and works out of Tomah, was brought to the United States as a child legally. After arriving in the country, his parents waited seven years for an asylum interview, according to a press release issued by the law firm Christopher & De Leon. The firm said that Van Der Merwe was included on his father’s asylum application and holds a federal work authorization which expires in 2030. 

Van Der Merwe was released after U.S. Rep. Derrick Van Orden contacted DHS and intervened on the state trooper’s behalf. A spokesperson for Van Orden told the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel that appropriate authorities will now work to resolve Van Der Merwe’s immigration paperwork and legal status. 

Attorney Marc Christopher said that while Van Der Merwe and his family are happy he was released, he should not have been detained and that it should not have required congressional intervention to resolve the matter. 

Christopher called on lawmakers to confront what he called “inhumane and wasteful detention practices and the failure of our immigration system,” by ICE under the Trump administration, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reported.

“Wisconsin trusted him to protect the public,” the law firm said in a statement after Van Der Merwe was arrested. “Now, ICE is holding him in immigration detention in Dodge County.”

Van Der Merwe joined the Wisconsin State Patrol because his pending immigration status prevented him from joining the military, according to his lawyers. The Wisconsin Department of Transportation, which oversees the State Patrol, confirmed in a statement to the Examiner that it was “aware of the situation” involving Van Der Merwe. He has worked with the department since July 2025. 

DOT did not comment on the circumstances of Van Der Merwe’s hiring, how his arrest affected his colleagues and community, or whether ICE or the Department of Homeland Security communicated with the State Patrol before or after arresting Van Der Merwe.

The statement from his attorneys said  that Van Der Merwe was detained as he prepared to board a domestic flight. He tried to explain that he had a valid work permit pending an asylum claim, but “according to Van Der Merwe the officers said they did not care, placed him in handcuffs and shackles, and transported him to immigration detention in Dodge County. ICE says it is going after people who break the law. Here, it has detained someone whose job it is to uphold it.”

Christopher said in a statement that ICE did not have to detain Van Der Merwe. “He is neither a threat nor a flight risk,” he said. “He has a home, a career, and a community he serves. How does putting him behind bars make Wisconsin safer?”

A DHS spokesperson confirmed that Van Der Merwe was taken into ICE custody on Nov. 5. Calling him “an illegal alien from South Africa,” the spokesperson said that the arrest was part of a targeted operation at the Dane County Regional Airport in Madison. Contrary to his attorneys’ statement, DHS said that Van Der Merwe “entered the country in March 2019 with legal permission to stay until September 2019.” 

The spokesperson added that, “in defiance of our nation’s laws, he overstayed his admission. This illegal alien will receive due process and remain in ICE custody pending removal proceedings.” DHS added that, “work authorization or a pending application do not confer legal status in the U.S.” The agency stated that  “DHS reversed the horrendous Biden-era policy that allowed aliens in our country illegally to jet around our country. Under President Trump, DHS will no longer tolerate this. This administration is working diligently to ensure that aliens in our country illegally can no longer fly unless it is out of our country to self-deport.” 

Christopher called the government’s claims “absurd and ridiculous,” asserting that Van Der Merwe and his family were here lawfully and waiting for immigration to process their asylum claim, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reported.

Van Der Merwe’s arrest came just weeks after an Oshkosh middle school teacher who was raised in Costa Rica was detained and deported by ICE. The teacher, Wendy Mendez,  was recognized in 2025 as an employee of the year by her school district. 

As a white South African, Van Der Merwe is part of a group that has received favorable treatment from the Trump administration.

In 2027, the Trump administration is limiting the number of refugees it admits to the United States to   17,500 people, most of whom will be white South Africans fleeing what they say is persecution under the Black majority government of their country. Even as his administration has targeted immigrants from Latin America for deportation, President Trump welcomed white South African farmers and falsely claimed that white South Africans — the descendants of Dutch and French colonialists known as Afrikaners  — were the victims of genocide. 

Van Der Merwe’s family arrived in the U.S. during Trump’s first term, when he was 14 years old. As they were awaiting processing of their asylum claim, Trump signed an executive order saying the U.S. would “promote the resettlement of Afrikaner refugees” based on the claim that they faced anti-white racial discrimination. 

Van Der Merwe graduated from the Wisconsin State Patrol academy in 2025, as Gov. Tony Evers looked on. 

More reports of immigration arrests at airports stem from increased collaboration between the Transportation Security Administration and ICE, according to CBS News. TSA has been identifying noncitizen travelers who are “easy targets” for federal agents seeking to meet high quotas for immigration arrests.

Gov. Evers joins criminal justice advocates at gala

9 November 2026 at 09:45

Gov. Tony Evers listens to EXPO honoree Tamra Oman, a formerly incarcerated person who now works helping people currently incarcerated in Wisconsin prisons. (Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

The Wisconsin Examiner’s Criminal Justice Reporting Project shines a light on incarceration, law enforcement and criminal justice issues with support from the Public Welfare Foundation.

Tamra Oman, the recipient of the Ramiah Whiteside Changemaker Award at the EXPOnentially Correcting the Narrative 2026 gala in the  Madison Concourse Hotel ballroom on Saturday night, recalled her first meeting with Jerome Dillard, the former executive director of Ex-incarcerated People Organization (EXPO) in 2003. They met in a basement with 30 people and raised $35 for a group called Voices Beyond Bars.

She contrasted that small start with the large gathering Saturday of criminal justice advocates and those they represent, along with Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers, Wisconsin Secretary of the Department of Corrections Jared Hoy and Evers’s chief legal counsel and chair of the newly created Commutation Advisory Board, Mel Barnes.

“We have formerly incarcerated leaders,” she said of those in attendance. “We have Department of Corrections leaders. We have the governor of the state of Wisconsin. We have family members,” Oman said, adding, “30 people in a room to a 450 count.”

The Saturday event was a collaborative effort between EXPO, an organization of formerly incarcerated people working for a better future for those impacted by incarceration, and The Community, a statewide organization assisting people inside prisons and after their release.

Both EXPO and The Community, each founded in 2014 and launching gala celebrations in 2020, were celebrating the sixth anniversary of their annual events, so the two organizations decided to hold a joint event.

“Bringing two organizations together for anything can be difficult, especially something that is much of our identity as an annual celebration,” said Shannon Ross, the executive director and founder of The Community. “We all have our own practices and our own traditions and our own ideas, but if we can’t come together on things that are large and difficult like this, how can we ask the system and ask society for criminal legal system change?”

The event included  a phone tree where attendees could  listen to recorded conversations between people in prison and their family members. There was also artwork by artists who had been incarcerated, and a large display of framed posters of people who had served their time in prison but, after years of supervision and being responsible members of society, were still facing more years of parole or extended supervision. The exhibit questioned supervision over five years.

Ross said crime survivors are not helped in the criminal justice system because it is built to be adversarial and doesn’t lean toward healing but “fear-based mannerisms.”

“Tonight we are going to hear from someone who is very familiar with both sides of a criminal collision,” said Ross, introducing crime survivor  Melissa Ludin. 

“Today I come into this conversation as someone who has caused harm, and someone who has lost a loved one to violence,” said Ludin.

Melissa Ludin spoke about being both an offender  and victim of crime. (Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

She told how at age 19 she attempted suicide because of the grief of losing her father. She drove her car into an intersection and, she said, “caused devastating harm to other people and many families.”

She received a 25-year sentence and said in six months she would finish 20 years of supervision.

“Over those years, I’ve made amends, including with the person I harmed,” she said, “and I’ve worked to become someone that my children can look up to and depend on. Then I found myself on the other side of violence.”

She recounted the death of Chad Wilson, a criminal justice advocate who worked with Ludin and with whom she had a child. He was killed on Dec. 21, 2021, intentionally run over by a woman he had only known for 24 hours.

Ludin described how she struggled with wanting the woman to receive justice but also suffer.

“Justice meant she needed to answer for what she had done,” she said. “Vengeance was part of me that wanted her to hurt because we were hurting, and I felt both.”

She remembered speaking at the Wisconsin Resource Center, and knowing that the woman who had killed Wilson was in the audience. She questioned whether she wanted to be there, but then finally asked to shake the hand of every woman in attendance, including Wilson’s killer.

“I don’t know her full story, but people who cause harm can also have been victims themselves, and I know what it is to carry pain without knowing what to do with it,” Ludin said. “Understanding that matters if we want to prevent harm and accountability matters, too.”

Marriane Oleson, co-executive director of EXPO, thanked Gov. Evers for bringing back commutations, a reduction or modification of a criminal sentence under the state’s constitutional authority, using his authority to issue executive orders.

“Thank you for the hope of being seen for who a person has become,” she said. “Shannon and I, with others in this room, hear every day from people holding that hope very carefully, people who have spent years understanding the harm they cause, who are preparing to come home. They are trying to imagine where they could belong. We also recognize the people who have been harmed. Their healing deserves support, and every decision about someone’s future carries real responsibility. I know something about rebuilding a life. I began as an EXPO fellow less than two years after coming home from prison, and today I stand here as the co-executive director. It’s given my life purpose.”

Ross noted the special exhibit for those on supervision who are hanging by a thread, and their photo spinning represents the tenuous nature of being associated with anyone who violates their supervision and also being vulnerable to having their freedom revoked and being sent back to prison just on an allegation.

“Many people on paper (supervision) try to stay out of getting involved and participating in a lot of things in the public and civic space because they don’t feel they’ll be given the benefit of the doubt if something happens when we’re trying to just help people,” he said.

The family of Alejandro Silva, an incarcerated man, was given an award for supporting him while he is still incarcerated.

“I’m just, so you know, grateful and thankful and appreciative for everything that they do for me,”  Silva said on a recorded phone call.

Delilah Franklin, wife of Dennis Franklin, the co-executive director of EXPO, and a member of the Silva family, spoke of her admiration for the family.

The Silva Family was honored for their support of family member, Alejandro, who is in prison. (Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

“When someone is sentenced, their family serves a sentence, too,” she said. “They may not be behind those walls, but they carry the heartache, the worry, the sleepless nights, and the silent pain comes, to see someone they love in prison. And somehow they still have to get up every morning, go to work, take care of their families, and carry on with a life while a piece of their heart is somewhere else. That is exactly what the Silva family does. They travel for visits, sometimes multiple times a week. They make the video calls, answer the phone, include Alejandro in family decisions, and make sure even the youngest nieces and nephews know him, love him, and build memories with him. They refuse to let incarceration erase Alejandro’s place in their family.”

Democrat Evan Goyke (right) and Republican Michael Schraa. (Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

Former Assembly representatives Michael Schraa (R-Oshkosh) and Milwaukee City Attorney Evan Goyke, who previously served as a Democratic state representative, were honored for their bipartisan efforts to advance criminal justice legislation, including making vocational training part of the state’s earned release program.

Schraa and Goyke both said that, even though they were on opposite political sides, they became friends and found common ground on legislation.

Goyke celebrated the recent wave of midterm election victories by  Democrats, but cautioned that legislation passed without bipartisan support can be repealed. He offered the example of a “package of criminal justice reform bills called justice reinvestment” passed between 2006-10 by a Democratic Legislature and governor, only to be rescinded under the Republican administration of Gov. Scott Walker. 

Marty Dunmore, the founder of the Dunmore Project was honored for creating an organization that collaborates with other groups to promote safety and healing.

Dunmore lost a daughter to cancer in 2019 just before her 18th birthday, and then subsequently two other daughters were injured, one fatally, in an accident caused by a fifth-time drunk driver, and then a year later the daughter who survived the vehicle injury died by gun violence.

Marty Dunmore featured in a video about her experience of losing three daughters and forming the Dunmore Project (Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

“And at the end of the day, I am just a mother who has lost three children, two of which were so preventable,” said Dunmore on video. “So we have to go back to the preventive measures, restorative justice, to meeting people, meeting the youth where they are.”

Marian Wasierski of the citizen’s group Enough is Enough, addressing reckless vehicle driving, said Dunmore was an inspiration.

“Marty refuses to remain frozen in the moment of shock to be seen only as that mother broken by cruel death and immobilized by profound grief,” said Wasierski.  “Marty refuses to allow her sorrow to undo her bottom line, her non-negotiable tenet that the goodness of her girls will never be lost or forgotten.”

Dunmore said she had experienced unimaginable grief, and the Dunmore Project was one place to focus her love for her daughters and share it with others, hoping it will make a difference.

Ronald Watson, another honoree, was nominated by Focused Interruption, a volunteer group that addresses gun violence in Dane County.

In his video presentation, Watson recounted his successful efforts to reintegrate into society after leaving prison in 1993, including working in the restaurant industry, making connections in the community, getting married, starting a family, and staying accountable to his support system.

“I just want to continue to do the work and help other people, no matter how small it be,” he said. “I just want to help others,”

Anthony Cooper, CEO and founder of Focused Interruption, said of Watson, “This brother here is a man of integrity. He continues to want to do the right thing for the right reason, and not just sometimes, but all the time. He wants to make sure he continues to honor his family, continues to honor the work that he’s doing, and continues to honor the community that he’s attached to.”

“Tamra has touched thousands of lives,” said Dillard, introducing Oman for her award. “That’s no exaggeration.”

Oman said she had met Ramiah Whiteside, the namesake of her award, while he was still in prison, and he impressed her because he advocated for others, not knowing if he would ever gain his freedom.

Recorded phone calls between those incarcerated and their family member could be heard by picking up a phone at this exibit. (Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

“When I think about what it means to be a change maker, I don’t think about grand gestures,” she said. “What I think about is someone who refuses to accept the world as it is because it can be better. Yes, a change maker sees the possibilities, but other people see just problems. A change maker sees people for who they are, not what they did, but what they can be. Most of all, change makers believe that every single person has value, and every life has the power to create something meaningful.”

Gov. Evers was the last to be honored for restoring the pardon advisory board and pardoning over 2,400, offering commutations and pursuing criminal justice reforms.

“We’ve also expanded the successful earned release program, and we provided the highest level of funding ever for the state’s treatment and diversion program to help reduce recidivism and get folks the resources they need to use,” said Evers. “We also expanded the popular Windows to Work program, enabling more folks to participate in programming that increases general work skills, financial literacy, and work search abilities that will help them to be successful after they’re released.”

He noted the recent opening of the Type One Southeast Regional Care System for Youth in Milwaukee, which he said, “represents nearly a decade of work to transform a failed juvenile correction system.”

He added, “last year I introduced a corrections reform plan to modernize our deteriorating prisons, stabilize our population, and expand evidence-based programming to improve public safety and efficiency in the system. This includes expanding community-based options for alternatives to revocation. As well as providing meaningful supports for those facing housing instability, substance use recovery, reentry programs, and more.”

“Unfortunately, Republicans have rejected these common-sense proposals without offering any comprehensive alternatives of their own; my plan is still the safest, fastest, and cheapest option to overhaul the state’s dated correctional system. Every day of delay or inaction makes projects costlier and the goalposts that much harder to reach.”

He encouraged the audience to keep pressure on state leaders to pursue reforms that “keep our communities safe while giving folks the second chance that they deserve.”

Correction: An earlier version of this story misspelled the name of Melissa Ludin. We regret the error.

Violent, property crime victimization rates fell in 2025, federal data shows

6 November 2026 at 18:10
Crime scene tape surrounds an entry to the Barus & Holley engineering building at Brown University. The rate of violent crime victimization declined 25% between 2024 and 2025, while the rate of property crime victimization fell 19%, according to the U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics’ preliminary National Crime Victimization Survey. (Photo by Christopher Shea/Rhode Island Current)

Crime scene tape surrounds an entry to the Barus & Holley engineering building at Brown University. The rate of violent crime victimization declined 25% between 2024 and 2025, while the rate of property crime victimization fell 19%, according to the U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics’ preliminary National Crime Victimization Survey. (Photo by Christopher Shea/Rhode Island Current)

A new federal report released the week before Tuesday’s midterm elections found that Americans experienced declines in several categories of violent and property crime victimization in 2025, including aggravated assaults, burglaries and motor vehicle thefts.

The preliminary survey findings from the U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics offers a fresh look at crime trends as the country emerges from another election cycle, providing new data on Americans’ experiences with crime, including incidents never reported to police.

The rate of violent crime, excluding simple assault, declined 25% between 2024 and 2025, while the rate of property crime victimization fell 19%, according to the agency’s National Crime Victimization Survey.

Unlike crime statistics based solely on offenses reported to law enforcement, the National Crime Victimization Survey captures both reported and unreported crimes. The nationally representative survey interviews people aged 12 or older about their experiences with violent crime, excluding homicide, and household property crime. It also collects information about the frequency, characteristics and consequences of those incidents.

The preliminary survey results are consistent with other national crime data, including the FBI’s Uniform Crime Reporting program, which tracks crimes reported to law enforcement and has documented several years of declining crime rates nationwide. Preliminary FBI data suggests those declines have continued into 2026.

Independent analyses, including crime trends reports from the nonpartisan Council on Criminal Justice, have identified similar patterns, with declines reported in some of the nation’s largest cities. However, crime trends vary across communities, with some experiencing different patterns.

“To see that those things really align, it gives me much more confidence that I’ve had over these past several years that what we’re seeing is a real decline in crimes beyond homicides,” said Thaddeus Johnson, a senior fellow at the council. Johnson also is an associate professor in criminology and criminal justice at Georgia State University.

Violent crime declines

Americans aged 12 or older experienced an estimated 7.5 million violent victimizations in 2025, a rate of 25.7 victimizations per 1,000 people, according to the report.

The rate of violent crime excluding simple assault fell from 9.9 victimizations per 1,000 people in 2024 to 7.4 per 1,000 in 2025, a 25% decline. 

Aggravated assault rates dropped from 4.5 victimizations per 1,000 people in 2024 to 3.1 per 1,000 in 2025 –– a 31% decrease. The rate of simple assault victimization decreased slightly from 18.8 per 1,000 people in 2024 to 18.3 in 2025.

The robbery victimization rate declined 27% from 2024 to 2025, while the rate of rape and sexual assault victimization fell 11%.

Property crime also falls

U.S. households experienced an estimated 14.9 million property victimizations in 2025, according to the report.

The rate of property victimization declined 19%, from 138.0 victimizations per 1,000 households in 2024 to 111.2 per 1,000 in 2025.

Motor vehicle theft recorded one of the largest decreases, with its victimization rate falling 30% over the year.

The rate of burglary or trespassing declined 25%, while other types of household theft fell 19% and vandalism decreased by nearly 11%.

Survey redesign and limitations

The Bureau of Justice Statistics fully transitioned to a redesigned National Crime Victimization Survey in January 2025, changing how the agency collects information about Americans’ experiences with crime.

The agency redesigned the survey to improve how it identifies and measures crime victimization. The updated questionnaire uses shorter, more specific questions intended to help respondents recall incidents they may have experienced, including crimes that were never reported to police.

The redesign also expands questions about sexual assault, victims’ experiences with law enforcement and the consequences of crime. The agency cautioned that estimates from the redesigned survey cannot be directly compared with those produced using the previous version.

The preliminary 2025 estimates may change when the agency publishes its final report, which is expected to be released next year.

Stateline reporter Amanda Watford can be reached at awatford@stateline.org.

This story was originally produced by Stateline, which is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network which includes Wisconsin Examiner, and is supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity.

Wisconsin Deflection Initiative aims to keep people out of  the criminal justice system

6 November 2026 at 09:00

The Wisconsin Deflection Initiative offers peer support, job counseling and other services to help keep people from becoming entangled in the criminal justice system. (Getty Images)

The Wisconsin Examiner’s Criminal Justice Reporting Project shines a light on incarceration, law enforcement and criminal justice issues with support from the Public Welfare Foundation.

School districts often identify students they call “at-risk” who might have a learning disability or low reading or math scores in order to  provide them additional resources and attention to help them keep pace with their classmates and avoid dropping out.

In the Wisconsin Deflection Initiative, the “at-risk” people are in the community at large. They might have mental health or addiction issues, and the objective is to provide support to create stability and help them steer clear of the criminal justice system.

Eau Claire County is one of roughly 11 counties in the state that have a deflection program under the Wisconsin Deflection Initiative. The county started the program in 2024 under an opioid abatement efforts law enforcement grant that involves a partnership between the sheriff’s office, the public health department, human services, and criminal justice services.  

“Deflection, in its truest form, is really to try to be a preventative program that we can intervene when people are having difficulties in their lives before a major kind of event happens,” said Brianna Marsden, recovery and justice service manager for the Eau Claire County Department of Human Services

It’s a voluntary program for people who are at least 18 years of age, live in the county, have completed an assessment, have agreed to case management, and have no warrants or pending felony charges.

The Eau Claire County’s deflection program website states that the program “prioritizes connecting people experiencing substance use and/or mental health challenges with the care and resources they need—particularly in low-level, non-violent situations—while promoting healthier outcomes for individuals, families, and communities.”

With so many jails and prisons in Wisconsin filled with people who also have addiction and mental health problems, the deflection program offers a proactive, preventive alternative to incarceration.

“We’re really trying to look at where there are the gaps in our system and how can we help that? How can we prevent these bigger things from happening in people’s lives?” said Marsden.

Those “bigger things” could be accruing a large financial debt or having felony charges, spending time in jail, losing a job or acquiring a social stigma that shadows one’s life.

Currently, Marsden said, there are about 30 people in the deflection program in Eau Claire County, and a total of 50-60 have been served since the program began.

It’s often law enforcement personnel responding to a crisis who make a referral to the deflection program.

“Law enforcement gets sent to many different calls throughout their day, and the vast majority aren’t criminal in nature,” said Eau Claire County Sheriff Dave Reiewestahl. “Whether it’s mental health, substance use, there’s a variety of reasons why we get called, and the hope is that we can pair that person up with somebody in peer support and a case manager, you know, walks alongside that person, so they don’t get involved in the criminal justice system.”

People can also apply for the program or self-report online.

“We get some of our people already connected to some resources in our community, like sober living, who could use a little bit more support, or they’re already connected with peer support from our jail, and community members can send in referrals for other community members,” Marsden said.

To promote the deflection program, the county has also produced informational videos airing at Kwik Trip gas pumps and ads on city buses and social media.

“It’s low-barrier, free services for individuals,” said Marsden. “You don’t have to have Medicaid. You don’t have to have insurance. We’re not charging you for anything. It’s really trying to be in that space to help people when they’re ready for help.”

After applicants fill out an  online application, they receive a call within 72 hours to determine interest in the program. Then there is an  intake meeting where participants sign an informed consent form and are connected to  peer support specialists. The specialists often have struggled with the same kinds of problems facing  their clients, but have received training to become mentors. 

Marsden said the pillars of the deflection program are case management, helping to secure resources and peer support.

The concept of flagging “at-risk” students, she said, is very similar to the deflection program effort to help “at-risk” people in the community.

“We know something is going to likely happen if we don’t intervene,” she said, “so let’s just intervene so that nothing really big or significant happens.” 

The power of peer support

Emily Nichols is a certified recovery coach and operations manager for At the Roots LLC, which provides services through certified peer support specialists and certified recovery coaches.

“The provider often helps with practical things,” she said. “That might include rides. It might be setting up or getting to appointments. It might be completing paperwork or following up on leads for things like housing. Because we know those are the barriers that often derail somebody’s recovery, and once that recovery is derailed, they’re definitely at risk for becoming involved in the legal system.”

Nichols said it makes a huge difference that the peer support and recovery coaches working with clients know first hand what their  clients are going through.

“Even if somebody is maybe wary of the system, oftentimes peer support or recovery coaching is an easier way for them to kind of get the help and support that they need without feeling like they’ve kind of been sucked into the system,” she said. “I think it’s easier for people to talk to folks who have been where they are and have actually been successful, to kind of keep that hope alive.”

Her agency does a brief screening with potential clients and asks such basic questions as: “Are you going to answer the phone when we try and get hold of you?”

The agency matches the participant with someone who has a similar demographic and life experience, and they meet once a week.

“Oftentimes we’re meeting with individuals before they’ve done their intake into deflection because we’re trying to get them help as quickly as we can,” she said. “We do some goal setting with the person, kind of figure out if they have any basic needs they need met, and then kind of get talking about recovery capital and what they have going on in life.” 

Help can mean different things to different people, from processing past trauma to working on communication skills to getting their most basic needs for food and housing met, she said. 

The goal is to help clients manage their lives and not live in a constant state of crisis, but there are times when additional help is needed. Mentors have given clients rides to appointments, helped them deal with the social service bureaucracy and apply for benefits. 

“We have people who have said they truly have just never felt listened to before,” Nichols said. “So it was the first time they had somebody who would listen to them without judging or offering unsolicited advice. We’ve had individuals who came to us unemployed and with engagement from the cops, and after six months of the program, some of them have done things like enroll at the technical school. We’ve had people get jobs.”

Some clients, she added, worked on interview skills through the program and were successful in finding employment. Others began attending recovery meetings,  “which, while that sounds like a small thing, it’s helping them build a healthy community, which replaces some of the relationships that maybe they need to leave behind them.”

“I think the biggest thing from our perspective is if we can reduce the level of harm that people are facing, whether that’s with the legal system, or it’s by stopping or reducing drug use,”  Nichols said.  

“We’ve extended people’s opportunity to survive and exist … you cannot put a price on that,” she said.

Nichols thinks the most important thing  the deflection program offers clients is community connection,  helping them feel secure and participating and living in the community, and confidently exploring interests without falling back into destructive habits.

“Oftentimes, the people that end up in the deflection program just don’t have anyone else who is supportive of them in that way, and we do very little advice giving, and a lot of guided listening,” she said. 

‘This has helped me the most’

Mae is a young woman who has struggled with addiction. She had recently been released from jail when she learned about deflection. At first she was skeptical and asked, “What’s the catch?”

But then Mae, who meets with a therapist, sat down with her peer support specialist and liked the fact that the woman helping her had similar experiences.

“It was great because I was able to relate to her on different things during our meetings, like domestic violence things, recovery-related things, mental health and substance abuse,” she said. “It didn’t feel clinical. Out of everything that I’ve tried, that’s like recovery-related oriented stuff, this has helped me the most and I feel the most supported and the most seen and understood.”

Mae meets one hour a week with her peer specialist, and they talk about how her week has gone. They work on positive self-talk and learning coping skills to support Mae’s recovery and also address her anger.

The peer specialist doesn’t just find resources for Mae; she shows her how to research and look for resources herself.

 “She shows me, and we do it together so that I don’t feel like I don’t know how to look and find resources on my own when we are done meeting,” Mae said.

In two months, Mae will leave the deflection program and transfer to Comprehensive Community Support (CCS), a voluntary Medicaid-funded community-based psychosocial rehabilitation program, where she will keep her peer specialist and have a team to support her as she pursues recovery.

“I would not have known about it (CCS) if it wasn’t for being in the deflection program,” she said.

Mae knows another person in deflection, also struggling with addiction, who was referred to by a law enforcement officer, and she says that person is doing well.

“And I hear people talk about it (deflection) in support groups or recovery groups like NA (Narcotics Anonymous) or AA (Alcoholic Anonymous), and they also speak highly of it,” she said.

Just being able to talk about her pursuing recovery, she said, is growth because in the past she’s always pretended not to have a problem.

“I’m getting more comfortable talking about it,” Mae said. “I think that’s part of just accepting what I’m going through and being okay with it and coming out on the other side, because I haven’t been this far yet in my mental health and substance use recovery. It’s like coming through on the other side and being OK to talk about it and accepting myself and what I’m going through and giving myself grace.”

Mae has been so inspired by her growth and working with her peer support specialist that she envisions herself one day being a certified peer specialist herself.

Sheriff support

Sheriff Dave Riewestahl is very supportive of the deflection program.

“Historically, law enforcement has really three options when responding to the needs of the community,” he said. “We can leave that person there. We can arrest that person if they’ve committed a crime, or if they’re having a medical or mental health emergency, they get to go to the hospital,” he said.  

“Deflection gives our staff a fourth option. Yes, that person remains in the community, but we don’t just walk away. We’re able to get them linked up with DHS, with a case manager, and start working on that individual’s needs.” Peer support, he said, seems to be the  … “secret sauce”:  “They have a greater rapport, a greater ability to affect that person than somebody with a badge.”

Riewestahl said that when the case manager in his office talks with Marsden about people in the deflection program and he hears names he knows from previous interactions with law enforcement, it reassures him that those people have someone in their lives who can make a positive difference.

“Nobody wakes up and says, you know, I want to be homeless, or I want to be a criminal,” he said. “There are a multitude of reasons why somebody ends up in the criminal justice system — underlying traumas, historical trauma, family trauma, mental health, AODA, you name it. The hope is that we can work with that person sooner when the problems and the issues are maybe easier to fix. Because once somebody gets incarcerated and has a criminal record, the barriers just get bigger and harder to overcome.”

Beyond Bars celebrates writing and writers reaching out from inside prison walls 

28 October 2026 at 08:00

Louise K. Waakaa'igan reading her poems at Beyond Bars: Voices of Incarceration. (Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

The Wisconsin Examiner’s Criminal Justice Reporting Project shines a light on incarceration, law enforcement and criminal justice issues with support from the Public Welfare Foundation.

Louise K. Waakaa’igan, a poet and member of the Anishinaabe (Lac Courte Oreilles Band of Lake Superior Chippewa) tribe in Sawyer County, Wisconsin, spent 16 years at the Shakopee women’s prison on the outskirts of the Twin Cities. Waakaa’igan was one of the 19 writers featured at a program called Beyond Bars: Voices of Incarceration.

The event, held on Oct. 24 at Hamline University in St. Paul, was the 15th public reading organized by the Minnesota Prison Writing Workshop, made possible by a grant from the Minnesota State Arts Board.

Some of the writers, like Waakaa’igan, had been released and now have jobs on the  outside. Waakaa’igan is the event coordinator at Lac Courte Oreilles Ojibwe University in Wisconsin. Others are still incarcerated and their writings were read by other authors or by a writing mentor or instructor.

More than 500 people filled the large, open venue at Hamline University overlooking the campus. The mood was upbeat. Writers who had recently been released got standing ovations, and all who had spent time in prison received flowers.

All of the writers in attendance who had been released from prison received flowers. (Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

Waakaa’igan, who has participated in several of the past events since 2020, said she started writing when she was young as a way to “survive early adolescence,” but had stopped writing as an adult until she was in prison and a volunteer group encouraged her to start writing again in 2004.

“That’s really where my voice solidified, where I had an actual writing community for the first time in my life,” she said.  “Just a circle of writers where we would give each other feedback, where we’d be able to share, learn different aspects and different pieces of the craft, which was really beneficial.”

In 2014 Jennifer Bowen, the founder of the Minnesota Prison Writing Workshop, came to Shakopee, and helped expand the prison writing program with support from a large group of mentors who give feedback to incarcerated writers and instructors who teach in the prisons and provide a “creative community” to encourage writers.

“It’s just a creative, collaborative, supporting community that recognizes the writer, whether they’re incarcerated or not, recognizes the writer as an essential part of our creative life,” Waakaa’igan said of the Minnesota Prison Writing Workshop.

Bowen spoke of her appreciation for the writers and those who came out to support them.

Jennifer Bowen, the founder of Minnesota Prison Writers Workshop, talked about her admiration for the writers and also the people supporting them (Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

“The incarcerated writers you all have sent thousands, literally thousands, of notes of feedback to, have long written under pressure, under surveillance, and toward change,” she said. “They’ve told us stories about 600 days in segregation, about surviving the Khmer Rouge, about missing their daughter on her birthday every single year for 21 years. Many of those writers are home now, joining us as citizen artists on pages and stages and in the streets, showing up to offer change as artists and the art when it’s most needed, which is now. And they are building nonprofits that connect and organize and heal this community.”

The readings kicked off with a student introduction by an incarcerated writer named Andrew  (read by Tarik Dobbs) who described himself as serving more than one life sentence. He recounted not caring about writing when he joined a workshop in prison just to pass the time, but then found something more:

“Writing gave me my life back, or at least made my fate and future possible, tolerable. And more often than one might think, for someone serving multiple life sentences, enjoyable — the  kind of joy and serenity only possible when one finds a sense of purpose, a reason for being. For me, this meant, in some part, the self-expression, the catharsis that comes from any writing, as small as one word on a post note or a magnum opus on the meaning of the universe.”

Waakaa’igan read “East of Cicero,” a poem that recalls memories of abuse and struggles experienced after leaving the reservation:

“The year was 1999. They just buried half my identity. I refused to attend the ceremony after talking with Ni maama (Ojibwe word for mother). Instead, I sat in the dark, carving scars on my anemic body, dirtying my pale skin blending tears with Mad Dog 20/20, burning stale cigarettes in my nephew’s sandbox. I began driving alone back then, replacing reservation roads for out-of-state freeways…I met my first demon there on I-94 east of Cicero. He silenced me like those drunk hands did in Six Mile. I laughed as I flicked my Newport out the window. I’m not a little girl anymore. I bragged. I’ll fight back this time. It was his turn to laugh, and he did, mimicking that drunken slur that left boozy saliva on my five-year-old body? …It wasn’t until I slept in that cement cell block in Minnesota that he let my tears dry on their own. Those saltless tears pulled next to me on that cement floor pitied me, just as that demon den east of Cicero.”

Louise K. Waakaa’igan (left) with her daughter Janey Trepanier and granddaughter Arya House. (Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

Commenting on her poem, she said, “There are traumatic events in people’s lives, that I think, unfortunately, happen when we’re young that we learn how to recover and heal from, and I’m not exempt from that, and there have been things that have happened in my life that I’m still trying to recover and heal from, and my writing has definitely been a way to make sense of some of that and move on and heal in a way.”

She also read a poem written in prison about the place that shaped her:

“…I’m from Packer games on Sundays, Greyhound trips for Christmas, and Easter baskets with Karla. I’m from women with the same last name and a father none of us knew. I’m from the woods, northern, where pines and birch bark blanket both ends of tribal roads, paved and gravel. I’m from a single parent household. Michael Jackson cassette tapes, Purple Rain posters, and latchkey kids. Title V programs, commods (commodities, federal government issued food) on pantry shelves, cucumbers from Grandpa Jake’s garden and a mean ol’ dog named Turkey. I’m from ‘crying won’t change anything,’ and ‘you should have known better.’ I’m from punitive silence and where it’s normal, hugs are warm, forced Catholicism still weighs heavy on Imam’s shoulders. This is where I will always return.”

The poem, she said, was a kind of “sweet lamentation,” of the place she couldn’t return to because of incarceration.

Von Johnson, a writer recently released from prison and now on supervision, read his poem “Here Now!” describing the hardships in prison and then being released into society where he was adjusting to the freedom, figuring out who he spend his free time with,  learning new technology, enjoying his first savoy steak, but also the continued accountability to the criminal justice system living with an ankle monitor:

Von Johnson read his poem “Here now.” (Frankj Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

“I have to fill out a pass to go everywhere, even to come here tonight. Noting the time to leave, how long the drive will take, the moment I arrive, the purpose of being in each destination. My selfie game is out of control, except there’s always some address or giant logo next to my face to identify that I reached my destination, as if this ankle monitor wasn’t enough, right? How long I will stay, the minute I leave, my travel time, the next logo-slash-address field, you get the picture. I have to have permission to see my mother. Rules on how long I can hold my significant other, but I guess I’m here now. I need permission to drive a car, own a car. I’m not allowed to finance a car. Hell, get into a car. But I’m here now…”

Mark Altenhofen, called Red because he formerly had a red beard, read his  poem, “Do you remember,” written in prison upon learning a life-long friend outside was dying of leukemia:

“…Do you remember the feel of fist against flesh when we fought? The bitter tears on our lips with “I love you” and “I’m sorry” still foreign to us. Do you remember tumbling through the dust, our blood mixing with it until we fell side by side, too exhausted to do anything but laugh? Your mom compared us to Huck Finn and Tom Sawyer. We acted out the stories written until we nearly drowned…”

After his reading, Altenhofen talked about how  the Minnesota Prison Writing Workshop helps remind people in prison that  “we’re still human beings.” That  is “huge,” he said, “because it’s really easy to lose your humanity in there, and to be reminded we’re still people. We still have people that care about us, and there’s a community out here we can come back to. … It gives us something to hold onto and to look forward to, and to make ourselves better men.”

He added, “I was one of those guys I didn’t know how to talk about emotions. I treated emotions like I was a diabetic and that was sugary cereal for kids.” Writing, he said, was “a way to get to deal with the stuff I never had a chance to deal with, I never had the courage to talk to anybody about.”

Peter Schilling has mentored seven writers through the  Minnesota Prison Writing Workshop.  He said writers in prison often are processing their experience in a way that helps them cope. He noted one of his mentees wrote a Western, with wide open spaces that speak of unrestricted freedom as a counterpoint to his confinement, and another wrote a horror, modeled on a Steven King novel, transposing real struggles into the stories of fictional characters.

Will sang his original song “Among these Voices.” (Frank Zufall/Wisconsin Examiner)

Michael Kleber-Diggs, a writing instructor in prisons since 2015 and board president for Minnesota Prison Writing Workshop, said the evening event represented an effort to “transcend prison walls and reach the community,” and also to “tear down the distinction between incarcerated writers and community writers.”

One of the evening’s last offerings was an original song written by a man named Will, who had recently been released. He performed  “Among these voices,” an anthem to living courageously: “Justice, burn my lips come roaring off my tongue. Set me alight to set me free. This tide has risen to make many voices one. Among those voices you’ll find me.”

Teen found not guilty of homicide in Lincoln Hills counselor death

28 October 2026 at 02:32
Lincoln Hills detention facility

Lincoln Hills, the youth prison plagued by problems in Wisconsin. (Photo courtesy of the Wisconsin Department of Corrections)

The Wisconsin Examiner’s Criminal Justice Reporting Project shines a light on incarceration, law enforcement and criminal justice issues with support from the Public Welfare Foundation.

A jury has found Javarius Hurd, 18, not guilty of reckless homicide in the death of a youth counselor at the Lincoln Hills School for Boys. Hurd was, however, found guilty of battery by a prisoner. 

Hurd had been charged with reckless homicide in the death of Corey Proulx, who died after a confrontation with Hurd in 2024. Prosecutors said that Proulx chased Hurd after the then 16-year-old threw a cup of soapy water in another staff member’s face. Proulx chased Hurd into an outdoor recreational area where, in a scuffle with Hurd, he hit his head on a hard surface. 

After Proulx’s death, the Department of Corrections issued a statement that staff members were collectively mourning. In a press release sent out after the incident, the DOC said that Proulx’s fiancee and daughter “would like everyone to know that Corey was an amazing partner, father, and human being.” 

Hurd’s case became a flashpoint both in and outside of the courtroom. While his attorneys battled prosecutors unsuccessfully to prevent the case from being tried in adult court, Proulx’s death was used by Republican lawmakers to take shots at the approach to juvenile justice taken by Gov. Tony Evers.

Lincoln Hills had become notorious as one of the nation’s largest juvenile prisons where youth suffered abuse and excessive force while guards and counselors were under pressure from  staffing shortages. Recently, Lincoln Hills was found to be in compliance with the requirements set forth after a class action lawsuit over those conditions. As a result, court-ordered monitoring of the facility was halted as new, smaller facilities are being opened around the state. 

A sentencing hearing for Hurd has been set for Friday morning, Oct. 30.

Analysis: Trump deportations near 1M, but few are criminals

23 October 2026 at 02:50
An Avelo Airlines jet in October 2025 in Mesa, Ariz., for use by Immigration and Customs Enforcement for deportation and detainee transfers. The second Trump administration deported nearly a million people as of July 31, according to a new analysis. (Photo by Jerod MacDonald-Evoy/Arizona Mirror)

An Avelo Airlines jet in October 2025 in Mesa, Ariz., for use by Immigration and Customs Enforcement for deportation and detainee transfers. The second Trump administration deported nearly a million people as of July 31, according to a new analysis. (Photo by Jerod MacDonald-Evoy/Arizona Mirror)

The current Trump administration claims its mass deportation efforts have expelled nearly a million people through July of this year, but those include both voluntary returns and people turned around at the border, according to a new analysis by the former chief statistician for the Department of Homeland Security.

The level of deportations is sharply higher than during the Biden and first Trump administrations but well below the level of the 2000s. Deportations peaked at about 1.9 million in fiscal year 2000 as border enforcement ramped up under a sweeping immigration enforcement law in 1996.

Former DHS official Marc Rosenblum did the analysis, using only public records, for the Migration Policy Institute, a non-partisan think tank for immigration research. Rosenblum resigned in protest in July against what he called the Trump administration’s “war on immigrants.” He had been with DHS since 2016 and executive director of the statistics office since 2023. 

Rosenblum emphasized in his analysis how many non-criminals have been either forcibly deported or pressured to leave voluntarily. Only 20% overall — and 28% of those in the U.S. for at least two years — have a criminal conviction.

“These data here do not suggest the administration is deporting the worst of the worst,” Rosenblum said.  

Even among convicted criminals, he added, the records were more likely to be immigration or traffic infractions rather than violent or other more serious crimes. 

DHS officials have maintained that living in the country illegally is enough reason to be deported. Tom Homan, the administration’s so-called border czar, told a Florida audience Oct. 1 that deportations have ramped up this fall and will be even higher in 2027. He was speaking to a Hispanic leadership event near Miami sponsored by the America First Policy Institute, a conservative think tank.

“Mass deportation is happening,” Homan said. “I think September’s going to be the highest deportations of any month in the history of ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement). Right now we’ve arrested more people than in the history of this nation.” 

He added later, “Wait until you see what we do next year.”

Rosenblum tallied 980,000 deportations, including arrangements to leave voluntarily after arrest, during the second Trump administration through July 31, about 18 months. About 300,000 had been arrested inside the United States, but most deportations were from the U.S. border with Mexico. There, 680,000 people were either turned around at the border or arrested at the border and deported after processing. 

The number of people leaving the country without being arrested is disputed — DHS earlier this year claimed more than 2.2 million “self-deportations,” apparently based on a decline in immigrant population in surveys. Others dispute that number, saying it’s more likely immigrants are avoiding government surveys. 

In his analysis, Rosenblum estimated the number of immigrants leaving of their own accord — not including people who had formal agreements to leave voluntarily — at between 310,000 and 1.5 million for immigrants who had been here at least a year. The departures include legal immigrants and those who had been living here illegally. 

Rosenblum’s estimate of departures, other than deportation, is imprecise, relying on Mexican census data on its returning citizens to estimate a “plausible level of departures” for other nationalities. 

The numbers in his analysis include people making arrangements to leave voluntarily rather than continue their court cases or contest a return at the border, about 170,000.  It may not include some people who came forward voluntarily to claim financial assistance to leave from the Project Homecoming program. 

Stateline reporter Tim Henderson can be reached at thenderson@stateline.org.

This story was originally produced by Stateline, which is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network which includes Wisconsin Examiner, and is supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity.

Gov. Tony Evers tours new Milwaukee juvenile facility for 32 boys

15 October 2026 at 08:30
Gov. Tony Evers looks at different rooms inside the Southeast Regional Care Center for Youth. (Photo | Isiah Holmes)

Gov. Tony Evers looks at different rooms inside the Southeast Regional Care Center for Youth. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

Gov. Tony Evers toured a new Milwaukee juvenile facility on Wednesday along with Department of Corrections leaders, closing another chapter in the troubled history of the Lincoln Hills and Copper Lake youth prisons. The sleek, colorful new facility looked like  a well-resourced though highly secure school. The Southeast Regional Care Center for Youth, or SERC, will house 32 boys who are in the DOC’s custody. 

While serving their sentences the boys will have access to educational programs, a gym, a greenhouse and other opportunities to help prepare them to return to their communities. Since many of the boys will be from the Milwaukee area, the new $65.6 million facility will make it easier for their families to visit compared to Lincoln Hills, hours away in Irma, Wisconsin. 

The Southeast Regional Care Center for Youth. (Photo | Isiah Holmes)
The Southeast Regional Care Center for Youth. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

“This new facility marks a historic milestone for our state and is the beginning of what I hope is a real, meaningful transformation of not only juvenile corrections in our state but of corrections in Wisconsin,” Evers said. “Not only will this new facility allow us to safely move our kids closer to their homes, their families, and their support systems, but it will give kids and families hope for a brighter future. With evidence-based strategies, this new facility will provide young people the role models, educational opportunities, and support needed so they can grow, be better, and do better, all while helping to reduce crime, prevent violence, and keep our kids, families and communities safe.”

SERC is located on Milwaukee’s North Side, tucked away a few blocks  from a busy roadway just north of Good Hope Road. At first glance the tan brick building resembles a small school, but a closer look reveals  large tinted windows and a few State Patrol vehicles parked outside. Walking through the front door, visitors come to  a metal detector station in a  front lobby with light colored walls, tiled floor and chairs. 

Wednesday’s official  tour of the new facility began with a visit to the SERC’s chapel. Next, Evers was guided by DOC Sec. Jared Hoy and DOC juvenile corrections administrator Lance Horozewski to an outside area surrounded by a high brick wall and security gate, where Evers viewed a basketball court and a large greenhouse next to  raised garden beds — one for each boy which the facility will house.

Classrooms within the Southeast Regional Care Center for Youth. (Photo | Isiah Holmes)
Classrooms within the Southeast Regional Care Center for Youth. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

Heading back inside, Hoy and Horozewski showcased medical facilities with individual exam rooms and areas where youth can access needed dental care. There was also a large kitchen, and spaces where youth could learn welding and woodworking. Evers also looked over visiting areas complete with games and kiosks for video visits, a large indoor gym and basketball court and classrooms. Evers also checked out a creative room where the boys will be able to make and record music, and even make videos using a large green screen.

The area where the boys will be housed was  behind a door, which will be controlled by staff monitoring from an adjacent room. A common space contained couches, tables, a couple of phones and games. Down the hall were dorm rooms with wood floors and gray metal furniture, with one bed per room, a toilet, desk, and a window with a view of the outdoors, with a blind the boys can open or close. 

The design of SERC is intended to forge a new direction for juvenile incarceration in Wisconsin. For years, the Lincoln Hills and Copper Lake schools were  notorious for reports of abuse and suffering for both youth housed there and the staff responsible for their care. Earlier this year, a federal judge ended mandatory oversight of Lincoln Hills and Copper Lake after the DOC had been found to be in “substantial compliance” with reforms mandated after a 2018 class action settlement.

The garden and greenhouse area of the new juvenile facility in Milwaukee. (Photo | Isiah Holmes)
The garden and greenhouse area of the new juvenile facility in Milwaukee. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

Lincoln Hills’ troubled history led the Legislature to spend years planning to close the 500-bed facility, convert it to an adult prison, and open up smaller and safer juvenile facilities which would also be closer to home for the youth housed there. 

Evers appeared to approve of SERC as he walked through its halls. “But our work is not over — far from it, ” he said in a statement. “Our state is decades behind in how we think about corrections, and this new facility is the first step, but it is only a step. We must continue our work to modernize our corrections system into the 21st century and close Lincoln Hills and Copper Lake schools for good.”

Hoy said that looking around SERC “you see a school, not a prison.” He went on to say in a statement that “that’s because it is a school and even more. It’s a place to learn and to heal. There’s no barbed wire. No towers. There are big windows, color, space. And it’s all secure both for the youth and for the neighborhood. The design supports what we now know about adolescent development, and the programming offered here will follow suit with staff using evidence-based techniques to help youth make better choices and support rehabilitation.”

Hoy said at the beginning of November the first group of youth will be moved into SERC, with more to come over the following months into the holidays. “We’ve been recruiting for staff starting back in the summer,” said Hoy. “And so we’ve had two graduating classes already. We’ll have more than adequate staff. Not just safety staff — so your youth counselors that are here  — but education, treatment, all of those different functions are already on board…And then we will continue to staff up. We have another class graduating, I think at the beginning of November.”

Keana Berkhalter (Photo | Isiah Holmes)
Keana Berkhalter (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

Staffing shortages had long plagued Lincoln Hills and other DOC facilities. Hoy told the Wisconsin Examiner that the DOC has paid particular attention to staff-to-youth ratios for the SERC to help prevent burnout among staff, and has established staff wellness spaces. Hoy also said that “the space itself lends to a sort of feeling of wellness and calmness.”

Another Type 1 facility is being constructed in Dane County which is designed to hold 32 boys and eight girls. The DOC is also pushing for a third facility to be opened in northern Wisconsin in order to serve youth from that region of the state. Hoy told the Examiner that having multiple facilities would allow the DOC to cross-train and pull staff from one facility to another in order to help fill any gaps and prevent burnout.

Many of the staff who will work at the new facility are from the Milwaukee area, and theoretically might have an advantage in  relating with the youth there. Kashunda Brown, 37, one of SERC’s youth counselors, explained that she grew up on the North Side of Milwaukee where she learned what it’s like to experience poverty and living in a single parent home. Brown also has two boys of her own which “resonates with the youth that we encounter here,” she told the Examiner. 

Kashunda Brown (Photo | Isiah Holmes)
Kashunda Brown (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

Keana Berkhalter, 32, a licensed counselor who will be working with the facility’s Psychological Services Unit, is also from Milwaukee. “I’ve seen the complex issues and challenges that we have here, as well as the strengths that Milwaukee has,” Berkhalter told the Examiner. Berkhalter said that it’s important that youth know that the staff understand them because it helps them feel safe. “As human beings, it’s easier to connect to people that look like us, or at least that we have some sort of similar commonality.” 

The experiences the counselors share with the youth help them to connect. “I think that gives me leverage to connect to the youth, as well as help them feel safe and to talk to me and to want to trust and confide in me, to talk about things that maybe they don’t want to talk to anybody about.”

Brown said the greenhouse, raised beds, and creative spaces are especially important for the boys SERC will house. To anyone who questions whether the facility should feel more punitive, Brown says, “I think the punitive is them being away from their family.” 

Gov. Tony Evers (Photo | Isiah Holmes)
Gov. Tony Evers (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

She continued, “this should be, and is, a space where they can have different things that they don’t experience on the outside. A lot of people don’t have access to a basketball court at home. A lot of people don’t have access to gardening.” These translate into coping skills the boys can take home with them to avoid getting in trouble. 

Youth who learn that they enjoy woodworking, cooking, growing food in the garden or other activities available at SERC could take that with them and become more productive members of society, Brown said. “I think all the skills that they will get here, they can use on the outside. The punitive is them being in here.” 

Milwaukee County covers Flock cameras, moves away from controversial tech

14 October 2026 at 07:34
A Flock camera in Milwaukee County covered after local officials decide to remove them from county parks. (Photo courtesy of Milwaukee County)

A Flock camera in Milwaukee County covered after local officials decide to remove them from county parks. (Photo courtesy of Milwaukee County)

Milwaukee County is a step closer to getting rid of Flock automatic license plate reader cameras. On Monday, joined by county board members, Milwaukee County Executive David Crowley signed a resolution directing the removal of Flock cameras from county parks.

“Today is about our commitment to protecting the rights and privacy of our residents,” said Crowley, who is running for governor against Republican U.S. Rep. Tom Tiffany.  “Across the country, the use of Flock cameras and automated license plate readers, or ALPRs, has sparked a fierce backlash that defies traditional partisan lines. Residents and lawmakers on both sides of the aisle are asking whether the convenience of this technology is worth the cost to our privacy, and who is accountable for how it is used.”

The Wisconsin Examiner’s Criminal Justice Reporting Project shines a light on incarceration, law enforcement and criminal justice issues with support from the Public Welfare Foundation.

Flock cameras store images of traveling vehicles and their license plates in a database which can be searched by law enforcement using license plate numbers or vehicle descriptions. 

Although police can use the AI-powered cameras to investigate crimes such as homicide, kidnapping and theft, they have also been used to track protesters and women suspected of crossing state lines to seek an abortion. There have also been numerous cases in Wisconsin and elsewhere of officers or police staff using Flock to track romantic partners and exes. In some areas, local police chiefs and elected officials have expressed a distrust of Flock Safety, the multi-billion dollar company behind the cameras. 

Both Crowley and Tiffany have criticized Flock, though Tiffany said just months ago that he did not know what the cameras were. Since then Tiffany has proposed prohibiting shared revenue funds from being used for Flock cameras, and has labeled Crowley as an advocate of constant surveillance. Police surveillance cameras were  adopted in Milwaukee as the city and county sought to tamp down reckless driving and car theft with the support of  Republican lawmakers. 

Crowley said that in Wisconsin, “Flock executives have shown a pattern of misleading the public about their business practices, their safety record, their commitment to privacy, and their efforts to protect vulnerable populations.” He added that, “nationwide, we have seen documented cases of law enforcement officials misusing this data for personal and often malicious reasons.”

Though Crowley said that none of those cases involved Milwaukee County employees, but two officers with the city’s police department have been charged or sentenced for misusing Flock. 

Milwaukee County Executive David Crowley signs legislation removing Flock cameras from county park property. (Photo courtesy of Milwaukee County)
Milwaukee County Executive David Crowley signs a resolution removing Flock cameras from county park property. (Photo courtesy of Milwaukee County)

Crowley said that while he appreciated the sheriff’s office work on a policy framework to address concerns about Flock, “even the strongest policy framework is only as trustworthy as the company behind the technology, and a good relationship with the vendor does not safeguard our residents’ data.” 

“‘It hasn’t happened here yet’ is not a good enough reason to keep this technology in place,” he said. “We cannot wait until data is breached, privacy is compromised, or information is misused before we act. When it comes to our residents’ rights and safety, we must be proactive.”

Milwaukee County’s contract with Flock expires in December, and the proposed 2027 budget does not include funding for Flock. Last week, teams of Milwaukee County Park workers began covering the cameras to prevent them from collecting data. In recent public meetings, the sheriff’s office pushed against the cancellation of Flock, attributing a 43% decline in certain crimes within county parks to the camera’s arrival, and warning that crime will rise should they be removed. Recently, the Milwaukee Police Department signaled that it would renew its own contract with Flock while also employing new auditing and other guardrails to detect further signs of misuse.

“Our residents should be able to enjoy our beautiful parks without wondering whether their presence is being logged in an AI-powered surveillance system run by a company that has already lost the trust of local governments and law enforcement agencies across the country,” Crowley said. “Today, Milwaukee County is choosing to put our residents first. And I will keep making that choice, every day, in every decision.”

Researchers point to community violence programs, pandemic recovery in historic homicide decline

13 October 2026 at 22:13
Police investigate a crime scene where three people were shot at a housing complex in Chicago. A new survey of nearly 50 crime scholars points to community violence intervention programs, pandemic recovery and focused deterrence as potential contributors to the historic decline in homicides in the United States. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)

Police investigate a crime scene where three people were shot at a housing complex in Chicago. A new survey of nearly 50 crime scholars points to community violence intervention programs, pandemic recovery and focused deterrence as potential contributors to the historic decline in homicides in the United States. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)

As candidates debate public safety ahead of the midterm elections, a new assessment of the nation’s historic homicide decline suggests there is no single explanation for the drop — and that some widely discussed enforcement strategies may have played little role.

A survey of nearly 50 crime scholars convened by the nonpartisan Council on Criminal Justice found the strongest support that the top contributing factors to the drop in homicide rates have been community violence intervention programs, the easing of pandemic-related disruptions, and focused deterrence strategies that pair law enforcement with social services.

The findings come amid a historic national decline in homicide. In 2025, the estimated U.S. murder and nonnegligent manslaughter rate fell 18.1% compared with 2024, which equates to about 4 killings per 100,000 people. It tied the lowest rate recorded since national estimates began. The FBI recorded the same rate in 1955 and 1956. 

But a national decline does not mean every community has experienced the same drop.

The decline has unfolded in cities with different public safety strategies, economic conditions and political leadership, complicating efforts to credit any one approach, according to the council’s report.

The researchers rated 48 potential explanations for the decline between 2022 and 2026. Six factors received support from more than two-thirds of respondents as contributing either substantially or to a limited degree:

  • Expanded community violence intervention programs, which work directly with people at highest risk of violence, were rated as either a major or a limited contributor contributing by 91% of researchers. 
  • The pandemic recovery was rated as a major or a limited contributor by 83% of respondents. It was the only factor that a majority of respondents, 57%, rated as a major contributor.
  • Eighty-three percent of the crime scholars gave credit to the increased use of focused deterrence, an approach that targets high-risk individuals and groups directly with a carrot-and-stick approach through social support and law enforcement.
  • Researchers also pointed to increased local government capacity to provide social services, with 75% rating it either a major or limited contributor.
  • Greater public safety and support resources relative to demand earned a rating of 68%.
  • And more proactive policing was likewise named as a major or limited factor by 68% of the scholars.

Researchers largely dismissed more than half of the potential explanations, including National Guard deployments, increased immigration enforcement and increased pretrial detention. 

Other factors thought to have contributed little included homeless encampment removals, improved housing stability, electronic monitoring, GLP-1 medications, declining cash use, presidential public safety signals, DNA databases, neighborhood crime alerts and increased incarceration.

The findings do not establish that any one strategy caused homicide to fall. The ratings reflect researchers’ professional judgments, not definitive findings, and multiple factors may have overlapped or reinforced one another, according to the council’s report. 

The council also cautioned that a factor judged to have contributed little to the recent decline could still help reduce violence in the future.

But understanding what drove the decline could help policymakers determine how to sustain the progress, according to the council’s report. 

“Theories and claims abound, and sorting among them is essential if we’re going to sustain the progress. This diverse array of researchers took the challenge seriously, testing competing explanations, debating the evidence, and making tough judgments,” Adam Gelb, the president and CEO of the council, said in a news release. “Their effort leaves the country with a much clearer picture of what likely contributed, what probably did not, and what we still need to learn.” 

Stateline reporter Amanda Watford can be reached at awatford@stateline.org.

This story was originally produced by Stateline, which is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network which includes Wisconsin Examiner, and is supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity.

Dane County proposes $3 million for sheriff body camera program

13 October 2026 at 18:03

West Valley City, UT patrol officer Gatrell starts a body camera recording by pressing a button on his chest. (Photo by George Frey/Getty Images)

A $3 million capital investment to equip Dane County sheriff’s deputies with body cameras has been included in the proposed 2027 county budget. Dane County Executive Melissa Agard and Sheriff Kalvin Barrett praised the move as an investment in public safety. 

“Public Safety is one of the most fundamental responsibilities we have in county government, and our residents deserve to feel safe and have confidence in the people and institutions that serve them,” Agard said last week. “This $3 million investment is about strengthening safety, transparency, and public trust. Body-worn cameras can provide greater clarity when questions arise, strengthen accountability, and help protect both members of the public and the deputies who serve them.”

The Wisconsin Examiner’s Criminal Justice Reporting Project shines a light on incarceration, law enforcement and criminal justice issues with support from the Public Welfare Foundation.

A county press release states that a Wisconsin Department of Justice Survey found that 88% of responding law enforcement agencies reported using at least one form of recording device. The survey found 12% of responding agencies reported using neither body cameras nor dash cameras. 

Sheriff Barrett called body cameras “an important resource that supports accountability, transparency, and trust.” Barrett added that “this investment will enable us to build on the work we began with our pilot program and move Dane County forward. The funding reflects what can be accomplished when we collaborate with our community partners and elected officials toward a shared goal. I especially appreciate County Executive Agard’s leadership and support in making this possible.”

The sheriff’s office is also finalizing policies for the cameras including how to use them, how long footage is retained and when it can be released.

Body cameras became a hot topic in Dane County after the shooting of Corey Ruiz by a Madison police officer. The officers involved in the shooting were not wearing body cameras, leaving bystander video as the main public video evidence of the incident. The Madison Police Department, despite being one of the state’s largest, does not have a uniform body camera program. After the Ruiz shooting, community members called on city officials to equip all officers with body cameras.

“Technology alone does not create trust,” said Agard. “It matters how that technology is used and whether the public understands the policies surrounding it. As we make this investment, we are committed to ensuring transparency and accountability remain at the center of implementation.”

Criminal justice advocates disappointed by GOP attacks, Crowley’s jail tablet messaging suspension

13 October 2026 at 08:15
David Crowley, Milwaukee County Executive, speaks to media after he relaunches his campaign in July to become Wisconsin's next governor. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

David Crowley, Milwaukee County Executive, speaks to media after he relaunches his campaign to become Wisconsin's next governor. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

For weeks, a stream of ads has attacked Milwaukee County Executive David Crowley, the Democratic candidate for governor, for allowing  access to tablets in the Milwaukee County Jail. In some high-profile cases, incarcerated people used the tablets to harass people on the outside. The ads, which recycle footage of a disgruntled local judge, have kept Crowley on the defensive while casting his Republican opponent, U.S. Rep. Tom Tiffany, as a protector of crime victims. 

The ads focus on individual cases of people using their jail-issued tablets to harass witnesses and victims. Many feature Milwaukee County Circuit Court Judge David Borowski, who asked,  “Why is the sheriff’s office handing laptops and iPads to defendants?” Borowski was presiding over a hearing involving Thomas Zollicofer, who is accused of killing three people in a spree. Zollicofer used his tablet to tell a witness to “stop lying,” WISN 12 News reported. Some of the ads also mention Ameir Jones, who is also accused of homicide and of attempting to call a victim in his case over 1,500 times, with prosecutors saying 300 of those calls were answered.

The Wisconsin Examiner’s Criminal Justice Reporting Project shines a light on incarceration, law enforcement and criminal justice issues with support from the Public Welfare Foundation.

Over a short span of time, the anti-Crowley ads have made tablet access a big issue in the governor’s race. Late last week, Crowley suspended instant messaging on digital tablets at the Community Reintegration Center. The facility, formerly known as the House of Correction, is under more direct oversight by Crowley and the county board than the jail, which is overseen by the sheriff’s office. 

On Monday Brian Schimming, chairman of the Wisconsin Republican Party, issued a press release accusing Crowley of protecting himself from a scandal. “This program should’ve never been allowed in the first place, and Crowley resisted ending it for months after victims were threatened and laws were broken,” said Schimming, going on to call Crowley “a craven politician who only cares about his own political future, not the safety of our state’s citizens.”

Milwaukee-based Black Leaders Organizing Communities (BLOC), which supported Crowley when he re-entered the race for governor and won the primary race, expressed disappointment at the suspension of messaging services. “We have to be careful in giving in to the narrative of Republicans and their methods to make incarcerated people as uncomfortable as possible,” their statement warned. The group added that “this form of communication seems to be the best and safest form that there is currently.”

As the political controversy over tablets grew, the sheriff’s office attempted to clear the air. Joshua Briggs, director of the Milwaukee County Jail, said that the devices are not iPads but a “generic tablet.” Briggs explained that the tablets cannot be used to make calls out of the jail, and are not connected to the internet. The devices use a network maintained by the vendor, ICSolutions, which allows for keyword flagging and other guardrails. Briggs estimated that 98% of the people held in the jail use the tablets responsibly.

U.S. Rep. Tom Tiffany speaks to reporters after his launch event in Wausau in September. (Photo by Baylor Spears/Wisconsin Examiner)

The ads don’t mention that Republican-dominated counties including Waukesha and Ozaukee also give people housed in their jails access to tablets. 

The tablets are important, advocates say, because they allow incarcerated people to maintain connections with loved ones and others on the outside. 

“I understand what it means to have a connection to home,” Marianne Oleson, co-executive director of Ex-Incarcerated People Organizing, told the Wisconsin Examiner. Oleson, who spent four years in prison before being released in 2017, explained that tablets give incarcerated people access to recovery resources, employment preparation, parenting classes, and other rehabilitative services. 

Tablet use  has become commonplace in jails and prisons. “This technology is being used on a significant scale,” Oleson said. “Edovo reports that its educational platform was available in 1,483 correctional institutions across 47 states in 2025, with participants completing 46 million hours of learning. Those are the provider’s reported numbers, but they show how much programming can be delivered through these tools.”

Shannon Ross, a founding member of Justice Forward, wrote in August in an op ed for Wisconsin Watch that tablet-type devices are used in 48 state prison systems, the federal prison system and in county jails nationwide. “Correctional officials have credited tablets with reducing violence and disturbances inside correctional facilities,” Ross wrote. “Some jurisdictions have reported declines of up to 40%, and the director of the Federal Bureau of Prisons described the agency’s tablet program as reducing administrative burdens and allowing staff to focus more on institutional safety, not as a security risk it was forced to accept.”

The Milwaukee County Jail. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)
The Milwaukee County Jail. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

“Providing tablets is an established practice today,” Oleson told the Examiner. “Wisconsin DOC says that each person residing in an adult facility will be issued an ICS tablet as its transition moves forward. Ozaukee County’s own website says that personal letters, pictures and drawings are delivered digitally through tablets available in all living units. This is happening across jurisdictions, regardless of politics.”

Other criminal justice advocates raised similar points about the use of tablets in jails and prisons. “Allowing tablets inside jail facilities is particularly important because it allows more in-depth communication with family and friends,” BLOC said in a statement to the Examiner. “Inmates can see messages and pictures from their families and loved ones. It enables them to maintain a closer connection than that of regular phone use. Sometimes, persons in custody need their families to advocate for them for their health, treatment and more that the jail staff cannot assist with immediately.”

Oleson was also disappointed by Crowley’s move. “My reaction to Crowley’s decision is concern for the people and families who are losing legitimate communication because of someone else’s misuse,” she wrote. “Victim harassment and witness intimidation are serious, and they must be addressed. We support holding people accountable for that behavior and holding facilities and vendors accountable for enforcing protections.”

Roy Rogers, a minister, board member of the Wisconsin Justice Initiative, and leader of the Onesimus Group of Milwaukee, wrote in a statement to the Examiner that electronic communication is one of the main ways his ministry can keep in touch with incarcerated people. “For us, a message is an opportunity to encourage someone, share our faith, or help them think through their next steps,” wrote Rogers. “For families, it means maintaining a connection with a parent, spouse, or child. We say ‘reentry begins with relationship’ because those connections need to grow before someone comes home.” 

Key in Jail Cell Door
Getty Images

Rogers said that he cares about the safety and security of victims. “No one should have to fear threats or harassment through this technology,” wrote Rogers. “My understanding is that Crowley’s action pauses messaging at the CRC until stronger safeguards are in place, rather than eliminating tablets altogether. My hope is that those protections allow safe communication to continue. These tools have a meaningful place in family connection, ministry, daily facility operations, and preparation for reentry.”

“If a suspension is necessary while those changes are made, there should be a clear timeline and an explanation of what must happen for access to resume,” wrote Oleson. “I am concerned when the needs of incarcerated people and their children become talking points in a political campaign. These decisions affect real families. They should be guided by evidence, safety, and what will help people return home successfully.”

 

Clarification: An earlier version of this story used the words “cancellation of jail tablets” in the headline to describe Crowley’s decision to disable the use of the messaging feature on jail tablets in Milwaukee. The article makes clear that it was the messaging feature, not the tablets themselves, that was suspended, so the headline has been updated to clarify that fact.

 

Cornell case highlights the patchwork of state laws governing intoxication, sexual consent

12 October 2026 at 07:40
The Chi Phi fraternity house at the center of a rape allegation stands on the campus of Cornell University in Ithaca, N.Y. Nineteen states, including New York, limit mental incapacity under sexual assault law to cases of involuntary intoxication, such as being drugged against one’s will. (Photo by Ryan Murphy/Getty Images)

The Chi Phi fraternity house at the center of a rape allegation stands on the campus of Cornell University in Ithaca, N.Y. Nineteen states, including New York, limit mental incapacity under sexual assault law to cases of involuntary intoxication, such as being drugged against one’s will. (Photo by Ryan Murphy/Getty Images)

A former Cornell University student’s allegations of gang rape in 2024 have renewed attention on a difficult area of sexual assault law.

A person can be awake, responsive and even able to move during a sexual encounter while still being so intoxicated or impaired that they cannot understand what is happening or make an informed decision about sex.

But whether that person is considered legally incapable of consenting can depend on the state and, in some cases, on how the person became intoxicated. 

“There are a lot of very good laws on the books,” said Renée Williams, CEO of the National Center for Victims of Crime. “The problem is that nobody knows how to enforce them, including district attorneys, and enforcement varies from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, even within the same state.”

In New York, where Cornell is located, criminal law distinguishes between mental incapacitation caused by a substance administered without a person’s consent — such as being “roofied” — and other forms of intoxication. That can leave prosecutors relying on other provisions of the state’s sexual assault laws when someone voluntarily drinks alcohol or uses drugs and later becomes severely impaired.

The legal debate comes amid years of scrutiny over sexual assault and safety on college campuses, particularly around fraternity and sorority life, where alcohol and drugs are often part of the social environment. The Cornell case has brought those broader concerns back into focus while New York state lawmakers consider changes to the state’s sexual assault laws.

Across the country, sexual assault statutes vary in how they define incapacity, what level of impairment can make someone legally unable to consent and what prosecutors must prove about the accused person’s knowledge of the victim’s condition. 

Nineteen states, including New York, currently have statutes that limit the definition of mental incapacity in sexual assault law only to cases of involuntary intoxication, such as when someone is drugged against their will, according to experts. 

More than half of states also set time limits for prosecuting sexual assault. But those statutes of limitations vary by state and offense, and they can make prosecution more difficult when a case is reported years after an alleged assault, according to a review of state laws by NBC News.

Legislation on the issue has been before New York lawmakers for years, but the Cornell case has renewed attention on proposed changes to the state’s sexual assault laws. Two measures that passed the state Senate unanimously earlier this year would broaden how the law addresses intoxication and incapacity, and change the definition of “physically helpless.” 

The legislature has already adjourned for the year, but both measures were stalled in the Assembly after they failed to garner enough support for passage. Since the case came to light, the Assembly has formed a 15-member working group to examine the state’s sexual assault laws ahead of the 2027 session.

Democratic Gov. Kathy Hochul, who has assigned the state’s attorney general to investigate the case independently, has said lawmakers could consider changes to state law early next year. 

Some possible changes have drawn pushback from some criminal defense attorneys, including the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, who have raised concerns about whether the proposed language would provide enough guidance about when someone is too intoxicated to legally consent. 

“Claims that a loophole exists are not supported by the law, and proposals based on that premise risk creating confusion while eroding fundamental due process protections and increasing the risk of wrongful convictions,” the organization said in an emailed statement to Stateline. 

What happened at Cornell

The allegations date to October 2024, when the young woman, identified in court documents as Jane Doe, was a student at Cornell. She alleged that she was sexually assaulted by members of the Chi Phi fraternity, naming seven men in connection with the incident.

She said in her lawsuit that she drank alcohol at a local bar, then felt pressured by two of the defendants to snort ketamine while at a party at the fraternity chapter house, and that it was her first time doing the drug. She also wrote that she was “plied” with marijuana and “Jamaican Liquor.”

All of the men have denied the allegations, according to hundreds of pages of confidential investigative files obtained by The New York Times. Jane Doe filed a civil lawsuit in September naming the fraternity members, the fraternity, Cornell University, a local bar and her sorority, Tri Delta, as defendants. A Snapchat screenshot in the lawsuit shows a message to all Chi Phi fraternity members encouraging them to join the encounter.

Jane Doe reported the alleged assault to Cornell police in November 2024. In an interview with police, she described being severely intoxicated and said she was confident she had been raped. The subsequent criminal investigation did not result in charges.

Tompkins County, New York, District Attorney Matthew Van Houten has defended his office’s decision, saying the evidence available to prosecutors did not establish a prosecutable case under New York law, and that his office had not received the full transcript of the woman’s interview with police. The New York Times reported last week that a condensed version of the police statement sent to the DA’s office omitted that she reported being raped.

Under Cornell’s disciplinary process, two of the men were expelled, two suspended, two given lesser sanctions and one, a graduate, barred from campus. The Chi Phi fraternity chapter was closed in 2024.

But university proceedings and criminal prosecutions operate under different standards. For prosecutors, the issue is whether they can establish the elements of a specific sexual offense under New York’s criminal statutes.

That makes the state’s definitions of consent and incapacity central to the case.

Defining incapacity

The details of New York’s penal law offer a window into how seemingly narrow distinctions in legislative language can have significant implications for the outcome of a sexual assault case. 

The state’s criminal code identifies several circumstances in which a person is considered incapable of consenting to sexual activity.

One is physical helplessness. A person is physically helpless when they are unconscious or otherwise physically unable to communicate unwillingness to an act.

Another is mental incapacitation, which New York defines as being temporarily incapable of appraising or controlling one’s conduct because of an intoxicating substance administered without the person’s consent.

Those definitions can create challenges in cases involving intoxication. Erin Murphy, an expert on sexual assault laws and a law professor at New York University, said the physical-helplessness standard can be difficult to apply to someone who is severely intoxicated but still conscious.

“The failure to express unwillingness continuously means that they were not physically helpless,” Murphy said, describing current law. “Someone can kind of fall through the cracks.”

New York law also raises questions about what the person accused of the crime knew about the other person’s condition. And a defendant’s own intoxication can also be relevant.

One of the men accused in the Cornell case said he was “a victim of sexual misconduct” because Jane Doe had performed oral sex on him when he was “too incapacitated” to consent, according to the university’s investigative files obtained by The New York Times.

Voluntary intoxication

One of the most significant distinctions in New York’s law is that its definition of mental incapacitation only applies when an intoxicating substance was administered without the person’s consent, such as when someone is unknowingly drugged. 

That does not make sex with a voluntarily intoxicated person automatically legal. Other provisions of New York’s sexual assault laws address forcible compulsion and cases in which a person clearly expresses that they do not consent.

Still, the distinction has fueled what some lawmakers and victim advocates call a “voluntary intoxication loophole.” But others, including the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, deny there is a loophole.

“Proposed legislation that would brand someone a rapist if their partner is voluntarily intoxicated and later claims a crime was committed because they were “incapable of appraising or controlling their conduct” is simply too vague to be fairly enforced,” the association said in an emailed statement.

Murphy said the challenge for lawmakers is drawing a line between someone who is intoxicated but still capable of making consensual decisions and someone whose impairment leaves them unable to consent.

“Any indication they were conscious or unwilling kind of works against them under physical helplessness,” Murphy said, referring to how New York’s laws are currently written.

That line can be particularly difficult to establish when a person has little or no memory of a sexual encounter. Alcohol, marijuana and ketamine — substances Jane Doe said she consumed before and during the alleged assault — can affect memory, judgment and perception. 

Prosecutors will likely have to rely on text messages, photographs, videos, witness accounts and other evidence to establish Jane Doe’s condition, Murphy said.

Dr. Chinmoy Gulrajani, a psychiatry professor at the University of Minnesota who has studied intoxication and consent laws across the U.S., said a person’s effort to reconstruct an incident afterward can also introduce another complication. Talking with friends or other witnesses about what happened may help fill gaps in memory, but those conversations can also influence how a person remembers or interprets the encounter, and, in turn, how they report it to authorities.

“To actually figure out what actually went down and what the exact facts were can be a challenge for the legal system,” Gulrajani said.

Because a person’s condition can change during an encounter, prosecutors and juries may have to assess the evidence moment by moment, including what the accused person knew about the other person’s condition.

Varied approaches across the states

New York is also not the only state wrestling with this issue.

A national comparison is complicated because states define consent, incapacity, intoxication and sexual offenses differently. Some statutes focus on whether the victim was “mentally incapacitated.” Others use terms such as “incapable,” “impaired” or “unable to resist.” Some expressly address intoxication, while others rely on broader definitions or case law.

A 2022 research article published in the Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law found significant variation among state statutes and cautioned that courts can interpret similarly worded laws differently.

In 2021, when the review of state statutes was conducted, 21 states appeared to limit mental incapacity to involuntary intoxication only — though two states, Michigan and Texas, have since changed their laws. 

Another 25 states now recognize incapacity from either voluntary or involuntary intoxication. And six states address the issue through case law rather than statutory language, according to the research article.

“Lawmakers need to understand that a person who is mentally incapacitated due to intoxication is a vulnerable person,” said Gulrajani, the Minnesota psychiatry professor and an author of the research article. “It does not matter whether they ingested the chemical of their own volition, or it was forced on them, or they were deceived into taking it.”

Minnesota changed its law in 2021 after its Supreme Court overturned a sexual misconduct conviction involving a victim who had voluntarily become intoxicated. 

The state legislature amended the law so that the victim’s intoxication could establish incapacity regardless of whether the alcohol or drugs had been voluntarily consumed. 

Michigan adopted similar language in 2023, following years of pressure to pursue other major legislative changes to better support survivors of sexual violence.

In Texas, lawmakers added a provision in 2025 that expressly defines as sexual assault a situation in which a person knows someone is so intoxicated or impaired by a substance that they are incapable of consenting.

Stateline reporter Amanda Watford can be reached at awatford@stateline.org.

This story was originally produced by Stateline, which is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network which includes Wisconsin Examiner, and is supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity.

Milwaukee PD renews Flock contract as former detective appears in court for misuse

8 October 2026 at 07:23
A Milwaukee police squad in front of the Municipal Court downtown. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

A Milwaukee police squad in front of the Municipal Court downtown. (Photo | Isiah Holmes)

The Milwaukee Police Department intends to renew its contract with Flock Safety, the multi-billion dollar producer of controversial AI-powered license plate reader cameras. In a statement, an MPD spokesperson said that the contract will be renewed “to maintain the investigative and public safety benefits the system provides.”

Flock cameras store images of traveling vehicles and their license plates in a database which can be searched by law enforcement. While police say that the cameras are valuable tools used to investigate serious crimes like gun violence, theft and kidnapping, Flock surveillance has been criticized as an invasion of privacy. Numerous cases of officers misusing the cameras for personal reasons to surveil people have emerged around the country, including in Wisconsin. 

The Wisconsin Examiner’s Criminal Justice Reporting Project shines a light on incarceration, law enforcement and criminal justice issues with support from the Public Welfare Foundation.

Two of those cases played out in Milwaukee over the last year. Former Milwaukee police detective Tehrangi Chapman pleaded not guilty on Wednesday to felony misconduct in public office and misdemeanor misuse of a GPS device. Chapman is accused of  using Flock to track the movements of two people 20 times for personal reasons, and also of placing a GPS device on one of their vehicles. He’d kept tabs on these individuals even before Milwaukee adopted Flock in 2022. 

As an internal affairs detective, Chapman was involved in the investigation of Josue Ayala, a former Milwaukee officer who used Flock to track an ex-girlfriend and her new partner over 170 times. Ayala was given probation and avoided prison time. 

Both Chapman and Ayala were reported by the people victimized by their use of surveillance technology. Websites like haveibeenflocked.com helped them determine that they had been tracked. Two other cases of officers or sheriff’s deputies being charged for Flock misuse have also appeared in Kenosha County and the city of Menasha. 

As opposition to Flock grew in the community, Milwaukee PD has gone through a couple of phases of tightening and restricting the cameras. The department restricted access to the system to supervisors only, and limited the kinds of crimes that can trigger Flock use. Following a trend among some other agencies, MPD created a transparency portal describing how Flock is used, and restricted its network to use by outside agencies including  other local jurisdictions. One of the main appeals of Flock is the ability to conduct searches across a network composed of thousands of law enforcement agencies. 

MPD has also increased auditing of the system to flag suspicious uses. The Milwaukee County Board of Supervisors voted last week to remove Flock cameras from county property. In arguing to keep the cameras, the sheriff’s office attributed a 43% decline in certain crimes around county parks between 2023 and 2026 to the cameras. 

Their removal from county property follows a cascade of cities and towns across Wisconsin canceling their Flock contracts. Stevens Point, Fond du Lac County, Winnebago County, Sheboygan, Verona, Stoughton, Dane County, Sturgeon Bay, Appleton, Manitowoc, and  other  local governments have worked to cancel contracts and disable their cameras.

Judge dismisses lawsuit against Tosa cops for 2022 shooting

6 October 2026 at 08:00
The Wauwatosa Police Department (Photo | Isiah Holmes)

The Wauwatosa Police Department (Photo | Isiah Holmes)

A federal judge has dismissed a civil rights lawsuit stemming from the non-fatal shooting of Damiso Lee by Wauwatosa police officers in April 2022. In a court document filed in late September, U.S. District Judge Brett Ludwig said that among the reasons he issued the summary judgement were the fact that  Lee was armed with a handgun, disobeyed officer commands and attempted to run. 

A month before the shooting Lee, who was 17 years-old at the time, had reported his car stolen to the Milwaukee Police Department. Lee never called the department to say that he found the car, so it was still listed as stolen when Wauwatosa officer Evan Olson noticed it driving around one evening.

The Wisconsin Examiner’s Criminal Justice Reporting Project shines a light on incarceration, law enforcement and criminal justice issues with support from the Public Welfare Foundation.

 “The [automatic license plate reader] alert was categorized as ‘high,’ indicating that the vehicle had been involved in a felony offense,” a court document detailing Ludwig’s reasons for dismissing the case stated. The document mentions that Lee was returning home after picking up a Doordash order when he drove past Olson. He acknowledged in a deposition that he was in possession of a Glock Model 22 handgun. 

After his squad car’s automatic license plate reader system flagged the car, Olson radioed dispatch and followed Lee before deciding to conduct a felony traffic stop. He requested another nearby officer, Dexter Schleis, assist him. Lee drove into an alley behind an apartment complex and parked. “Officer Olson observed Lee open and close the driver’s door without exiting, turn the engine off, and then open the driver’s door a second time and leave it open,” Ludwig wrote. 

Body camera footage released by the Wauwatosa Police Department in 2022 shows that Olson got out of his squad and told Lee to “show me your hands” as Lee exited his own vehicle, holding the food container he’d picked up. Olson told Lee to stop and to not reach for his gun, the outline of which he said he could see in Lee’s pocket. In a report from district attorney’s office, explaining the decision not to charge Olson, Olson describes Lee as wearing a black hooded sweatshirt with a Glock logo in large lettering on the front. 

The footage shows that Lee dropped the food and turned to run away. Schleis was waiting on the other end of the alley. Olson yelled that Lee was armed and as he ran, Lee fell causing his gun to fall out of his pocket. He got back up, picked up the gun, and both Olson and Schleis fired. 

A Wauwatosa police squad on the scene of a non-fatal officer-involved shooting. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)
A Wauwatosa police squad on the scene of a officer-involved shooting. (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

In his decision to dismiss, Ludwig states that while the officers believed that “their use of deadly force was objectively reasonable under the circumstances,” Lee argued that it was not reasonable because he was running away. “Lee’s position is contradicted by the evidence presented, including video recordings of the incident,” Ludwig wrote. The judge questioned whether Olson and Schleis “reasonably believed Lee posed a threat of death or serious bodily harm based on the information they knew at the time.” 

Ludwig ruled that the license plate reader flagging Lee’s car, Olson confirming the car’s stolen car status through dispatch, and Lee’s decision to flee while armed rather than explain that it was his car led to the shooting. “Indeed, the officers gave Lee multiple opportunities to surrender before resorting to deadly force, including after he retrieved the handgun,” Ludwig wrote. 

The judge discounted arguments by Lee’s attorney, William Sulton, that video shows that Lee was facing away from officers and running when he was shot. Ludwig wrote that Lee “changed directions multiple times during his brief attempt to escape.”

Attorneys offer opposing perspectives

Sulton wrote in an email statement to the Wisconsin Examiner that Lee is considering his options for appeal but that no decision has been made. “Suing law enforcement officers is not like suing other members of society because they have qualified immunity,” Sulton wrote. “I disagree with the judge’s conclusions about what the videos show. The videos show Damiso running away from the officers. The judge saw things differently and ruled that Damiso was running towards one of the officers, justifying lethal force.” Sulton continued, “there are too many cases of officers shooting civilians who are running away from them. This will continue until different decisions are made.”

Attorney Jasmyne Baynard, who represented Olson and Schleis, wrote that she disagrees with Sulton. “Plaintiff’s counsel took no depositions and did not serve any discovery,” Baynard wrote in an emailed statement to the Examiner, noting that Ludwig’s dismissal relied on “substantive law” rather than qualified immunity. “The idea that a police officer is required to wait until a suspect points or shoots a gun before they can act in justified self-defense is contrary to the law and common sense. Police officers are also not mind-readers and can only respond to a suspect’s action.”

The Wauwatosa Police Department (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)
The Wauwatosa Police Department (Photo by Isiah Holmes/Wisconsin Examiner)

The Examiner asked Baynard whether there was anything the officers and Lee could have done differently.

Baynard said that Olson was not mistaken in stopping Lee because his car had been reported stolen and was still flagged that way in a police database. She added that “there is something Lee could have done differently —  he could have not gotten high, illegally possessed a firearm, and ignored multiple clear commands to STOP, not reach for a gun and most importantly AFTER dropping the gun, he could have just continued to run off and not picked it back up. No rational and objective review of the video (or Lee’s sworn testimony and recorded statements) supports the view that he was not a threat.”  

Lee being under the influence is not mentioned in Ludwig’s dismissal, Wauwatosa Police Chief James MacGillis’ summary of the incident, or the district attorney’s decision not to charge. A check of online circuit and federal court records also turned up no charges or citations listed under Lee’s name. 

Baynard stressed that “of course we should question an officer’s actions in these situations — in Wisconsin that is done in EVERY officer-involved critical incident.” In 2025, Baynard helped defend former officer Joseph Mensah during a federal civil trial over the shooting of Alvin Cole, Mensah’s third fatal shooting in five years. Olson and Schleis were called as witnesses during those trials, which ended in two hung juries before a confidential settlement was reached. The 17-year-old ran from police while carrying a handgun, but officers also provided contradictory statements about what happened. Mensah recently received $95,000 from the city of Wauwatosa for a PTSD claim.

Baynard wrote in a statement that “cops are subject to the court of public opinion and unable to respond. But we should also start questioning the behavior of the public. Until we stop forgiving criminal behavior, we will unfortunately continue to see cases like this where officers are forced to make difficult decisions so that they get to go home to their families.”

In 2022, after the district attorney decided not to issue charges in Lee’s shooting, Chief MacGillis spoke to the gravity and responsibility that comes with an officer’s decision to use force. “We all experience trauma when an officer-involved shooting occurs,” said MacGillis. “The injured subject, the subject’s family, the officers involved, the police department, and the community as a whole.”

❌
❌