❌

Reading view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.

Data center boom revives debate over how to plan Wisconsin’s energy future

An industrial yard contains stacks of pipes and metal equipment, with utility poles, power lines and a glass-domed structure behind a concrete wall.
Reading Time: 8 minutes
Click here to read highlights from the story
  • Wisconsin once gave the Public Service Commission broad authority to guide utilities’ long-term energy planning, but lawmakers scrapped that system in 1998, shifting more control to utilities.
  • Ratepayer advocates argue the hands-off approach incentivizes power plant construction over investments in energy efficiency and demand reduction.
  • A surge in electricity demand from data centers is driving a multibillion-dollar buildout and renewing calls for regulators to take a greater role in planning for future needs.
  • Regulators say current law limits their ability to compare competing proposals and assess major projects as a package, prompting calls for lawmakers to reconsider the state’s approach.

Wisconsin’s electricity needs are on track to skyrocket. Utilities plan to spend billions of dollars to keep up, and ratepayers — residents, businesses and data center operators — will pick up the bill. 

The three-member Public Service Commission, which regulates utilities, is responsible for guarding ratepayers’ wallets from unreasonable spending, but Wisconsin law gives it relatively little sway over how utilities plan for the future.

The commission can review proposed power plants on a case-by-case basis, but not as part of a broader blueprint for keeping the lights on as affordably as possible. 

That hasn’t always been the case. Bureaucratic gridlock and a near-blackout prompted Wisconsin lawmakers to scrap a more hands-on approach to energy planning three decades ago.

Utilities don’t mourn its loss. Ratepayer advocates, however, argue the hands-off approach that followed caused Wisconsin’s electricity prices to climb faster than necessary.

A flurry of new power plant projects spurred in part by the data center boom is pushing that once-arcane disagreement into the public eye, and regulators themselves are now taking a side.

Wisconsin once gave regulators broad planning power 

Investor-owned utilities generally operate as regulated monopolies: State and federal commissions grant them exclusive rights to sell electricity to consumers within a defined territory in exchange for government oversight of their rates and infrastructure projects.

That basic model dates back more than a century in Wisconsin, which formed its Public Service Commission — among the nation’s first utility regulators — in 1907.

The mass adoption of air conditioning and the rise of nuclear power complicated the picture in the mid-20th century. 

Wisconsin lawmakers responded in the 1970s by empowering the Public Service Commission to take the lead on energy planning, hoping to steer utilities toward the most cost-effective path to meeting skyrocketing electricity demand.

Those powers took shape as the “Advanced Plan”: 20-year road maps for utilities to meet electricity needs. Working in two-year cycles alongside consumer advocates and other players, the commission could revise the road map to fit its priorities, and especially to save ratepayers money.

“This approach requires that the utilities focus on the most cost effective means of meeting customers’ energy service needs,” the commissioners explained in a 1987 biannual report. 

Utilities have a strong incentive to build new power plants. Ratepayers pay for newly built plants, along with a commission-approved “rate of return” on every dollar spent on the projects, passed along to the utility’s shareholders. The commission could use the Advanced Plan to reconfigure utilities’ construction plans in search of savings. Later iterations embraced demand-side fixes, trimming future energy needs by incentivizing customers to switch to energy-efficient appliances or run factories at off-peak hours.

The PSC used its planning power to chip away at utility monopolies in 1989 by beginning to open utility-owned transmission lines to other power producers. Wisconsin was an early adopter of an open transmission system, hoping to keep prices in check by encouraging competition in the electricity market. State lawmakers later directed utilities to pass control of their transmission infrastructure to a new, independent company to protect other power producers’ access to the grid. That company, now called the American Transmission Company, was the country’s first multi-state, transmission-only utility. 

The PSC went further in 1993, inviting third-party developers to bid for power plant projects outlined in utilities’ long-term plans. Commissioners awarded a natural gas plant in Whitewater to a New York-based developer later that year, saving We Energies’ customers an estimated $66 million. 

Other states deregulated their electricity markets entirely. Chaos ensued, most notably in California, where flawed execution, price gouging and a drought caused regional blackouts, a major utility bankruptcy filing and billions of dollars in economic losses.

Lawmakers let utilities take the lead

Wisconsin didn’t copy California’s experiment. It did, however, scrap the Advanced Plan.

Utilities argued comprehensive planning was cumbersome and prone to gridlock, blaming it for a slowdown in power plant and transmission construction in the mid-1990s. Some commission staff also recognized the Advanced Plan’s deficiencies. 

Newspaper clipping with the headline “Governor signs bill to derail blackouts” and an article about Wisconsin electricity regulations.
An Associated Press article published in the Kenosha News on April 29, 1998. Ratepayer advocates and members of the Public Service Commission now argue that giving utilities more control over energy planning has made it harder to control costs passed to ratepayers.

“It became an anti-utility regulatory mechanism that put electric reliability at risk,” recalled Randel Pilo, the PSC’s chief energy economist through much of the 1990s. 

A close call in the summer of 1997 pushed Wisconsin’s political and business leaders, and even some ratepayer advocacy groups, to rethink the state’s approach. With nuclear power plants in Wisconsin and Illinois unexpectedly offline for repairs, utilities warned that summertime air conditioning use might stretch the state’s supply past its limits and trigger widespread blackouts.  

State lawmakers abolished the Advanced Plan the following year. They replaced it with what Pilo called a “regulation-lite” approach, leaving planning for Wisconsin’s energy future mostly in utilities’ hands. 

The PSC still considers the cost of and market justification for new power plants, but not as part of a broader strategy for balancing affordability and reliability. 

Utilities made the most of the new landscape. We Energies embarked on a $7 billion “Power the Future” construction spree only a few years later — the largest energy buildout in Wisconsin history. The present power plant construction boom may surpass that record if projections of data centers’ energy needs prove accurate. 

Shift to ‘regulation-lite’ approach

Ratepayer advocacy groups and some independent energy developers argue the “regulation-lite” approach to energy planning is taking a toll on Wisconsinites’ budgets.

“Without a robust planning process, we don’t have balance and we’re left with higher bills,” said Tom Content, executive director of the Wisconsin Citizens Utility Board. Under the current system, he argues, “utilities present their spending plans to investors eager for the higher profits that come from their build-build-build agenda.”

Had regulators retained greater energy planning authority, Content believes they might have more closely scrutinized We Energies’ investments in coal-fired generators just before the fracking boom made natural gas cheap and abundant in the late 2000s. Wisconsin’s average electricity rates — the second-lowest in the Midwest in 1998 — soared during the Power the Future buildout. They are the region’s second-highest as of August. 

An aerial view of a large electrical facility surrounded by dirt roads, open fields, railroad tracks and nearby industrial buildings
The former We Energies power plant site in Pleasant Prairie, Wis., on Nov. 13, 2025. Ratepayer advocates say greater planning authority for the Public Service Commission might have prompted closer scrutiny of We Energies’ investments in coal-fired generators just before the late-2000s fracking boom made natural gas cheap and abundant. (Joe Timmerman / Wisconsin Watch)

Former Republican Sen. Robert Cowles, a longtime ally of ratepayer advocacy groups who chaired the Senate’s energy committee at several points in his 38-year Senate tenure, voted alone against the 1998 bill. He told Wisconsin Watch that preserving advanced planning could have curbed some of those rate hikes by reducing demand through energy efficiency programs. 

“To the extent that we can avoid building additional capacity, it saves us money,” he said. 

Skeptics of the current system don’t uniformly oppose construction. A 2026 study by Advanced Energy United — a clean energy trade group that supports comprehensive planning — estimated that We Energies’ customers could have saved roughly $150 per year between 2021 and 2024 had the utility replaced its Elm Road plant with renewables and battery storage, in part by avoiding the cost of fueling and maintaining older coal and natural gas plants.

Utilities maintain that the PSC already has sufficient authority to protect ratepayer interests.

“State regulatory staff, intervenors and the public thoroughly evaluate our projects, including their costs compared to alternatives, environmental impacts, and the actual need for these new generation resources,” We Energies spokesperson Brendan Conway wrote in an email. “This robust review process ensures customers are protected every step of the way.” 

How Wisconsin compares to neighboring states

Wisconsin’s current approach to energy planning sets it apart from most neighboring states — and most of the country. 

Minnesota’s Public Utilities Commission has required utilities to develop comprehensive plans since the early 1990s. Illinois adopted the practice earlier this year, and Michigan lawmakers re-introduced comprehensive planning a decade ago during a transitional period in the energy sector. 

“We knew that there were a number of plants that were scheduled for retirement,” said Michigan Public Service Commission chair Dan Scripps, and “a better planning process was needed” to replace them. 

Michigan’s residential electricity prices nevertheless remain the highest in the Midwest, but supporters of the state’s planning approach argue other factors obscure the policy’s positive results.

“Michigan’s energy bills are driven much more by distribution system upgrades than by generation costs,” said Michigan Energy Innovation Council President Laura Sherman, citing years of deferred power line maintenance for power lines. “Without the long-term planning and competition,” she added, “I think we’d see higher generation costs as well.”

“It is effectively impossible to know what rates would be” had Michigan not adopted comprehensive energy planning, said Jonathan Kim, a Chicago-based researcher with the watchdog Energy and Policy Institute. Any number of variables — even weather — can skew comparisons between states that take a hands-on approach to planning and those that do not. 

Iowans, for instance, pay the lowest retail electricity prices in the Midwest even without a comprehensive energy planning process. Kim attributes those low prices to Iowa’s early and speedy adoption of renewables, which spare the state’s ratepayers from “fossil fuel price instability.” Renewables, and especially wind turbines, account for roughly 60% of Iowa’s in-state electricity generation, compared to about 12% in Michigan and Wisconsin.

Kim also underscored that utilities can take advantage of the long-term energy planning process at ratepayers’ expense. 

“We’ve seen utilities routinely overproject demand growth or need for new projects so that the amount they have to build seems greater,” he said. If regulators approve a utility’s construction to-do list in one go, Kim added, “the incentive for utilities to cheat the system, as well as the need for heightened scrutiny and rigorous ratepayer advocacy, grow even stronger.”

Data center boom revives planning debate

With a massive energy buildout on the near horizon, even Wisconsin’s regulators are joining the push to rethink the state’s energy planning paradigm.

The Public Service Commission’s most recent draft strategic energy assessment — a biennial forecast introduced as a nonbinding Advanced Plan substitute — projects Wisconsin’s energy use will climb by roughly 40% over the next five years, driven mostly by new data centers.

We Energies’ parent company alone expects to spend nearly $47.5 billion on new infrastructure over that time frame. 

Those plans await commission approval on a project-by-project basis. Among them: a pair of natural gas plants in southeastern Wisconsin. 

We Energies isn’t building the plants itself. That responsibility falls to Invenergy, the nation’s largest independent energy infrastructure developer.

The same 1998 law that axed the Advanced Plan also streamlined permitting for independent  “merchant plants” built to sell electricity on the wholesale market — a move lawmakers believed would spur competition. Invenergy’s proposed plants in Kenosha and Walworth counties qualify for that streamlined review, preventing commissioners from scrutinizing their price tags. 

Invenergy brought the plants to the commission for approval last year. We Energies promptly applied to buy the facilities to power its data center customers for a combined $2.3 billion; that price tag has since climbed to roughly $2.8 billion. 

While We Energies must still prove the natural gas plants would provide more reasonable prices than generators powered by a different fuel, it need not demonstrate that Invenergy offered a better deal than competing developers. Microsoft, which plans to “subscribe” to the Kenosha County plant’s power and pay for its purchase, declined to comment.

Wisconsin utilities have used the same maneuver at least a half-dozen times since 2018, mostly to develop solar and wind farms.

“When developers like Invenergy develop a project, they take on all the risk and responsibility of making that project viable, that protects our customers,” Conway wrote.

Tall electrical transmission poles and power lines stretch across a grassy field beneath a cloudy blue sky, with an industrial building in the distance.
High-capacity power lines serve Microsoft Corp.’s Fairwater data center in Mount Pleasant, Wis., on Sept. 24, 2026. (Andy Manis for Wisconsin Watch)

Commission Chair Summer Strand isn’t convinced. Speaking at the commission’s Oct. 15 hearing on Invenergy’s applications, Strand argued Wisconsin’s “piecemeal, often whack-a-mole approach” to energy planning enables the end-around.

Strand and her fellow commissioners emphasized that current law leaves them unable to consider the We Energies-Invenergy deal as a package, even if doing so could help identify a more cost-effective alternative. The commission approved Invenergy’s permits last month; it has yet to weigh in on We Energies’ purchase plans.

“The deficiencies in the current framework are ripe for legislative action,” Strand said.

Outgoing Gov. Tony Evers proposed granting the PSC comprehensive planning powers in his most recent draft budget, but the Republican-controlled Legislature rejected the provision. The question now falls to Gov.-elect David Crowley and a new Democratic-majority Legislature.

Pilo likewise believes Wisconsin’s energy planning model needs “modest reform,” even as he recalls the Advanced Plan’s flaws. In his view, a “major transformation” in Wisconsin’s energy sector calls for a planning model more focused on affordability, competition and “public stewardship.” 

Ratepayer groups enthusiastically agree.

“It’s long overdue that we give the state the tools it lacks,” Content wrote in an October press release. “Until we do, the PSC is trying to guide the state down the ‘energy future highway’ without a GPS, or even a map.”

Editor’s note: This story has been updated to correct a figure related to planned infrastructure spending. WEC Energy Group, the parent company of We Energies, plans to spend $47.5 billion across its portfolio. A previous version incorrectly attributed that figure to We Energies alone.

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

Data center boom revives debate over how to plan Wisconsin’s energy future is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

We Energies customers face another rate hike — but smaller, as regulators push back on utility

A red oval sign with white lowercase letters "we" is mounted on the light gray exterior wall of a building beneath a dark roofline.
Reading Time: 9 minutes

We Energies customers are in for another round of rate hikes over the next two years, although not as steep as the utility first proposed.

Wisconsin’s Public Service Commission voted Thursday to approve a roughly 7% increase in We Energies’ electricity rates spread across 2027 and 2028 — the utility’s sixth consecutive rate hike. The utility expects an average residential customer’s monthly bill to rise between $7 and $8 per month in 2027 and again by between $6 and $7 the following year. 

The utility will direct much of the new revenue toward emerging renewable energy, natural gas and battery storage projects. It comes after We Energies, which serves more than a million customers in Wisconsin and parts of Michigan and Illinois, touts a roughly $10 billion increase to its capital spending plans over the next five years.

The company initially proposed a roughly 9% overall electricity price increase, including a 16% hike for residential customers, over the next two years. 

We Energies’ rate increases have outpaced inflation for the past three years, and commissioners sought to pump the brakes during Thursday’s 10-hour hearing.

“I do not believe we can ignore the cumulative impact of years of increases simply because each individual increase can be explained by a particular investment or expense,” Commissioner Kristy Nieto said at the hearing’s outset. “When customers are experiencing some of the highest rates in the region” and the utility is delivering strong returns for its shareholders, she added, “we have to ask whether the scales are properly balanced.”

The commission pared back the increase on multiple fronts, including by lowering the utility’s guaranteed “rate of return” —  the amount We Energies shareholders earn on each dollar they invest, passed along to ratepayers on their electricity bill. Market forces also play a role: We Energies’ fuel costs are also set to dip next year, as are those of Wisconsin’s other major utilities.

Their rewrite came two days after Wisconsinites voted to send a Democratic trifecta to Madison in 2027, with a new governor and legislative majorities poised to steer the largest energy buildout in Wisconsin’s living memory. The commission’s chair made clear on Thursday that she wants lawmakers to overhaul the state’s utility regulation rules. 

What is We Energies’ new rate of return? 

We Energies’ shareholders typically earn a 9.8% return on their investment, though that rate rises to roughly 10.5% or more for dollars spent building infrastructure to power data centers.

The company asked the commission this year to bump its rate of return to 9.9%, which it was as a “conservative” increase needed to attract new capital.

The request prompted outcry from — among other critics — Walmart. In testimony filed with the Public Service Commission in September, the retail giant called the request “unjustified,” saying it would push We Energies shareholders’ profit margins above the national average — and even higher when accounting for profits from new data center customers.

Walmart did not propose an alternative, but the Wisconsin Citizens Utility Board called for lowering the rate by nearly a percentage point.

Commissioners split the difference Thursday, setting the rate at 9.5%. The decrease from We Energies’ original ask will save ratepayers roughly $60 million over the next two years as the utility ramps up construction. 

Do the rate increases include data center-related costs?

We Energies proposed the rate increase in March, when the utility still awaited commission input on a pitch to bill ratepayers for a quarter of the costs of building new power plants for new data center customers. The utility offered to offset those costs for non-data center ratepayers with revenue from selling the plants’ surplus electricity on the wholesale market. 

Commissioners rejected that plan a month later, instead ordering We Energies to assign the power plant construction costs directly to its current and future large data center customers. 

A pending agreement between We Energies and Oracle, a partner in the Project Lighthouse data center campus in Port Washington, could also save ratepayers millions. 

The tech giant reached an agreement with We Energies last month to “subscribe” to a share of the Point Beach Nuclear Plant’s electricity output. Fueling that plant – Wisconsin’s largest — is increasingly expensive; the price of a megawatt of Point Beach electricity will rise more than 7% under We Energies’ current contract with the plant’s operator. The utility estimates that granting Oracle rights to a share of the plant’s output would spare other ratepayers roughly $300 million in fuel costs over the next five years. The commission has yet to approve the agreement.

Ratepayers could still pay for a portion of transmission infrastructure built to serve data centers. Transmission cost sharing is mostly outside the Wisconsin Public Service Commission’s authority. 

Those powers rest with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which is considering a proposal from the American Transmission Company — the utility that owns and operates most of Wisconsin’s grid — to charge data center operators based on their projected transmission needs. 

Microsoft, the operator of the sprawling new data center in Mount Pleasant, has pushed back on that plan, arguing the transmission company could overbill it for infrastructure without providing an opportunity to protest. 

How did regulators respond to We Energies’ cost overruns?

Commissioners attempted to clamp down on We Energies’ recent overspending on renewable energy projects by limiting its shareholders’ profits from a southeast Wisconsin solar and battery project.

The commission allowed We Energies in 2022 to purchase a large planned solar farm and battery storage facility in Kenosha County from an independent developer for $433 million.

The solar farm went online in late 2024; the battery facility followed less than a year later. Their final price tag exceeded the commission-approved figure by nearly 40%.

WEC Vice President of Regulatory Affairs Richard Stasik attributed the overrun to inflation, component shortages and delays tied to a then-new law requiring customs officers to confirm that the project’s solar panels weren’t made using forced labor in China’s Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region. 

Commissioner Marcus Hawkins noted that the labor law — and many of the other economic forces behind the overspend — existed before We Energies sought permission to buy the  facilities. Hawkins argued that the utility’s leaders “chose to put their head in the sand” instead of identifying those risks in their purchase request, leaving ratepayers to absorb any unexpected spending.

While the commissioners allowed We Energies to bill ratepayers for the full cost of the projects, they barred the utility from earning a profit on the $166 million in unapproved spending.

“We need to deny something,” Hawkins said, explaining the decision would pressure utilities to be more transparent about the risks of budget overruns when proposing to build or buy new infrastructure.

The commission plans to revisit two other multimillion-dollar overspends in the utility’s next rate case. We Energies’ Darien Solar Energy Center in Rock and Walworth counties is 35% over budget; the utility’s Koshkonong Solar Energy Center in Dane County is 42% over budget. Neither project is fully online as of November.

Unlike the Kenosha County facility, the commission approved the Darien and Koshkonong projects on the condition that We Energies cannot bill ratepayers for any amount above their  original price tags.

How did regulators try to ease the burden of retired power plants on ratepayers?

We Energies’ customers still owe roughly $1 billion for the utility’s “stranded assets” — power plants and generators retired before the utility’s customers fully paid off their value. When the utility pulled the plug on its once-mighty Pleasant Prairie coal plant in 2018, for instance, ratepayers still owed $775 million toward We Energies’ investment in the plant, plus a return for shareholders. 

“Retiring these plants saves customers millions of dollars in avoided operations and maintenance costs and hundreds of millions of dollars in additional costs for ongoing capital investments when compared to their original expected retirement dates,” Stasik testified earlier this year.

With more retirements on the horizon, consumer advocates pushed the commission to lighten the financial burden the now-demolished generators place on ratepayers. 

The commission took a moderate approach on Thursday, extending the timeline for We Energies to recoup its investments in the “stranded assets.” The longer payment period will reduce customers’ monthly payments on the remaining balance by spreading those costs over six additional years. Commissioners also voted to limit shareholder profits on the defunct plants. The Wisconsin Industrial Energy Group, which represents manufacturers and other large electricity customers, estimated those changes will save ratepayers at least $30 million by 2028.

An aerial view shows an electrical substation beside large paved lots with patches of blue, surrounded by grassy fields, roads, ponds and industrial buildings.
The former site of the We Energies power plant on Nov. 13, 2025, in Pleasant Prairie, Wis. (Joe Timmerman / Wisconsin Watch)

While forcing the utility to write off the plants as a loss was out of the question, Nieto argued that treating the plants “as though they were used and useful” is unfair to ratepayers.

The problem isn’t new, Hawkins added. But the looming retirement of coal generators at We Energies’ Oak Creek plant in Milwaukee County — which the utility pushed back from 2024 to 2027 — and the construction of new renewables and natural gas projects increased pressure to spare ratepayers from a double whammy. 

“Now we have the confluence of the replacement costs hitting along with more stranded asset costs piling up,” he said.

Public Service Commission Chair Summer Strand described extending the payment timeline as the best option in the limited pool available under state law, slipping in a critique of state lawmakers for limiting commissioners’ flexibility.  

“We do not have any action from the policymakers in this state to help with stranded assets,” she said. 

Some neighboring states allow utilities to “securitize” the remaining value of a retired plant — converting the value into a specialized bond, similar to refinancing a mortgage. Customers still pay back the bond, but its interest rate on the bond may be lower than the utility’s profit margin. 

Will We Energies bill ratepayers to pay for its board of directors?

We Energies sought permission to bill ratepayers for roughly $5.3 million to cover a portion of its board of directors fees, arguing that the board’s oversight of budgets, capital plans and risk management “helps ensure utility resources are used prudently and in customers’ interests.” 

Commissioners weren’t convinced. The board provides a “shareholder benefit, not a customer benefit,” Strand said. “If you benefit from an expense, you should pay for it.”

We Energies also asked to bill ratepayers roughly $4 million over the next two years for its membership in industry associations. Several of those groups, especially the Wisconsin Utilities Association, the Metropolitan Milwaukee Association of Commerce and the national Edison Electric Institute and American Gas Association, run extensive state and federal lobbying operations.

The commission typically allows utilities to recoup only a portion of their membership dues from ratepayers — a share meant to match the ratepayer benefits of those memberships. That practice will continue over the next two years. Commissioners called the justifications in the latest request for billing customers for some membership dues  “flimsy” and urged the utility to be more transparent about whether the memberships benefit customers in any future requests. 

“I don’t know how else to send the message that we’re serious about this,” Strand said. 

How much will We Energies’ customers pay to restore service when the utility disconnects them for missing bills?

We Energies disconnected roughly 60,000 customers last year for falling behind on their energy bills, including roughly one in six households in parts of Milwaukee’s North Side. The commission placed a one-year hold on disconnections at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, and annual disconnection totals remained below pre-pandemic levels — about 51,000 in 2019 — until 2024. 

“Disconnection is always a last resort,” We Energies spokesman Brendan Conway told Wisconsin Watch in an email. “A number of factors in recent years have created unique situations that impact customer bills, including very cold winter weather and very hot summer weather, fluctuating natural gas prices impacted by international events and an increase in federal heating assistance available to people during and after the COVID pandemic that has expired.”

We Energies currently requires that disconnected customers pay at least 80% of their past-due balance to restore their electricity service, with a maximum down payment of $600 for low-income households. 

Strand called the $600 cap “atrocious” and far out of reach for low-income households already behind on bills.

Commissioners agreed to lower the minimum payment for all customers to 50% of their arrears and cap the maximum down payment for low-income customers at $100. 

How did We Energies, investors and ratepayer advocates respond to the PSC?

We Energies did not publicly object to the commission’s multimillion-dollar cut to its revenue request.

“The Commission’s votes today support key investments for our customers: more Wisconsin-produced energy, continued tree trimming to reduce power outages and undergrounding of power lines to strengthen the grid against severe weather. It also reflects our shared commitment to ensuring that no costs to serve data centers are shifted to other customers,” Conway wrote in a statement after the hearing. “Our typical customer bills are below the national average and in line with customers across the Midwest. That will remain true in the coming years.”

The Citizens Utility Board applauded the commission’s efforts to rein in costs, but Executive Director Tom Content emphasized that regulators could have gone further — especially if state lawmakers gave them a longer leash. 

“The savings could be in the hundreds of millions of dollars, but unfortunately not enough to stop an increase from taking effect,” he wrote in a preliminary press release. “After all, the increase sought was nearly half a billion — $449 million — over two years.”

Shares in WEC Energy Group, We Energies’ parent company, hit an all-time high of $120 shortly before Thursday’s hearing. That price fell to $116 by Friday morning. 

Strand used the rate case to renew her criticism of Wisconsin’s comparatively hands-off approach to energy planning and legislative Republicans, just two days after Democrats won a trifecta in state government. 

“The commission is still tasked with balancing reliability, affordability and environmental responsibility,” she said as the marathon hearing began. The task is challenging, Strand added, because the commission is “hamstrung by an inadequate and outdated regulatory framework” and because “the majority party that has been in power since 2011 has refused to consider beneficial changes.”

The state Senate confirmed Strand to the commission in 2024; her term ends in 2029. Commissioners Nieto and Hawkins are serving without Senate confirmation, enabling Gov.-elect David Crowley to appoint a new majority to the commission next year.

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

We Energies customers face another rate hike — but smaller, as regulators push back on utility is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

ICE officers arrest Wisconsin state trooper for expired visa

Reading Time: 2 minutes

Editor’s note, Nov. 7, 2026: Carel Aaron Van der Merwe was released later on Nov. 6, his attorney confirmed to multiple news outlets.

Federal immigration authorities arrested a Wisconsin state trooper this week, apparently in connection to his pending asylum claim.

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers detained Carel Aaron Van der Merwe at the Dane County Regional Airport on Thursday as the 21-year-old prepared to board a flight to New Mexico, where his father works on a sheep ranch. 

A person wearing a dark uniform with a badge, gray tie and wide-brimmed hat smiles at the camera, with other people partially visible nearby.
Wisconsin state trooper Carel Aaron Van der Merwe in uniform. (Courtesy of the Van der Merwe family)

Van der Merwe immigrated to the U.S. from South Africa with his family in 2019. Milwaukee immigration attorney Marc Christopher, who will represent Van der Merwe in his removal case, told Wisconsin Watch that his client has waited half a decade for an asylum interview; his family fled their home in rural South Africa amid a rise in attacks targeting farmers. 

Unable to join the military because of his pending legal status — but equipped with a work permit valid through 2030 — Van der Merwe joined the Wisconsin State Patrol last year, working from the agency’s Tomah post. The Wisconsin Department of Transportation, which oversees the State Patrol, told Wisconsin Watch that it is aware of his arrest, but an agency spokesperson did not clarify whether Van der Merwe is on paid leave while in ICE custody. The Wisconsin Troopers Association, Van der Merwe’s union, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Christopher is unaware of any prior criminal history that would explain Van der Merwe’s arrest. While immigration authorities can detain a person solely because of a pending asylum application, Christopher has never encountered a comparable case. “I think the only reason, to be honest with you, is that they’re trying to make it as onerous (as possible) for anyone who is not a U.S. citizen to live and travel in the United States,” he said. 

An ICE spokesperson defended its actions on Friday afternoon. “(Van der Merwe) entered the country in March 2019 with legal permission to stay until September 2019,” the spokesperson wrote in an email. “In defiance of our nation’s laws, he overstayed his admission. This illegal alien will receive due process and remain in ICE custody pending removal proceedings. To be clear: work authorization or a pending application do not confer legal status in the U.S.”

The agency indicated that Van der Merwe’s arrest was part of a broader effort to prevent immigrants without legal status from flying domestically. “DHS reversed the horrendous Biden-era policy that allowed aliens in our country illegally to jet around our country,” the spokesperson wrote. “Under President Trump, DHS will no longer tolerate this. This administration is working diligently to ensure that aliens in our country illegally can no longer fly unless it is out of our country to self-deport.”

Van der Merwe was in custody at the Dodge County Detention Center in Juneau awaiting a hearing in his immigration case as of Friday afternoon.

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

ICE officers arrest Wisconsin state trooper for expired visa is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

History made: Wisconsin elects first Black governor and first Latino and Hmong statewide officers

Three side-by-side photographs show a person standing at a "Crowley Godlewski" podium, a person in a light blue shirt and glasses, and a person holding a microphone.
Reading Time: 5 minutes

Tuesday’s Democratic sweep of statewide offices included three notable firsts: Wisconsin’s first Black governor and first Latino and Hmong statewide elected officials.

Gov.-elect David Crowley, Secretary of State-elect JoCasta Zamarripa and Treasurer-elect Yee Leng Xiong, all Democrats, formed the most racially diverse party slate — alongside Lt. Gov.-elect Sarah Godlewski — in Wisconsin history. The trio occasionally acknowledged that detail on the campaign trail, but it didn’t feature front and center in their messaging this year.

Wisconsin has had some of the largest racial disparities in the nation in infant mortality, income, education outcomes and incarceration rates. More than a quarter of Black Wisconsinites lived below the poverty line in 2024 — a higher rate than in all but three states and Washington, D.C.; Latino and Asian Wisconsinites also experienced higher poverty rates than their white counterparts and the national average for Latino and Asian Americans, respectively.  

The gap between the share of Black and white Wisconsin students who graduate high school on schedule was the highest in the country between 2019 and 2024. Black children born in Wisconsin die in their infancy at roughly three times the rate of white children — a pattern public health experts say doesn’t map neatly to family income. Black Wisconsinites are roughly a third as likely as white Wisconsinites to own their homes, though gaps vary by city; and Black Wisconsinites’ incarceration rate was roughly 12 times higher than that of white Wisconsinites in 2022, a gap surpassed only in Vermont. 

In his victory speech in Milwaukee, Crowley alluded to the challenges the state’s Black residents have long faced.

“Because of you, a boy who grew up facing eviction will soon take residence in the governor’s residence,” Crowley said. “Tonight Wisconsin made history, and being your next governor is humbling in its own right. I don’t take any of this lightly. And I know exactly the shoulders that I stand on.”

Crowley became Milwaukee County’s first elected Black executive in 2020, though former Milwaukee Common Council President Marvin Pratt served in the role on an interim basis in 2011.. At  least one in five Milwaukee County residents have identified as Black since the 2000 census. That share rose to roughly one in four residents as of the 2024 American Community Survey, compared to roughly 6% of Wisconsin’s overall population.

Crowley attended Bay View High School with Cavalier Johnson, whom Milwaukee voters chose as their city’s first Black mayor in 2022.

Wisconsin’s first Black state lawmaker, Progressive Republican Lucian Palmer, likewise represented Milwaukee; he served in the Assembly for a single term from 1907 to 1909. Former Secretary of State Vel Phillips became Wisconsin’s first Black statewide elected official in 1978.

Witnessing history at the Crowley event wasn’t lost on Kenya Perry, 38, an east side Milwaukee resident.

“I think it’ll be great, not just for us minorities, but for everyone, because he not only represents us, but he’s representing everybody,” Perry said. “It doesn’t matter what color you are, what’s your background, what ethnicity or your religion or anything like that. He wants to come in and represent all people, not just one party.”

People cheer and hold up a cutout of David Crowley
Desilynn Smith and Anna Maria Hodges celebrate after David Crowley won the Wisconsin governorship during the election watch party for Crowley at Landmark Credit Union Live on Nov. 3, 2026, in Milwaukee. (Jonathan Aguilar / Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service / CatchLight Local)

Zamarripa is also a lifelong Milwaukeean. She, too, is no stranger to firsts; Zamarripa became Wisconsin’s first Latina state lawmaker in 2010 and the first Latina member of Milwaukee’s Common Council in 2020. Roughly 20% of Milwaukee residents identified as Hispanic as of 2024, compared to about 8% of all Wisconsinites.

She told Wisconsin Watch on Monday that her race for secretary of state was also an opportunity to build out Latino voter outreach infrastructure.

“We’re the fastest-growing constituency in the great state of Wisconsin,” she said, not only in Milwaukee, but in manufacturing and agricultural hubs across the state. “Wherever there are midterm Latino voters, we mailed them a bilingual piece of mail,” she said, alongside partnerships with Spanish-language radio stations and ad buys in southeast Wisconsin and the Green Bay area. Roughly the same share of Kenosha and Racine County residents identified as Latino in 2024 — about 16% — as did 1 in 10 Brown County residents.

Zamarripa hopes Wisconsin Democrats will be able to “replicate” her campaign’s Latino voter outreach efforts, or perhaps even devote resources to recruiting Latino candidates for local and statewide offices. Among the communities on her mind: Arcadia in western Wisconsin’s Trempealeau County, the state’s only majority-Latino city as of 2024.

Voters in majority Latino precincts on Milwaukee’s South Side veered right in 2024, including 44-year-old Nextaly Rodriguez. He voted in his first-ever gubernatorial election at the Kosciusko Community Center polling site on Tuesday, choosing Crowley over Republican Tom Tiffany. “Just trying something new,” he said in Spanish. 

Jesus Mancilla made it to the community center less than a half-hour before polls closed. The 18-year-old spotted U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents on his block during a wave of immigration arrests in and around Milwaukee in June; his older brother convinced him to vote for his immigrant parents’ sake. He wasn’t the only first-time Latino voter at the polling site. “I saw a couple of my friends leave (just now),” he said. Mancilla hasn’t sorted out his political identity yet, but he chose Crowley in the governor’s race. 

Xiong is both Wisconsin’s and the nation’s first Hmong statewide elected officer. He hails from Marathon County, home to Wisconsin’s second-largest Hmong community. Roughly 1 in 10 Wausau residents identified as Hmong in 2024, more than in any other Wisconsin city.

Tens of thousands of Hmong refugees, including Xiong’s parents, settled in Wisconsin in the wake of the Vietnam War; last year marked the 50th anniversary of the first Hmong families’ arrival in the state. Hmong Wisconsinites now comprise sizable constituencies not only in Wausau, but also in Milwaukee, Sheboygan, Madison, Eau Claire and the Fox Valley. 

The Hmong written language is still relatively young, so Xiong leaned into person-to-person outreach, producing a series of Hmong-language get-out-the-vote videos, hosting bilingual campaign events and making phone calls to Hmong-speaking voters. 

Xiong isn’t sure his voter outreach efforts are easily replicable. “It comes with relationships,” he said, and cementing those relationships for future election cycles will require Democrats to maintain a presence in Wisconsin’s Hmong communities. 

When the dust of Tuesday’s blowout settles, he expects Hmong voters, and Asian voters more broadly, to have played pivotal roles in flipping the Wausau-based 85th Assembly District — a seat for which he ran two years ago, losing by four points — and seats in greater Green Bay and Menasha. 

Person peeks through window of wood establishment that has menu displayed
Sa Sor Lee, owner of Mortchee’s Carryout & Catering in Wausau, peeks out from her business on Nov. 4, 2026. Lee previously mentored Treasurer-elect Yee Leng Xiong, who is set to become Wisconsin’s and the nation’s first Hmong statewide elected official. (Brittany Carloni / Wisconsin Watch)

As owner Sa Sor Lee opened the doors of Mortchee’s Carryout & Catering in Wausau on a windy Wednesday morning, she carried the joy and pride she had felt the night before at Yee Leng Xiong’s election party. Attendees watched Xiong’s vote total climb throughout the evening before the Associated Press called the race for him shortly after midnight.

Lee has known Xiong since he was 17 and mentored him through the H.M.O.N.G. Youth Program in Wausau, which stands for Helping Make Our Next Generation. She has watched him run for the local school board, the Marathon County Board and, ultimately, state treasurer. She also frequently contributed food to his campaigns.

Lee said Xiong’s victory means a lot to the Hmong community. “It means we can do a lot more than we think we can.”

“I’m so excited,” Lee added. “It’s not just him, but I think I felt like I am winning this election.”

Wisconsin Watch reporters Tom Kertscher and Brittany Carloni contributed to this report.

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

History made: Wisconsin elects first Black governor and first Latino and Hmong statewide officers is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

Wisconsin ICE arrestee’s case heads to US Supreme Court

White building with columns against a blue sky
Reading Time: 3 minutes

Federal immigration authorities asked the U.S. Supreme Court on Wednesday to hear the case of a Mexican national whom agents arrested last year in Racine. The petition is the latest escalation in a legal fight over the Trump administration’s mandatory detention policy for immigrants facing deportation. 

The justices’ decision will determine whether tens of thousands of immigrants currently in federal detention can seek release on bond. 

“The question of mandatory detention thus boils down to one question: Can we lock up noncitizens without giving them a day in court first?” said Jenifer Bizzotto, the Wisconsin attorney representing Jaciel Cirrus Rojas, the man at the center of the case. “The stakes could hardly be higher.”

Arrested as ‘collateral’

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents turned up at then-24-year-old Cirrus Rojas’ apartment in June 2025 in search of a prior tenant. They instead arrested Cirrus Rojas, who entered the U.S. in 2018 without a visa, as “collateral.” Wisconsin court records show no criminal convictions under his name. 

He spent most of the next nine months in custody at the Dodge County Detention Center in Juneau, entangled in a new White House policy barring ICE detainees from posting bond — a departure from decades of precedent.

The 1996 Immigration Reform Act requires immigration authorities to detain — without bond — anyone found crossing the U.S. border without authorization. Prior administrations applied that rule narrowly, allowing many immigrants arrested in the country’s interior to seek a bond hearing in immigration court.

A man leans against a building's wall, wearing a Lakers jersey.
Jaciel Cirrus Rojas is a Mexican national who federal immigration authorities apprehended in Racine in 2025 as “collateral” while searching for a different target. (Courtesy of Jennifer Bizzotto)

The Trump administration bucked that approach in July 2025, when ICE Director Todd Lyons issued a new legal interpretation requiring detention without bond regardless of where immigrants are arrested.

The Board of Immigration Appeals, a panel of judges who set the rules for the federal immigration court system, later signed off on the interpretation.

With bond off the table, tens of thousands of immigrants in ICE custody turned to a backup option: filing habeas corpus petitions in federal district courts to challenge their detention. 

Unlike immigration courts, which are part of the U.S. Department of Justice, federal district courts belong to the judicial branch and, therefore, are technically independent of the White House. When a federal district court grants a habeas petition, it generally orders an immigration court judge to hold a bond hearing.

Wisconsin’s Western and Eastern District courts have received more than 100 habeas petitions over the past year.

A federal appeals court split

The 7th Circuit ruled 2-1 in Cirrus Rojas’ favor in July, joining appellate courts based in New York, Cincinnati, Denver, Atlanta and San Francisco in rejecting the policy.“If Congress had indeed demanded — but not funded — no-bond detention for all unlawful entrants, that may well have thrown the nation’s immigration system into chaos,” Judge Joshua Kolar, whom Joe Biden appointed to the court, wrote in the court’s majority opinion. “Immigration authorities might have found themselves quickly overwhelmed by a colossal unfunded mandate to arrest and detain millions.” Judge Diane Sykes, a George W. Bush appointee, dissented alone.

“At this point, only the Supreme Court can bring uniformity and settle this question once and for all,” she wrote. “I anticipate that it will do so soon.”

Cirrus Rojas left custody earlier this year after a federal district court judge in California vacated the mandatory detention rule. The San Francisco-based 9th Circuit Court of Appeals stayed that decision less than a month later.

The 7th Circuit allowed his case to move forward because federal authorities plan to re-detain him. 

Supreme Court could have final say

“Nothing, absent our intervention, stops the government from making good on its promise,” Kolar wrote.The U.S. Department of Homeland Security, ICE’s parent agency, is now asking the Supreme Court to step in.

The court agreed to take up another mandatory detention dispute earlier this month. That case involves a Brazilian national arrested during a traffic stop in Massachusetts last September.

DHS asked the justices to hold Cirrus Rojas’ case until they decide the Massachusetts case. 

In Bizzotto’s view, both cases “offer the Supreme Court the opportunity to affirm that the Constitution means what it says.”

A ruling against the mandatory detention policy would open the door for thousands of ICE detainees — at least those within circuits that side with the Trump administration — to request bond hearings in immigration court. It would not require immigration court judges to grant their bond requests.

The Supreme Court also quietly declined this week to revive a Biden-era policy that allowed  immigration court judges to pause deportation proceedings for immigrants seeking humanitarian visas or other forms of legal status. 

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

Wisconsin ICE arrestee’s case heads to US Supreme Court is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

Federal loan could fund Wisconsin natural gas and battery storage projects

Building with sign that says Department of Energy
Reading Time: 2 minutes

Editor’s note: This story has was updated Oct. 29 with comments from Wisconsin Sierra Club and Clean Air Wisconsin. 

The U.S. Department of Energy announced a $5.1 billion loan to Alliant Energy on Wednesday, including $1.6 billion for Wisconsin Power and Light, Wisconsin’s third-largest electrical utility.

Alliant spokesperson Cindy Tomlinson told Wisconsin Watch that the loan may support the construction of a natural gas storage facility in Rock County and a pair of battery storage facilities — one in southwestern Wisconsin and another near Sheboygan — among other possibilities. Two of those projects still require approval from the Wisconsin Public Service Commission. The loan itself doesn’t name those projects, and Tomlinson noted that the federal dollars could also support efforts to restart or repurpose shuttered power plants or build new natural gas plants. 

The company estimates Wisconsin ratepayers will save $400 million over the life of the loan. “To the extent that tax dollars are used to help pay for projects that are approved,” Wisconsin  Citizens Utility Board (CUB) Executive Director Tom Content wrote in an email, “that should lower the overall cost over 20-40 years.” CUB has not yet reviewed Alliant’s ratepayer savings claim. 


The deal dates back to the final days of the Biden administration, when the Department of Energy’s Loan Programs Office focused on shoring up clean energy projects that otherwise struggled to get bank loans. The office mulled canceling existing clean energy loans after President Trump’s return to the White House in January 2025, Bloomberg reported.

The new loan language doesn’t explicitly bar spending on renewable energy infrastructure. It instead allows the utility to direct funding to “energy infrastructure and related projects that increase energy supply or enhance grid reliability, including but not limited to nuclear, coal, oil, natural gas, geothermal or hydropower power generation facilities.”

“The Energy Department is delivering on President Trump’s promise to lower electricity costs and unleash the full potential of American energy,” U.S. Secretary of Energy Chris Wright said in a statement. 

Environmental advocacy groups were dismayed to learn Alliant may use the loan to fund natural gas projects. 

“Clean, renewable energy like wind and solar are more affordable than gas infrastructure, and they come without the massive water use and pollution that fossil fuels have,” Wisconsin Sierra Club Senior Campaign Coordinator Cassie Steiner wrote in an email. “This grant that props up gas plants, a more expensive, financially volatile, and polluting fossil fuel energy source, will harm residents. We are going to pay for this dirty infrastructure with our health, our water, our air, and our bills.”

“They’re taking our tax dollars to pull us in the wrong direction,” added Brittany Keyes, clean air policy manager for Healthy Climate Wisconsin. “This is going to make the Rock River Valley sicker.”

Alliant also applied for a federal grant in June to extend the life of coal-fired generators it owns at the Columbia Energy Center near Portage. The utility previously planned to retire the plant’s coal units before the end of the decade.

Federal loan could fund Wisconsin natural gas and battery storage projects is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

Despite high stakes for energy future, Wisconsin’s utilities scale back campaign spending — so far

A stacked bar chart shows Wisconsin utility campaign contributions from 2016 to 2026, peaking at $421,000 in 2024 and divided among six recipient categories.
Reading Time: 9 minutes
Click here to read highlights from the story
  • Wisconsin’s largest utilities are on track to contribute less to political campaigns than in the last two gubernatorial election years, despite the enormous stakes for the state’s energy future.
  • Neither Republican Tom Tiffany nor Democrat David Crowley received contributions from utility political action committees through September. 
  • Utilities have directed nearly all their campaign contributions toward state legislative races. 
  • Democrats are gaining ground in utility fundraising, receiving about 45% of contributions to legislative candidates and fundraising committees this year, compared with less than 20% in 2022.

Wisconsin’s multibillion-dollar energy infrastructure construction boom isn’t fueling a similar deluge of utility-related campaign spending ahead of the election.

The state’s largest utilities are collectively on track to spend less supporting political candidates this year than in the last two gubernatorial election years.

Utility campaign contributions to Wisconsin’s local, state and federal campaigns — and state-level partisan fundraising groups — reached just under $300,000 by late September, down roughly $50,000 from the same point in 2022.

Neither Republican gubernatorial candidate Tom Tiffany nor Democratic candidate David Crowley took in any contributions from the utilities’ political action committees (PACs) between January and September. 

Utilities could still make last-minute contributions before the election, as they have in years past.

Utilities are dialing back contributions despite the influence the next governor and Legislature will wield over the industry. Next month’s winners will appoint and confirm a new majority to the state commission that regulates utilities and weigh in on legislation that could shape Wisconsin’s energy future for decades.

Some industry observers speculate that the mismatch between utilities’ political spending and the election’s ramifications reflect the mounting public hostility to the data center boom — and, by extension, to the utilities themselves. 

“I think utilities are beginning to recognize that their brand is increasingly toxic,” said Jonathan Kim, a Chicago-based researcher for the Energy and Policy Institute, a nonprofit watchdog. As of August, Kim is also the institute’s registered lobbyist in Madison, focusing on residential ratepayer concerns. 

If past ties to utilities put a target on a candidate’s back, Kim added, the companies would have good reason to avoid making direct contributions in hotly contested races. 

Wisconsin isn’t the only state where utility political spending appears to be softening. In Michigan, for example, the state’s largest investor-owned utilities are on track to spend less supporting political candidates this year than they did in the last three midterm cycles. 

The drop in political spending falls short of an all-out retreat in Wisconsin. Utilities have steered nearly all of their contributions toward state legislative contests — and, for the first time in at least a decade, divided their giving almost evenly between Democrats and Republicans. The shift coincides with Democrats’ improved prospects of securing a majority in at least one legislative chamber for the first time since 2010.

How utilities spend on politics

Three companies provide electricity for a majority of Wisconsin households: Alliant Energy, owner of Wisconsin Power and Light; WEC Energy Group, the parent company of We Energies and Wisconsin Public Service Corporation; and Xcel Energy, owner of Northern States Power Company. 

Each company operates separate federal and state political action committees, or PACs. The committees collect voluntary contributions from company executives, employees and shareholders, then distribute those funds to political candidates and organizations chosen by their boards of directors. Candidates can spend donations on their current or future campaigns — or share them with other candidates. They cannot legally spend on personal expenses. 

Can utilities use ratepayer dollars for campaign contributions? (Click to expand)

Wisconsin’s Public Service Commission doesn’t explicitly prohibit it, but utility spokespeople told Wisconsin Watch that their companies do not bill ratepayers for political contributions. We Energies said the same to the state’s Public Service Commission in April.

Voters in Michigan will decide in November whether to prohibit utilities from contributing to state political campaigns entirely.

 Wisconsin law caps how much a PAC can contribute to a given state-level candidate in a single cycle — up to $2,000 for a Senate campaign, for instance, or $86,000 for a gubernatorial campaign. Federal rules similarly limit PAC contributions to individual candidates. Utilities’ federal PACs can give up to $5,000 to a federal candidate.

Utility employees and executives, meanwhile, can donate via employer-sponsored “conduits.” Alliant, WEC Energy and Xcel each sponsor conduits, as do Madison Gas and Electric and the American Transmission Company, Wisconsin’s largest transmission utility. 

Like PACs, conduits serve as pass-throughs for political donations. Unlike PACs, employees choose which candidates receive their donations. The conduit’s sponsor may recommend candidates or races to support, and candidates who receive conduit contributions often also receive PAC donations. 

Conduit contributions appear in campaign finance records under the individual donor’s name. Although state law limits how much individuals may contribute to a candidate, the combined donations routed through a utility’s conduit can exceed the amount a utility’s PAC may give in a single cycle. 

How much have utilities spent on congressional races?

Alliant, WEC Energy and Xcel’s federal PACs gave roughly $23,500 to Wisconsin’s congressional delegation between January and late July.

U.S. Rep. Bryan Steil, facing a competitive race for a district stretching from Janesville to Racine, received $5,000 from Alliant’s PAC in early March — the largest Wisconsin utility contribution to a single candidate this year. Federal campaign finance records show no utility PAC contribution to Steil’s Democratic opponent, Mitchell Berman. 

The state’s utilities have largely steered clear of the high-profile race in Wisconsin’s 3rd District, where incumbent Republican Rep. Derrick Van Orden and Democratic challenger Rebecca Cooke have tried to link each other to data center interests.

Utility PACs have donated to all eight Wisconsinites in the U.S. House in the last decade. But annual donations have plunged from 2016, when the three utilities’ PACs gave over $94,000 to the Wisconsin delegation, primarily to Paul Ryan, who was House speaker at the time.

U.S. Rep. Mark Pocan, the Madison area’s representative in Washington since 2013, hasn’t  received a utility contribution since 2018. 

How much have utilities spent on state races? 

Contributions from the state-level utility PACs and their conduits to Wisconsin legislative candidates and legislative fundraising committees totaled roughly $250,000 between January and September.

Much of the decline in utility contributions from 2022 stems from reduced spending by WEC Energy’s PAC and conduit. 

Democratic lawmakers have received about 45% of utilities’ year-to-date contributions, compared to just under 20% in 2022.

“We work with both sides,” WEC Energy President Scott Lauber told investors on a July quarterly earnings call. “It’s just a matter of how we make Wisconsin successful.”

Taylor Adams, an Alliant Energy spokesperson, said the utility’s political giving is bipartisan and varies from year to year based on the communities and elected officials within its service territory, not partisan preference. Adams added that his company focuses on policies that support “reliable and cost-effective energy.”

Rep. David Steffen, chair of the Assembly Committee on Energy and Utilities, is the top individual recipient of utility dollars, campaign finance records show. He has received roughly $13,655 via utility PACs and conduits this year, accounting for roughly a third of his total 2026 fundraising as of September.

Alliant and WEC Energy’s PACs have already given Steffen’s campaign the maximum $1,000 allowed by state statute for an Assembly candidate in a single cycle. Three WEC executives have done the same through their company’s conduit. 

The Assembly committee’s ranking Democratic lawmaker, Rep. Lisa Subeck, D-Madison, received $3,980.

Sen. Melissa Ratcliff of Cottage Grove, the ranking Democrat on the Senate Committee on Utilities, Technology and Tourism, received $5,250, including $2,000 from Alliant alone — the maximum state law allows for a Senate candidate. Ratcliff is not up for reelection until 2028.

Assembly Majority Leader Tyler August, R-Walworth, has received $7,500 from utilities and their conduits while Senate Minority Leader Dianne Hesselbein, D-Middleton, took in $5,560. With longtime Assembly Speaker Robin Vos set to retire, August is likely among top contenders to become speaker if Republicans keep the majority after Election Day. 

August led Assembly’s Republicans through the two consecutive fights over utility-backed “right of first refusal” (ROFR) bills, which would grant Wisconsin’s transmission utilities first dibs on any electrical grid projects within their territory. Ratepayer advocates argue the proposal would risk driving up electricity prices by stifling competition in the transmission market. 

Speaking at a June WisPolitics luncheon, Hesselbein blamed Republicans for the bill’s failure last session, casting the policy as a means to shore up Wisconsin-based businesses and union jobs.

Chamber leadership and members of the Senate and Assembly utilities committees received over a quarter of all utility PAC and conduit contributions this year. 

That pattern isn’t unusual. Other industry interest groups, including in agriculture, also focus contributions on the committees most relevant to their businesses. 

“Election spending from industry and wealthy special interests is about wanting access and sway over policy agendas that could affect their bottom line,” said Nick Ramos, executive director of the Wisconsin Democracy Campaign. “It’s no surprise that they assess the landscape and find who might have the most impact.”

Some top recipients are less obvious. 

Rep. Tip McGuire, D-Kenosha, has received $4,750 this year — more than many lawmakers on the Assembly utilities committee, despite not serving on it. McGuire is one of four Democrats on the Joint Finance Committee, which drafts the state’s two-year budget.

Other key lawmakers received relatively little this year. Senate utilities committee chair Sen. Julian Bradley, R-New Berlin, received $1,500 from utility PACs and conduits as of late September, and Assembly Minority Leader Greta Neubauer received $1,175. 

Not all utility money reaches lawmakers directly. Utility PACs also contribute to partisan fundraising groups like the Republican Assembly Campaign Committee, which contributes to legislative campaigns. 

Partisan committees also receive contributions directly from the utilities, rather than from their PACs. WEC Energy, for instance, gave $14,000 to partisan fundraising groups between January and June. 

State law doesn’t cap contributions to party fundraising committees. 

“There’s not supposed to be any sort of coordination between donors to the party committee and the campaigns that receive that money,” Kim said, making it difficult to know which candidates ultimately benefit from the utility’s committee contribution.

Scant spending on the governor’s race

About 2% of contributions from utility PACs and utility conduits between January and September flowed directly to gubernatorial candidates — including to candidates who lost their primary. 

Wisconsin hasn’t held an open gubernatorial election since 2010, muddying comparisons with other recent elections. 

Former Republican Gov. Scott Walker collected roughly $269,000 in contributions — not adjusted for inflation — between the launch of his gubernatorial campaign in 2009 and his exit in 2019, including about $86,000 ahead of his 2018 defeat by Democratic Gov. Tony Evers. 

Evers received about $11,000 in utility contributions during that race. Utilities have since contributed roughly $330,000 to his campaign committee.

Ahead of the 2022 election, utilities contributed more than twice as much to Evers as they did Tim Michels, his Republican opponent.

Some gubernatorial spending in 2018 and 2022 came in late October, just after the candidates turned in their final pre-election fundraising reports. 

Utilities haven’t transferred that financial support to Crowley, whom Evers backed during the chaotic final leg of this year’s Democratic primary. Utility PACs have yet to contribute to his or Tiffany’s gubernatorial campaigns.

Tiffany has received roughly $3,600 via WEC and MGE’s conduits while Crowley has drawn none during the campaign. 

Still, both accepted utility contributions during previous runs for office.

Tiffany brought in at least $17,000 from utility PACs and through their conduits over a decade of state legislative campaigns, followed by another $11,500 during and after his U.S. House campaign in 2020.

Crowley’s state Assembly campaign committee raised just over $1,600 from utility PACs and conduits — mostly WEC, which serves households in the Milwaukee district he represented. His Milwaukee County executive campaign committee accepted another $9,900 from WEC’s PAC and via its conduit between 2020 and 2024.

Any additional contributions between Oct. 26 and Election Day will appear on the candidates’ next finance report in January.

Crowley and Tiffany’s visions for the PSC (click to expand)

Both Crowley and Tiffany are picking up the banner of energy affordability, promising to follow through in part via their appointments to the PSC.

“Under David Crowley, the PSC will become a watchdog for taxpayers, ensuring that Wisconsinites’ utility bills stay as low as possible while creating greater transparency in where their tax dollars are going,” Crowley spokesman Philip Schulman wrote in an email. “This includes empowering the PSC to reject rate hikes in favor of cheaper options and publishing a quarterly score card detailing everything from avoided outages to fuel cost savings.”

Tiffany doesn’t shy away from criticizing the current commission, in no small part because of his objections to converting cropland into solar farms. “Day one when I become governor, they will be replaced,” he said at a September town hall in Sauk County, referring to the two acting commissioners — Kristy Nieto and Marcus Hawkins — serving without Senate confirmation.

Utility allies spend more

Utilities share interests with other groups, some of which have poured far more into this year’s governor’s race.

Crowley has received separate $86,000 donations — the PAC cap for a single cycle — from at least four labor groups that often align with utilities on energy infrastructure projects:  International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers PAC, International Union of Operating Engineers Local 139 PAC, Wisconsin Laborers’ District Council and Wisconsin Pipe Trades Association PAC. Two other construction trades unions contributed smaller sums to Crowley’s campaign; a PAC representing a carpenters’ union gave $82,500 and a PAC representing plumbers and steamfitters gave $25,000.

Those unions represent workers who build or operate power plants and transmission lines. The political director of the Wisconsin Laborers’ District Council sits on the board of Fair Rates for Wisconsin’s Dairyland alongside WEC and Alliant representatives.

Tiffany seized on that support in an attack ad that dubbed his opponent “Data Center David Crowley,” citing the labor groups’ vocal support for developing data centers and associated energy infrastructure.

“IBEW certainly supports responsible data center development,” the IBEW state conference vice chair, John Jacobs, wrote in an email. “We also support renewable energy and countless projects that support family supporting jobs, great healthcare, great retirement benefits and a path to the middle class. All priorities of David Crowley – and that’s why we support him.”

Those labor groups had not contributed to Tiffany’s campaign through September. But Robert Marchant, the Wisconsin Data Center Coalition’s sole lobbyist, donated $5,000 in early June. Alliant, WEC and Xcel are founding members of the coalition. 

Spending strategically

Utilities’ spending this year leaves them far behind Wisconsin’s top political donors. Diane Hendricks, for example, has already given exponentially more than utilities in 2026 — all to the Wisconsin Republican Party, which has transferred most to Tiffany’s gubernatorial campaign.

But the companies’ political goals don’t match those of explicitly partisan spenders like Hendricks.

“They just want to be able to wield sufficient political power to get the things that they need,” Kim said. “They’re not going to spend dumb money.”

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

Despite high stakes for energy future, Wisconsin’s utilities scale back campaign spending — so far is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

We Energies strikes deal to power Oracle data center with nuclear energy

A large industrial complex sits along a shoreline, surrounded by trees and fields beneath an overcast sky.
Reading Time: 2 minutes

Editor’s note: This story was updated Oct. 5, 2026 to add comment from the Wisconsin Citizens Utility Board.

Oracle is looking to Wisconsin’s only operating nuclear plant to power its Ozaukee County data center.

We Energies announced an agreement with the cloud computing giant on Friday that would allow Oracle to “subscribe” to between 10% and 20% of the Point Beach Nuclear Plant’s electricity generation. That electricity would help meet the energy needs of Project Lighthouse, the data center campus in Port Washington that Oracle is co-developing with artificial intelligence firm OpenAI. 

The agreement still requires approval by Wisconsin’s Public Service Commission. If it is approved, We Energies spokesman Brendan Conway said it could spare the utility’s other customers roughly $300 million in fuel costs over the next five years.

The 60-year-old Point Beach plant in Manitowoc County is the state’s largest generator, but the electricity it produces is more expensive than alternatives. We Energies spends about twice as much on fuel as its sibling utility, Wisconsin Public Service Company (PSC). The cost of nuclear fuel for Point Beach accounts for much of the difference. 

We Energies owned the facility until 2007, when it sold Point Beach to independent energy infrastructure giant NextEra Energy but continued purchasing most of the plant’s electricity output. The utility’s current purchase agreement expires in 2033, but We Energies recently signed on to continue buying roughly 86% of the plant’s electricity for another 20-year term. 

“The announcement by Oracle is certainly a step forward, as we have been seeking relief on this for years,” Wisconsin Citizens Utility Board Executive Director Tom Content said. “Whether that is a baby step or a leap forward for affordability remains to be seen.”

Meanwhile, We Energies filed a separate application with the PSC on Friday seeking approval  to build a new natural gas power plant on the site of the Fox Energy Center in Outagamie County. The proposed plant would more than double the site’s electricity output.

Disclosure: The OpenAI Foundation recently awarded a grant to Wisconsin Watch but has no control over its editorial decisions. We will update our funding page to reflect the grant. A list of donors and funders through 2025, as well as our donation acceptance policies, can be found here.

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

We Energies strikes deal to power Oracle data center with nuclear energy is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

Two Wisconsin sheriff races test the future of local ICE cooperation

Two people sit behind nameplates reading "Darin Rice" and "Jason Rippl" beneath a wall sign reading "CITY OF OSHKOSH," with other people in the foreground.
Reading Time: 9 minutes

This article was produced in partnership with the nonprofit journalism publication Bolts, which covers criminal justice and voting rights in local governments.

Click here to read highlights from the story
  • Voters in Sauk and Winnebago counties will choose sheriffs who hold different views on local cooperation with ICE.
  • Both Democratic candidates pledge to end their counties’ 287(g) agreements while their Republican opponents support continuing them in some form.
  • In Sauk County, both candidates would maintain a contract allowing ICE to house detainees in the county jail, despite disagreeing over the financial and humanitarian implications.
  • In Winnebago County, residents have also raised concerns about the law enforcement use of Flock license plate cameras.

Half an hour into a packed June candidate forum in Baraboo, the moderator turned to the issue looming over the race for Sauk County sheriff: immigration enforcement. 

“As chief law enforcement officer of Sauk County, how will you separate the demands of ICE from your duty to uphold the law and protect the residents of Sauk County?” Baraboo Optimist Club President Joseph Viney asked.  

The six candidates at the front of the public library conference room offered well-rehearsed responses.

Three months and a primary later, one Republican and one Democrat remain, with the question still central to the race ahead of the Nov. 3 election.

“People are fired up and they’re frustrated with ICE in general from a national perspective, and it does have local consequences,” Ryan Jesberger, the Democratic nominee, told Wisconsin Watch and Bolts.

ICE agents haven’t turned up in large numbers in the largely rural south-central Wisconsin county to check homes, jobsites and cars for undocumented immigrants. Unlike in neighboring Illinois and Minnesota, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement has relied on jails and prisons to make most of its arrests in Wisconsin since President Donald Trump returned to office in January 2025. 

Sauk County is no exception. ICE has recorded about 100 arrests in the county during that period, almost all through custody transfers at the local jail. An agreement between the sheriff’s office and federal authorities makes a small portion of those arrests possible by allowing county jail supervisors to play a limited role in immigration enforcement.

The Sauk County Sheriff’s Office is one of 20 county law enforcement agencies in Wisconsin that cooperate with ICE through 287(g) agreements: voluntary partnerships allowing designated local officers to carry out some immigration enforcement tasks. Voters in two of those counties — Sauk and Winnebago counties, 90 miles apart — will have a say in the future of their sheriffs’ ICE partnerships this fall. Trump won both counties by less than 5 percentage points in 2024.

The Trump administration has tapped local law enforcement agencies across the country for help in its immigration enforcement push, often in the form of 287(g) agreements. Those arrangements are drawing pushback from immigrant rights organizations and, in some cases, shaking up local elections.

Sheriffs are “the most important state(-level) race for immigration purposes,” said Hannah Schwarz, a staff attorney with the ACLU of Wisconsin. The civil liberties organization opposes local law enforcement cooperation with ICE. 

Sauk and Winnebago county voters will now choose between Republicans promising to stay the course and Democrats campaigning to dial back cooperation with immigration authorities. Both Democrats promise to quit the 287(g) program as soon as they take office.

But the partisan split conceals a more complicated policy landscape in Sauk County, where both candidates in the race favor keeping in place a contract that allows ICE to rent out space in the local jail to detain immigrants.

In Sauk, ICE cooperation takes multiple forms

Sauk County sits on the edge of Wisconsin’s Driftless Area, a region of sandstone bluffs and organic farms that has veered toward Republicans over the past three presidential elections after more than a decade of favoring Democrats. 

Baraboo, the county seat, peters out into cornfields within city limits. Wisconsin Dells, the Midwest’s waterpark capital, spills across the county’s northern boundary. The city’s resorts hire foreign workers on temporary visas ahead of the summer rush; other immigrants, many without visas, milk cows on the county’s dairy farms. 

A street beside a building with a mural reading "Greetings From Devil's Lake State Park and Baraboo Wisconsin," with a communications tower nearby.
Downtown Baraboo, Wis., Sept. 24, 2026. (Paul Kiefer / Wisconsin Watch)

Signed by Sheriff Richard “Chip” Meister in November 2025, Sauk County’s 287(g) agreement enables the county’s six jail supervisors to execute immigration warrants on people in county custody — a task ICE officers would otherwise perform. Executing an immigration warrant transfers them to ICE custody. 

The Sauk arrangement “streamline(s) our existing relationship with ICE,” Meister wrote in an email to Wisconsin Watch and Bolts.

But Meister is set to retire this year after 16 years, leaving the future of this arrangement uncertain. He endorsed Capt. Matt Burch, a Republican, ahead of the August primary; Burch won the primary by a wide margin. 

He takes a position similar to Meister’s. 

“Our focus remains strictly on removing individuals who commit serious crimes rather than targeting members of our community solely based on their immigration status,” Burch wrote in an email. He does not, however, plan to extend the office’s partnership with ICE beyond the county jail. “Our authority applies exclusively to individuals who are already in our custody for violating local or state laws.” 

About half of people transferred from the Sauk County Jail to ICE during Trump’s second term had prior criminal convictions, a Wisconsin Watch and Bolts analysis shows; the other half had pending criminal charges. At least 8% of those transferred to ICE custody inside the jail had a prior conviction for driving while intoxicated — by far the most common conviction among Sauk County arrestees.

Jesberger, the Democratic candidate running against Burch and a University of Wisconsin-Madison police lieutenant, promises to end the county’s 287(g) agreement “on day one.”

“It’s not an anti-ICE or pro-ICE view,” he said. “We’re not talking (about) not doing any interaction,” he added, but instead about scaling back the county’s role. Jesberger also argues the 287(g) agreement sidesteps a contentious and unresolved question about the limits of local law enforcement’s arrest powers.

Two people pose in separate portraits, one wearing a dark suit with a red tie and the other wearing a dark uniform with gold collar insignia.
Republican Matt Burch, left, and Democrat Ryan Jesberger are running for Sauk County sheriff.
(Courtesy of the Burch and Jesberger campaigns)

Law enforcement agencies with or without 287(g) agreements can choose to honor ICE “detainer” requests, which can entail holding people in jail up to 48 hours past their scheduled release to give immigration agents time to take them into custody.

The ACLU of Wisconsin petitioned the state Supreme Court in September 2025 to take up a lawsuit claiming five Wisconsin sheriffs’ offices — including Sauk County’s — violate state law by honoring the requests. The lawsuit argues that jailing someone beyond the person’s scheduled release date on an ICE detainer qualifies as an arrest and that state law does not authorize law enforcement to make arrests solely on the agency’s administrative warrants. 

The lawsuit is currently caught in a jurisdictional tug-of-war.

Jesberger shares the ACLU’s view on detainers, which he called “request(s) to take an action we are not authorized to take.” 

“It’s easy to say we should just hold onto someone,” he wrote in an email. “The problem is that under Wisconsin Law, there is no legal authority to conduct an arrest on this civil detainer.”

Jesberger would, however, honor warrants signed by a judge.

A 287(g) agreement enabling jail supervisors to serve immigration warrants is not the same as honoring ICE detainers, he added, but it still blurs jurisdictional lines. “Entering into the agreement to act as federal agents,” he said, “is going around state law.”

A sign reading "RYAN JESBERGER FOR SAUK COUNTY SHERIFF" stands on grass against the wooden wall of a building.
A campaign sign for Ryan Jesberger, the Democratic nominee for Sauk County sheriff, stands Sept. 24, 2026, outside Baraboo, Wis. (Paul Kiefer / Wisconsin Watch)
A large red sign reading "MATT BURCH SAUK COUNTY SHERIFF" stands beside a sidewalk, with a smaller "SKRABEL CORONER" sign farther down the lawn in front of a house.
A campaign sign for Matt Burch, the Republican nominee for Sauk County sheriff, Sept. 24, 2026, in Baraboo, Wis. (Paul Kiefer / Wisconsin Watch)

Jesberger also argues that even the county’s current agreement can strain sheriff’s office resources.

“Our deputies are busy enough doing things for the citizens of Sauk County,” he said, “so adding roles and responsibilities and, frankly, liability on top of all that is a concern of mine.”

Alongside its participation in the 287(g) program, Sauk County built on its partnership with ICE last year when it extended a long-standing agreement to hold federal detainees to include people held on immigration grounds. 

The county’s original agreement with the U.S. Marshals Service dates back more than two decades. The sheriff’s office modified that agreement in April 2025 to also include ICE. More than 200 ICE detainees have since passed through Sauk County, most of whom entered ICE custody either at the jail or in other Wisconsin correctional facilities.

ICE reimburses the county $106 per day for housing a person in removal proceedings, plus $38.45 per hour for staff time spent transporting ICE detainees. That contract yielded more than $150,000 for the Sauk County Sheriff’s Office between January and June – less than 1% of the office’s annual budget, and about 15% of what Burch calls its “flexible” budget, or the portion not already devoted to wages and benefits. 

“That money is important to us,” Burch said at the June forum.

Jesberger also promises to maintain the county’s contract to provide jail space for ICE detainees, though he pushes back on Burch’s focus on the revenue it yields, calling on law enforcement to “stop talking about human beings as numbers or revenue generation.” 

Instead, he sees the housing contract as a way to protect immigrants’ due process rights while they await rulings in their removal cases. 

Aside from offering Wisconsin-based attorneys easier access to their clients, Jesberger argues that a responsibly managed contract can ensure people in custody “are treated with respect and dignity, are not laying on a concrete floor with a foil blanket in overcrowded cells (and) are not being shipped out of state to detention facilities with inhumane conditions.”

Some Wisconsin immigration attorneys and immigrant rights advocates aren’t sold on that pitch. “Any amount of custody is an incentive for ICE to continue” its crackdown, said Aissa Olivarez of the Community Immigration Law Center in Madison.

Schwarz of the ACLU of Wisconsin agrees, saying that housing contracts like Sauk County’s make it easier — and cheaper — for the agency to scale up its operations.

Cooperating with ICE in any capacity has a “chilling effect” on immigrant communities, Milwaukee-based immigration attorney Marc Christopher said, and can make immigrants less likely to contact law enforcement in an emergency.

But Christopher also noted that Sauk County is far easier to reach than the larger detention facilities in Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana and Texas where many Wisconsin arrestees land while awaiting outcomes in their removal cases. “I can meet with them in person,” he said. “Their families know where they are, and their families can meet with them.”

Jesberger and Burch have no debates scheduled ahead of Election Day, but a local coalition that opposes all cooperation with federal immigration authorities is planning an Oct. 3 event featuring the ACLU of Wisconsin and immigrant rights group Voces de la Frontera. 

In Winnebago, sheriff candidates diverge amid a broader debate on surveillance

Eastern Wisconsin’s Winnebago County is more than twice as populous as Sauk County. Sheriff John Matz entered its 287(g) agreement — also a warrant service model — in March 2025. 

ICE has recorded roughly 25 arrests in the county since last January, almost all inside its jail. Capt. Darin Rice, the Republican running to replace the retiring Matz, says that low number is no reason to end the agreement. 

“I do believe that it needs to continue,” he told a packed audience in an Oshkosh City Hall conference room in September. Still, he underscored that he isn’t interested in “street-level enforcement” or renting jail beds to ICE.

Rice is running against his colleague, Patrol Officer Jason Rippl.

Rippl, the Democratic candidate, has broader 287(g) qualms than Jesberger. 

“I feel like the 287(g) agreement may open the door for additional involvement with (ICE),” he told Wisconsin Watch and Bolts, “and I think that by any modern law enforcement standards, we’ve seen pretty clearly that their tactics are sloppy.”

He promises to void the county’s 287(g) agreement on his first day in office, which he argues would free up time to “clean up our own backyard” by digging out of a backlog of warrants unrelated to immigration.

Rippl said he would honor warrants signed by a judge, but he doesn’t “feel it is the responsibility of local jails” to hold inmates beyond their release date based solely on a non-binding ICE request. 

Though Winnebago County isn’t named in the ACLU lawsuit, a ruling could affect any Wisconsin county’s ability to honor ICE detainer requests. Sheriffs could also refuse to honor detainers absent a court ruling, as some have done elsewhere.

The early attention on Winnebago County’s relationship with ICE may be shifting to law enforcement’s use of surveillance technology. Both Rice and Rippl said they had reservations about the handling of sensitive data from the license plate cameras, citing the well-documented recent history of the technology’s misuse.

The Winnebago County sheriff’s office decided in early September to suspend its partnership with Flock, the embattled tech company that has built up an extensive camera network nationwide and has drawn increasingly bipartisan backlash this year. 

A large white building with gray along the top stands beside a paved drive, with a fenced metal tank and fire hydrant outside.
The Sauk County Jail in Baraboo, Wis., Sept. 24, 2026. (Paul Kiefer / Wisconsin Watch)

Sauk County’s sheriff’s office continues to operate Flock cameras, introduced as part of a pilot project last year. Burch, the GOP nominee for sheriff, called the program a  “pet project” and credits the cameras for solving several high-stakes cases. Other law enforcement agencies in Wisconsin have, like Winnebago County, ended their contracts with Flock.

“We had a lot of pushback early on to the 287(g) program,” Rice told Wisconsin Watch and Bolts. “That’s now taken a back seat to Flock cameras.”

Rippl agreed that Flock is “certainly the more prevalent conversation topic” in his conversations with constituents, though he does not believe it has “overshadowed” the 287(g) debate.

Ongoing controversies over ICE’s use of Flock camera data link the two issues.

404 Media revealed last year that local law enforcement agencies across the country have queried data from Flock cameras on ICE’s behalf, including some in states with strict restrictions on local cooperation with ICE. Wisconsin has no such restrictions. 

The Sauk and Winnebago County sheriffs did not reply to a request for comment on how often their Flock cameras have been used for immigration enforcement. In Verona, a Madison suburb with a population roughly one tenth of Winnebago County’s, public records revealed hundreds of searches tied to ICE last year.

Correction: This story has been updated to note that Ryan Jesberger is a University of Wisconsin–Madison police lieutenant. A previous version incorrectly reported that he was a former lieutenant.

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

Two Wisconsin sheriff races test the future of local ICE cooperation is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

ATC restarts push for grid upgrades serving Port Washington data center

An aerial rendering shows multiple large industrial buildings, roads and ponds spread across a landscaped site surrounded by fields and wooded areas with low clouds.
Reading Time: 2 minutes

The American Transmission Company (ATC) refiled an application on Monday for a sweeping series of grid upgrades in eastern Wisconsin, restarting the state’s six-month review of a project to plug the new Port Washington data center into the grid.

ATC, the state’s largest transmission utility, initially sought Wisconsin Public Service Commission permission last September, with plans to break ground as early as May 2026. Its initial application outlined a more than $1.3 billion infrastructure package, including a high-voltage transmission line and five new substations across Fond du Lac, Ozaukee, Sheboygan and Washington counties, needed to “reliably serve” the new data center by December 2027.

But the commission sent ATC back to the drawing board last month after the company repeatedly adjusted the project’s design, leaving the public with a hazy picture of the proposal, according to commission staff and ratepayer advocates.

Project’s design keeps changing

ATC has since stressed the urgency of the buildout needed to support the data center boom. The company is part of a coalition of utilities asking the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) to speed up regional transmission projects needed to serve data centers by suspending competitive bidding, arguing that “bureaucratic red tape” presents a national security risk as the U.S. competes with China for “dominance” in the artificial intelligence race.

But the utility’s first application underwent multiple redesigns, including the addition of temporary bypass lines to avoid outages during construction. The PSC must review those changes and allow other parties, namely ratepayer advocates and affected landowners, an opportunity to weigh in. 

“I don’t recall any other comparable cases in my experience with as many application material document revisions and ongoing design changes throughout the process,” PSC Environmental Affairs Coordinator Adam Ingwell wrote in testimony filed in July. “The sheer volume of documents and revisions, without adequate explanation, likely makes it more challenging than typical for a member of the public to find specific information about the project.”

ATC, by contrast, cast the revisions as “routine.”

“Every application develops during review,” company attorneys wrote last month. “Changes far larger and later than ATC’s have never cast doubt” on whether an application should move forward, they added, citing a Barron County solar farm the PSC approved last March despite an “eleventh-hour” overhaul that included “relocating an entire substation.”

“There is simply no principled basis on which to treat ATC’s lesser and earlier changes more harshly,” the attorneys wrote. 

The three-member commission in August unanimously sided with ATC’s critics, directing ATC to  submit a new application to give the public a better opportunity to assess the full package. 

“This PSC is not opposed or hostile to data centers, construction, generation, (or) transmission,” PSC Chair Summer Strand said, calling the decision “an unfortunate outcome.” Nevertheless, she added, “this application represents a cautionary tale of when unrealistic and unreasonable speed-to-power expectations collide with a deliberative regulatory process.”

How latest application differs

ATC’s new application departs from the previous version in several ways, including removing a segment of transmission line through Trenton in Washington County and Saukville in Ozaukee County.

“The need for this project has not changed, but the application has,” Jared Winters,

ATC executive vice president and chief assets officer, said in a Monday press release.

The PSC will hold a new round of public comment on the project before determining whether it can move forward. That review will begin once the commission determines the new application is “complete.”

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

ATC restarts push for grid upgrades serving Port Washington data center is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

Court ruling could spare Wisconsin ratepayers costs of keeping Michigan coal plant open

Stack with steam coming out against blue sky
Reading Time: 2 minutes

Editor’s note: This story has been corrected to reflect uncertainty about when Consumers Energy will close the J.H. Campbell plant. 

Wisconsin ratepayers may no longer be on the hook to keep a Michigan coal plant running past its retirement date. 

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit on Friday overturned a U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) order keeping the 60-year-old J.H. Campbell power plant online. The plant’s operator, Consumers Energy, approached the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission in 2025 for permission to bill ratepayers across the Midwest for the plant’s operating costs.

The Energy Department intervened to block the western Michigan plant’s scheduled retirement last spring, arguing the closure could exacerbate an “emergency” electricity shortfall in the region. Its operator, Consumers Energy, has since spent at least $295 million to operate the plant as the department repeatedly extended its life.

Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers urged Energy Secretary Chris Wright in July to allow the plant to close, citing a projection that Wisconsinites alone could spend $117 million on the facility over “the next few years.” 

Wisconsin’s Citizens Utility Board joined a coalition of ratepayer advocacy groups in a December amicus brief supporting Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel’s lawsuit challenging the extension orders.

The court ruled unanimously for Michigan Friday, questioning the federal agency’s authority to invoke emergency powers to keep the plant open. 

“The Department’s position would empower it to pick its preferred power sources in Michigan — or, presumably, any other state — and order them to operate without regard to the multiple procedural and substantive constraints built into state reliability planning processes,” Judge Cornelia Pillard wrote. 

Nessel applauded the ruling in a Friday press release. 

“By forcing its continued operation, DOE tried a never-before-used tactic to illegally prop up the aging J.H. Campbell coal plant that nobody asked to keep, sticking ratepayers with a bill for a facility that should have been retired more than a year ago,” Nessel said. “I am relieved that the Court saw through this facade.”

Consumers Energy told reporters on Friday it is reviewing the ruling but does not plan to immediately close the plant.

The Energy Department has not made similar efforts to block the retirement of Wisconsin coal plants, though the agency plans to spend $425 million to shore up 13 coal plants in 10 states, at least $19 million of which may be used to extend operations at Alliant Energy’s coal-powered units at the Columbia Energy Center near Portage. 

Meanwhile, Wisconsin ratepayers still owe more than $1 billion in costs tied to retired coal plants. The Citizens Utility Board estimates that We Energies would collect more than $100 million in returns from those retired assets over the next two years under a rate proposal pending before Wisconsin’s Public Service Commission.

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

Court ruling could spare Wisconsin ratepayers costs of keeping Michigan coal plant open is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

ICE arrests in Wisconsin hit a new peak. Follow what happens next.

Green glass is shattered inside a car and on the ground.
Reading Time: < 1 minute

ICE arrests in Wisconsin hit a new peak. Follow what happens next. is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

Microsoft, ratepayer advocates challenge ATC plan for data center transmission costs

Large industrial buildings, cranes and construction barriers stand beneath a cloudy sky with sunlight breaking through.
Reading Time: 3 minutes

Microsoft and Wisconsin ratepayer advocates are asking federal regulators to hit the brakes on a proposal to allocate the costs of transmission infrastructure built to serve data centers. 

Both argue that We Energies and the American Transmission Company’s (ATC) recent proposal to federal regulators fails to adequately protect Wisconsinites from picking up the construction bill, among other concerns. 

The utilities’ plan — setting a minimum transmission charge for Microsoft based on its Mount Pleasant data center’s anticipated electricity needs — mirrors elements of a strategy approved by Wisconsin’s Public Service Commission (PSC) earlier this year. 

We Energies and ATC argue the minimum charge will help prevent their other customers from paying for overbuilt infrastructure if the facility uses less electricity than anticipated.

Microsoft and ratepayer advocates, however, argue that the proposal falls short on protecting Wisconsinites from cost shifts and that the two closely related utilities left little room for input from those most affected. 

Who pays for data center transmission upgrades?

ATC anticipates spending more than $500 million to upgrade the Mount Pleasant facility’s connection to the electrical grid. The utility passes infrastructure costs to customers of all kinds through their electrical bills; We Energies, for instance, estimates that transmission-related costs account for about 10% of customers’ bills. 

The PSC can’t require ATC to bill data center developers for the full cost of infrastructure built to serve them. Only the five-member Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC), which oversees interstate transmission, could overhaul billing rules to fully shield other customers from the costs of new lines and substations for data centers.

The PSC signed off on a work-around this spring, requiring We Energies to set a minimum transmission charge for its large data center customers based on their projected electricity use — the same projections used to plan transmission upgrades. 

ATC and We Energies asked FERC earlier this month to approve a one-off transmission billing plan for Microsoft’s Mount Pleasant data center. The arrangement would require We Energies to pay ATC for the data center’s projected transmission capacity and pass that cost to Microsoft. The 15-year arrangement would take effect once ATC completes the infrastructure needed to serve the facility. 

“This is a customer protection mechanism that follows the ‘cost causer, cost payer’ methodology,” an ATC spokesperson wrote in an email to Wisconsin Watch.

Microsoft says proposal leaves gaps

The utilities didn’t consult with Microsoft before filing their plan with federal regulators.

“The entire purpose of these agreements, by ATC’s own description,” is to serve the Mount Pleasant data center, Microsoft’s attorneys wrote in a protest to FERC on Friday. Moving ahead without Microsoft’s input, they added, would risk “the timely interconnection and operation of this infrastructure.”

In their view, the utilities’ current proposal contains “systemic” flaws.

Some, they argue, pose risks to Microsoft’s finances, including an early termination fee that could force the company to pay “excessively more” than the remaining value of the transmission infrastructure if it backs out of the agreement before the 15-year mark.

Both Microsoft and the Citizens Utility Board (CUB) argue other elements of the proposal pose risks to ATC’s other ratepayers, including those outside of We Energies’ territory.

In a separate protest filed Friday, CUB regulatory affairs director Corey Singletary noted that the proposal would base minimum transmission charges on ATC’s standard interconnection rates.

“The electric demands and associated supporting infrastructure investments are so large relative to traditional loads and investments” that ATC will almost certainly undershoot the actual cost of data centers’ transmission needs,  Singletary wrote. 

“While ATC’s proposal would likely be an improvement over the status quo,” he added, it still falls short of shielding the utility’s other customers from data-center-driven transmission costs.

Microsoft’s attorneys echoed those concerns, emphasizing that Microsoft signed the White House’s Ratepayer Protection Pledge this spring: a commitment to “pay for all new power delivery infrastructure upgrades required to service (its) data centers” and “ensure that these expenses are not passed on to the ordinary household.”

Microsoft urges more scrutiny

We Energies’ parent company, WEC Energy Group, is ATC’s largest shareholder.

“A negotiated bilateral contract between them — especially one involving such large sums — should be further scrutinized,” Microsoft’s attorneys wrote.

Microsoft also pointed out that the proposal wouldn’t require the utilities to seek their company’s input before amending some terms of the contract, nor would it “create a clear path for Microsoft (or anyone else) to inquire and scrutinize the scope or prudence of expenditures made on its behalf.” 

Microsoft’s attorneys called that opacity “a recipe for future misunderstanding and litigation.”

Microsoft is asking FERC to send the entire proposal to a settlement judge, creating a venue for all parties to work through their concerns. As an alternative, the company’s attorneys suggested that the commission reject the utilities’ proposal outright. CUB, meanwhile, urged the commission to create a uniform transmission cost allocation process for all large data centers in ATC’s territory — including those in Port Washington and Beaver Dam.

ATC has yet to file a response to the complaints. 

“ATC is reviewing Microsoft’s filing and will respond through the established FERC process to demonstrate that existing customers are fully protected by the agreements,” a spokesperson wrote in an email on Tuesday. “We remain committed to cost transparency and protection of existing customers while ensuring reliable transmission service.”

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

Microsoft, ratepayer advocates challenge ATC plan for data center transmission costs is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

We Energies signs 20-year Point Beach nuclear power deal

Reading Time: 2 minutes

We Energies signed a new 20-year agreement to purchase electricity from the Point Beach nuclear plant in Manitowoc County, resolving uncertainty about the relationship between the utility and the state’s largest power plant. 

The agreement, disclosed in a Tuesday U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filing, still requires sign-off from Wisconsin’s Public Service Commission (PSC).

The roughly 60-year-old facility is Wisconsin’s only active nuclear power plant. We Energies owned the plant until 2007, when it sold Point Beach to a Florida-based utility. It currently purchases most of the plant’s output from independent energy infrastructure giant NextEra Energy.

But the electricity Point Beach generates is particularly expensive. We Energies spends about twice as much on fuel as its sibling utility, Wisconsin Public Service Company; the cost of fuel for Point Beach accounts for a large share of the difference. Milwaukee-based WEC Energy Group owns both utilities. The price of each megawatt hour of electricity produced by the plant rises by more than 7% each year under We Energies’ current arrangement with NextEra.

Ratepayer advocates have pushed We Energies to rethink its Point Beach contract for years. The PSC directed the utility to work with ratepayer groups to “review alternatives” to the power purchase agreement in 2019 as part of a broader rate case, and WEC Energy Group CEO Scott Lauber signaled that his company was considering alternatives as recently as last month.

We Energies’ latest SEC filing did not divulge most details of the new agreement, but spokesman Brendan Conway told Wisconsin Watch that it “will provide customers with fuel savings compared with the current (agreement) when it goes into effect.” 

If the PSC approves the proposed agreement, We Energies would buy 86% of the plant’s energy for another two decades. Its current contract is set to expire by 2033, according to the new filing. 

Wisconsin’s Citizens Utility Board (CUB), a nonprofit representing residential and some small commercial electricity customers statewide before the PSC, is among the most vocal critics of the current Point Beach contract.

CUB plans to review the new proposal with an “eye toward learning how much savings are in store for customers” compared to the current steep annual price increases, said CUB Executive Director Tom Content. “Given the climate and carbon commitments of the tech companies, I’ll be interested to learn whether Big Tech companies opening data centers in eastern Wisconsin want the carbon-free benefits of nuclear. That could relieve some of the price pressure being felt — every year — by 1.1 million We Energies customers.” 

We Energies is also eyeing an opportunity to add more nuclear energy to Wisconsin’s grid: the decommissioned Kewaunee Power Station. WEC Energy Group and the plant’s owner, Energy Solutions, are awaiting the Nuclear Regulatory Commission’s approval to restart production at the site more than a decade after a glut of cheap natural gas from the fracking boom drove it out of business. 

There’s no shortage of demand for electricity. A draft PSC report published in June projects Wisconsin’s peak electricity demand will rise 40% in the next five years, driven largely by new data centers in Port Washington, Mount Pleasant and Beaver Dam — possibly with more to come.

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

We Energies signs 20-year Point Beach nuclear power deal is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

Wisconsin tracks police use of force, but the numbers are hard to compare

People wearing helmets and uniforms stand behind shields marked "STATE PATROL" as two people face them at night near a building.
Reading Time: 6 minutes
Click here to read highlights from the story
  • Wisconsin collects statewide data on serious police uses of force, but inconsistent reporting standards make it difficult to reliably compare departments.
  • Police departments differ in what they define use of force, with some tracking actions — such as dog bites, pointing firearms or vehicle maneuvers — that others do not.
  • One expert says inconsistent statewide standards can make agencies that report more comprehensively appear more force-prone, potentially discouraging transparency.

A Madison police officer’s fatal shooting of 38-year-old Corey Ruiz last month was the department’s first in more than five years.

Madison police officers are less likely to open fire during an arrest than officers in most similarly sized departments nationwide. But police shootings account for only a tiny fraction of all uses of force in Madison and elsewhere. 

How does Madison’s broader use-of-force record compare with other departments? Inconsistent state-level data makes that question difficult to answer.

State lawmakers laid the groundwork for such comparisons in 2021 — one of many police oversight reforms enacted nationwide after a Minneapolis police officer killed George Floyd a year earlier. Wisconsin lawmakers voted to require the state Department of Justice to catalog serious uses of force by police departments and sheriffs’ offices. The DOJ now maintains a public Use-of-Force and Arrest-Related Death database, but the underlying law leaves room for law enforcement agencies to differ in the types of force they report to the state.

The result: The data offers apples-to-oranges comparisons that make it difficult to meaningfully weigh one agency’s record against another’s. 

Departments vary in rules for use-of-force tracking

Law enforcement agencies generally require officers to report uses of force to their chain of command.

Most agencies compile those records into internal datasets or annual reports, but they vary widely in the types of incidents they track.

The Green Bay Police Department, for instance, requires officers to file an after-action report if they use their police car to block, pin or strike another moving vehicle. The Milwaukee Police Department requires officers to file a similar report after conducting a “forcible blood draw.” Madison Police Department guidelines mention neither type of incident.

A document section titled "USE OF FORCE REPORTING REQUIRED" lists weapons, devices and tactics that require an officer to complete an incident report.
Types of force that require reporting, as shown in the Madison Police Department’s standard operating procedure.

Both the Madison and Milwaukee police departments, however, require officers to file after-action reports if they point their firearms at a person, regardless of whether they fire a shot. Green Bay’s department does not. 

“There’s really no uniformity,” said Matt Graham, a senior data analyst with the nonprofit Center for Policing Equity. 

While some states — New Jersey, for instance — have standardized use-of-force reporting rules for law enforcement, Graham said, Wisconsin’s patchwork of policies more closely resembles the national norm.

Though internal use-of-force data can’t be used to compare agencies, a single police department can still use its own data to “analyze whether any racial or other demographic disparities exist in their use of force patterns” and evaluate whether policies and training effectively limit unnecessary use of force, said Meghan Stroshine, associate director of Marquette University’s Criminal Justice Data Analytics program.  

Internal Madison Police Department records show more than 2,300 uses of force between 2020 and the first quarter of 2026, sometimes listing more than one use of force for a single police encounter. Most incidents involved bodily force alone, though officers reported using Tasers 197 times and pepper spray 127 times. The department averaged roughly 185,000 annual calls per service in recent years.

Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson’s shooting of Ruiz in late July was the department’s seventh since 2020 and its first fatal case since October 2019, when officers killed 63-year-old Dean Thomas in a shootout on Madison’s southwest side. 

Limited state-level data

The Department of Justice database is more complete than Madison’s internal records in at least one instance.

Madison use-of-force records include an entry matching the December 2024 arrest of 32-year-old Richard Johnson in a hotel parking lot. Officers tackled Johnson while investigating a reported car theft; the department’s entry describes his resulting injury as an “abrasion.” It does not note that Johnson went into cardiac arrest and died at a hospital the following day. 

The Dane County medical examiner ruled the death an accident, citing Johnson’s cocaine use as the primary cause of his heart attack. Madison’s Office of the Independent Police Monitor disputed that finding in June, arguing that Johnson’s death should be treated as a homicide. 

Unlike the internal Madison records, the DOJ’s database includes Johnson’s “arrest related death.” 

The 2021 state law behind the DOJ’s use-of-force tracking efforts requires the agency to collect records only on incidents resulting in “great bodily harm or death” and those involving gunfire — either an officer shooting at a civilian or vice versa. A separate law requires the agency to log any cases in which a person “dies while detained, arrested, or in the course of being arrested,” even if the death isn’t a direct result of a use of force. The DOJ combines both sets of records in its database.

That dataset lists 70 arrest-related deaths between 2022 and 2025. The Rock County Sheriff’s Office reported five of those deaths, all but one of which took place in the county’s jail. Though the database doesn’t specify causes of arrest-related deaths, the sheriff’s office characterized one death as a suicide and another as an accidental drug overdose.

The DOJ’s records are far from a perfect measuring stick. The DOJ relies on law enforcement agencies to provide up-to-date reports of serious uses of force, but agencies differ in the types of force they consider serious enough to report to the state.

While the agency “works continuously with agencies to train on proper data entry and usage of the form, as well as performs incident audits,” DOJ spokesperson Riley Vetterkind wrote, “the responsibility to report accurate, up-to-date data falls on each law enforcement agency.”  

“Ultimately, even when relying upon a rigid definition, human judgement is still a factor,” he added.

What is ‘great bodily harm’?

Wisconsin Statutes define “great bodily harm” as “bodily injury which creates a substantial risk of death, or which causes serious permanent disfigurement, or which causes a permanent or protracted loss or impairment of the function of any bodily member or organ or other serious bodily injury.”

Those variations can skew the number of incidents a given department reports to the state. 

Green Bay police, for instance, reported 31 serious use-of-force incidents to the DOJ between 2022 and 2025 — second only to Milwaukee’s police department, which reported 35 incidents in the same period. 

Milwaukee employs roughly 1,500 sworn police officers and received over 1 million calls for service over that four-year span, compared to Green Bay’s 176 sworn officers and roughly 270,000 calls for service. 

The Kenosha Police Department, with more sworn officers serving a city only slightly less populous than Green Bay, reported only five incidents. 

Those figures do not include arrest-related deaths, including the February 2024 suicide of 40-year-old Steve Evaristo Ventura after a shootout with Green Bay police officers. 

But Green Bay may not be as much of an outlier as it appears. All but three of the department’s use-of-force incidents in the state database involve police dog bites. 

Madison’s police department has not reported any dog bites to the DOJ since 2022, though its internal records list 27 incidents involving dog bites in the past four years — most of which sent the bitten person to the emergency room. A Madison Police Department spokesperson did not respond to questions about the department’s threshold for reporting uses of force to the state.

The Milwaukee Police Department likewise reported no dog bites to the DOJ between 2022 and 2025, though the department’s own use-of-force records list nearly a dozen dog bite incidents — many of them accidental. 

Green Bay Police Chief Chris Davis told Wisconsin Watch he can’t neatly explain his department’s relatively high use-of-force tally without first reviewing peer agencies’ standards for reporting to the DOJ. 

“Our intention is to report everything to the state that we’re required to under the law,” he said, “because I think it’s good for the public to know.”

Most Wisconsin law enforcement agencies reported no uses of force to the DOJ. Among those that reported at least one incident, a third exclusively reported incidents in which a police officer discharged a firearm.

The mismatch in use-of-force reporting standards across departments limits the usefulness of the DOJ’s data. 

“If you’re able to actually compare across departments, you could have a good idea of what reforms (or) what interventions are actually reducing use of force,” Graham said. “So far, that’s generally not possible in most places in the U.S.”

In the meantime, agencies that report a broader range of use-of-force incidents to the DOJ risk appearing more force-prone than agencies with narrower reporting standards, Stroshine said. 

“Without an insider’s understanding of the data and what it represents, one could make any number of erroneous conclusions about a department, its culture, or the nature and frequency of its officers’ use of force,” Stroshine said. “As a consequence, one could argue that nonstandardization creates a disincentive for data transparency.” 

The 2021 state law left some discretion for law enforcement agencies to decide which incidents to report to the state. 

Some of that flexibility was intentional, said Scott Kelly, chief of staff for state Sen. Van Wanggaard, R-Racine, the bill’s prime sponsor. 

“One of the things that was discussed was that different departments do record uses of force differently,” he said, “and we didn’t want to change how they dealt with it themselves.” 

With law enforcement agencies already under heightened scrutiny at the time, pushing departments to standardize their use-of-force reporting could have been too much to ask, he said. “That’s for a future legislature to decide.”

Davis, the Green Bay chief, says consistent statewide reporting is an achievable goal.

“We already use the same standards for use-of-force training and policy throughout the state,” he said, “so I think it’s not too far to jump to get to the same standards for use-of-force reporting.”

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

Wisconsin tracks police use of force, but the numbers are hard to compare is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

Oracle drops lawsuit challenging Wisconsin data center credit rules

A curved glass building displays the word "ORACLE" near the top, with trees and a light pole in the foreground.
Reading Time: 4 minutes

Oracle moved to voluntarily drop its lawsuit against Wisconsin’s utility regulator on Monday, nearly two months after the tech giant turned to the Ozaukee County Circuit Court to challenge new credit rating requirements for data center developers in eastern Wisconsin.

With the case put to rest, the credit rating rules — intended to shield other Wisconsin ratepayers from fallout in the event a data center developer goes bust — now stand unchallenged. Oracle previously argued the requirements were overly stringent and could dissuade other companies from setting up operations in Wisconsin.

Oracle’s share price has begun to rebound after a collapse that began in early June and continued for weeks after the company sued Wisconsin’s Public Service Commission (PSC). Its credit rating, however, remains well below the threshold at which it could avoid posting hundreds of millions of dollars in collateral as a condition of buying electricity for the Port Washington data center.

Vast power needs for data center

The Nashville-based cloud computing firm is a co-developer of the data center campus in Port Washington. The trio behind the project — Oracle, OpenAI and data center developer Vantage — expect the facility to require 1.3 gigawatts of electrical generation capacity in its first phase, or enough to power roughly a million Wisconsin homes.

We Energies, Wisconsin’s largest investor-owned utility, must meet the campus’ energy needs by a tentative late-2027 deadline.

The Port Washington facility’s energy needs are so vast — an order of magnitude greater than the Saukville steel mill that was, until recently, Wisconsin’s largest electricity user —  that state rules require it to buy its electricity under a specialized rate structure.

The PSC approved that rate structure for We Energies’ largest data center customers in May. Among other rules, the commission’s order requires the facilities’ operators to pay for the construction of new power plants needed to meet their energy needs.

But constructing a new plant can cost hundreds of millions of dollars, and any unpaid debts tied to the plants could fall on We Energies’ other customers if a data center operator becomes insolvent.

To shield ratepayers from a potential cost shift, the PSC set an A- credit rating threshold for data center operators seeking electric service from We Energies. Companies below the threshold must post steep collateral, either in cash or lines of credit.

That requirement could cost Oracle over $100 million per year in financial security payments. The company held a BBB credit rating when the PSC approved the credit rating standards, largely because of its aggressive borrowing to finance artificial intelligence ventures and its business relationship with OpenAI. 

S&P Global Ratings, one of the “Big Three” credit rating agencies responsible for assessing creditworthiness of government and corporate debt, lowered Oracle’s rating to a BBB- on July 9 — the bottom edge of the agency’s “investment-grade” tier.

PSC declines to reopen case

We Energies asked the PSC to reconsider the rule in June, arguing that the added cost could dissuade other companies from operating in Wisconsin. The PSC declined the request last month, and We Energies CEO Scott Lauber reassured investors on a recent quarterly earnings call that the credit requirements pose no threat to the Port Washington project’s viability.

Oracle, however, sued the commission in Ozaukee County Circuit Court as a backup to the reopener request. The company’s June lawsuit asked Judge Sandy Williams to “set aside, reverse, and remand” the credit rating requirements, arguing that they aren’t “needed to prevent harm” to We Energies’ other customers or shareholders.

The commission responded last month, accusing Oracle of trying to dodge regulatory scrutiny by seeking “to overturn over one-hundred years of established caselaw” and “dictate one-off preferential terms of service” with We Energies.

Questions remain for data center developers

Oracle’s attorneys filed a motion to voluntarily dismiss the lawsuit early on Monday morning.

Ratepayer advocates who supported the credit rating requirements celebrated the end of the lawsuit.

“We were confident the PSC would win and that the consumer protection safeguards the CUB team sought would remain in place,” said Tom Content, executive director of Wisconsin’s Citizens Utility Board. 

“CUB believes the safeguards the PSC established are critical to protect We Energies customers from the risks of tech companies overextending their borrowing, calling into question the long-run solvency of those companies.”

“This is an important win for Wisconsin since these safeguards — which We Energies claims would  ‘narrow the pool of investors’ for AI data center projects — could be used as a blueprint in other parts of the state,” said Clean Wisconsin spokesperson Amy Barrilleaux. 

The end of one legal fight doesn’t guarantee smooth sailing for the Port Washington project. The PSC voted last week to require the American Transmission Company (ATC) — the transmission utility responsible for connecting the data center to the grid — to restart the six-month application process to build the requisite transmission lines and substations, citing a series of design changes the utility made after the commission began reviewing its proposal.

Though the redo will leave ATC little time to meet its December 2027 deadline to plug in the Port Washington data center, the company has yet to announce changes to its timeline. 

Meanwhile, data center developer Cloverleaf Infrastructure signaled that it is considering developing facilities in Madison Gas and Electric’s territory. The utility, which serves the core of the Madison metropolitan area, is awaiting the PSC’s input on its own data center rate structure. 

MGE’s proposal would also require developers with credit ratings below A- to post collateral, with lower collateral requirements for companies rated BBB+ than for those with BBB ratings or below.

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

Oracle drops lawsuit challenging Wisconsin data center credit rules is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

Wisconsin regulators send ATC back to the drawing board on data center connection project

An aerial rendering shows multiple large industrial buildings, roads and ponds spread across a landscaped site surrounded by fields and wooded areas with low clouds.
Reading Time: 5 minutes

Wisconsin regulators voted Thursday to send the American Transmission Company (ATC) back to the drawing board as the utility attempts to build the grid infrastructure needed to plug in the Port Washington data center. 

Public Service Commission (PSC) Chair Summer Strand called the move a “reasonable reset” after ATC repeatedly adjusted the project’s design, which commission staff and ratepayer advocates argued left both regulators and the public with a muddy picture of a grid expansion expected to cost well over $1 billion. 

ATC and its partners, however, warned the decision — likely the first of its kind for the century-old commission — could set a dangerous precedent that drives away investment in Wisconsin’s energy sector.

Data center connection at risk

ATC, which owns and operates transmission lines in the eastern half of Wisconsin, is on the hook to connect the soon-to-open Port Washington data center to the electrical grid. 

The company approached the PSC last September for permission to break ground on the project as early as this past May. Its initial application outlined a more than $1.3 billion infrastructure package, including a high-voltage transmission line and five new substations spread across Fond du Lac, Ozaukee, Sheboygan and Washington counties, needed to “reliably serve” the new data center by December 2027. After two months of back-and-forth over the “completeness” of ATC’s application, the commission took up the proposal in December 2025. 

ATC has since been vocal about the urgency of the infrastructure buildout needed to support the data center boom. The company is part of a coalition of utilities asking the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) to speed up regional transmission projects needed to serve data centers by suspending competitive bidding, arguing that “bureaucratic red tape” presents a national security risk as the U.S. competes with China for “dominance” in the artificial intelligence race. 

Meanwhile, the utility has repeatedly adjusted its plans since December, redesigning proposed routes and adding a set of temporary bypass lines needed to avoid outages during construction. The PSC is responsible for reviewing those changes and giving other parties, namely ratepayer advocates and affected landowners, an opportunity to weigh in. 

Some commission staff sounded the alarm as the pile of revisions — and questions — grew.

“I don’t recall any other comparable cases in my experience with as many application material document revisions and ongoing design changes throughout the process,” PSC Environmental Affairs Coordinator Adam Ingwell wrote in testimony filed last month. “The sheer volume of documents and revisions, without adequate explanation, likely makes it more challenging than typical for a member of the public to find specific information about the project.”

Those concerns reached Administrative Law Judge Michael Newmark, who criticized ATC for creating an “unreasonable burden” on commission staff and the public by scattering “a plethora of changes, modifications and updates” across six months of filings. 

ATC, on the other hand, cast the revisions as “routine.”

“Every application develops during review,” the company’s attorneys wrote on Wednesday. “Changes far larger and later than ATC’s have never cast doubt” on whether an application should move forward, they added, citing a Barron County solar farm the PSC approved last March despite an “eleventh-hour” overhaul that included “relocating an entire substation.”

“There is simply no principled basis on which to treat ATC’s lesser and earlier changes more harshly,” the attorneys wrote. 

Ratepayer advocates weigh in

Ratepayer advocates generally avoid wading into fights over transmission line routes and substation siting, which Wisconsin Citizens Utility Board (CUB) Regulatory Affairs Director Corey Singletary described as a “zero-sum proposition” in which a victory for one group of landowners means shifting construction impacts onto another group of landowners.

But CUB raised concerns that ATC’s revisions make it difficult to forecast the project’s cost.

The route changes and new bypasses make the price tag “a moving target,” said CUB Executive Director Tom Content, as does the possibility that ATC still attempts to complete the project by December 2027. “Would they be paying double overtime or triple overtime to build it that quickly?” 

The Wisconsin Utility Association itself weighed in on Wednesday to warn the PSC that any additional delays in the project will “lead to increased costs for customers.”

Transmission utilities generally pass along the costs of new infrastructure to ratepayers of all kinds via their electrical bills; We Energies, for instance, estimates that transmission-related costs account for about 10% of customers’ bills. 

The PSC can’t require ATC to assign project costs to the companies developing the Port Washington data center. Only FERC, the five-person federal regulator that oversees interstate transmission, could overhaul billing rules to fully shield other customers from the costs of new lines and substations needed to serve data centers.

The commission offered an ad hoc solution this spring. The PSC’s May order creating a new billing structure for We Energies’ data center customers requires data center operators to pay a minimum transmission charge based on their projected electricity use. Wisconsin PSC Commissioner Kristi Nieto called the arrangement a “temporary stopgap measure” to protect other customers from the costs of overbuilt infrastructure if data centers use less electricity than anticipated. 

ATC and We Energies have since asked the PSC and FERC to approve a minimum transmission charge agreement with Microsoft, the operator of the vast new data center in Mount Pleasant. “This is a customer protection mechanism that follows the ‘cost causer, cost payer’ methodology,” an ATC spokesperson wrote in an email to Wisconsin Watch.

The utilities have not yet asked the commission to approve similar agreements with the companies developing the Port Washington facility: cloud computing giant Oracle, artificial intelligence firm OpenAI and data center developer Vantage.

In testimony filed last month, Singletary urged the commission to enforce “cost containment” measures for ATC’s project, including requiring the utility to cap its annual revenues from the new transmission lines. He also suggested that the commission push ATC to disclose any bids it receives for “work to be performed and equipment to be procured as part of this project,” which he argued would help keep an eye on the company’s efforts to rein in costs. 

‘Least-bad option’

All three commissioners aired matching frustrations during a Thursday afternoon hearing on ATC’s infrastructure plans before concurring on what Commissioner Marcus Hawkins called the “least-bad option” — requiring ATC to resubmit its application and restarting the case’s 180-day clock.

“There needs to be flexibility in the process,” said Nieto, “but there also has to be some point at which the changes become significant enough that we need to evaluate whether we are still reviewing the same project that was originally proposed.”

“This PSC is not opposed or hostile to data centers, construction, generation, (or) transmission,” Strand said, calling the decision “an unfortunate outcome.” Nevertheless, she added, “this application represents a cautionary tale of when unrealistic and unreasonable speed-to-power expectations collide with a deliberative regulatory process.”

ATC has not indicated when it will resubmit its application as of Thursday afternoon, nor whether the December 2027 deadline is still within reach. “ATC is disappointed with today’s Commission’s decision and is considering its options,” a company spokesperson wrote after the hearing. 

But the company’s final filing before the hearing signaled the possibility of a legal fight. “To date, the Commission has processed the application consistent with the law,” the company’s attorneys wrote. “At this stage,” restarting the process “would be the one action to depart from that.”

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

Wisconsin regulators send ATC back to the drawing board on data center connection project is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

We Energies says Microsoft won’t be held to contract terms that conflict with state regulators’ order

An aerial view shows a large industrial complex with adjacent electrical infrastructure, roads and retention ponds at sunset, with open land and power lines in the foreground.
Reading Time: 4 minutes
Click here to read highlights from the story
  • Microsoft’s new 15-year electric service contract with We Energies includes outdated language limiting where power plants serving its Mount Pleasant data center could be located.
  • The Public Service Commission rejected the geographic restriction, which would have limited Microsoft’s access to wind energy from neighboring states.
  • We Energies says the commission’s order — not the outdated contract language — will govern Microsoft’s power purchases.
  • Consumer advocates question why We Energies asked Microsoft to sign a contract that didn’t reflect regulators’ decision.

Microsoft’s new 15-year electric service contract for its Mount Pleasant data center includes a provision Wisconsin regulators previously rejected. 

Signed last month, the agreement with We Energies specifies that power plants built or purchased to serve data centers must be located in eastern Wisconsin or Michigan’s Upper Peninsula. But Wisconsin’s Public Service Commission (PSC) voted in May to remove those geographic constraints, which critics argued would cut off Microsoft’s access to abundant wind power generated elsewhere in the Midwest and Great Plains. 

We Energies says it will follow the commission’s order — as opposed to the contract’s language — while it works with the commission to resolve the discrepancy. In the meantime, some observers question how an outdated version of a high-stakes contract made it this far.

Where should data centers look for power? 

The mismatch traces back to one of many disagreements that arose during the PSC’s deliberations on a new rate structure for large data center customers: Should those facilities rely on nearby plants alone or be free to tap energy sources elsewhere?

The PSC-approved rate structure allows large data center operators to “subscribe” to new power plants, picking up the bill for purchasing or constructing them in exchange for the right to use the electricity they generate and revenue from selling surplus electricity on the wholesale market.

We Energies argued that those plants should be located as close as possible to the data centers they would serve. 

Longer distances would increase the risk of grid failures disrupting data center operations, WEC Energy Group Director of Planning Jody Arendt told the PSC in January. WEC Energy Group is We Energies’ holding company.

The local power plants would be within the territory of the American Transmission Company (ATC), a transmission utility in which We Energies owns a majority stake — a relationship that could simplify coordinating repairs and upgrades, Arendt said.

Ratepayer advocates and clean energy groups criticized the plan, arguing it would limit data centers’ access to wind energy. 

Electricity generated by onshore wind farms is, by some measures, cheaper than electricity generated by new natural gas plants. The Midwest’s regional grid operator has approved billions of dollars in grid upgrades over the past five years, in part to streamline transmitting wind energy from regions with high winds to population centers and industrial hubs. 

We Energies fully or partially owns a half-dozen planned and operational wind farms in Wisconsin, including the new Badger Hollow wind farm in Iowa and Grant counties. But neighboring states — especially Iowa and Minnesota — have far higher average wind speeds and generate vastly more wind power.

“Any Wisconsin customers should be able to benefit from lower cost resources like the wind profile in southern Minnesota,” Wisconsin Citizens Utility Board Executive Director Tom Content wrote in an email to Wisconsin Watch. 

The PSC ultimately sided with CUB and clean energy groups, striking the location constraints from the data center rate structure it approved in May. 

“Over-indexing on a smaller geographic area comes with its own risks,” said Commissioner Marcus Hawkins, adding that planned grid upgrades could resolve some of the challenges of powering data centers from afar. 

Outdated contract

With the rate structure approved, We Energies sent Microsoft a contract to implement the new rate structure.

Microsoft asked the PSC in June to reopen the case, in part to address “multiple errors or inconsistencies” in We Energies’ contract — including the provision limiting new power plants to eastern Wisconsin and the Upper Peninsula.

We Energies offered to drop the line, among other “ministerial changes that could streamline or improve” the contract.

After the PSC declined to reopen the case, Microsoft signed the contract as-is on July 16. A Microsoft spokesperson declined to comment on the contract.

Because the commission “did not reopen their decision or take up these changes,” the utility still needs to work with the PSC to fix the contracts, We Energies spokesperson Brendan Conway wrote in an email. “We do not have a timeline for when the language will be updated.”

“From a practical perspective,” he added, Microsoft will be held to the PSC-approved rules, meaning it can subscribe to plants outside of eastern Wisconsin and the Upper Peninsula. 

The companies are legally required to abide by the PSC’s terms, commission spokesperson Meghan Sovey-Lashua wrote in an email.

“To the degree there are conflicts” with the PSC’s order, Sovey-Lashua added, “there are procedural options” to bring the issue back to the commission for a resolution.

Ratepayer advocates, meanwhile, wonder why We Energies asked Microsoft to sign an outdated version of the contract in the first place. 

“There’s a basic and common-sense expectation that a utility’s filing would be revised to reflect changes the PSC made to a proposal,” Content wrote, “particularly for an issue that generated a fair amount of discussion during the seven-hour deliberation on this issue.” 

Microsoft has already signed up to purchase electricity from the planned Red Oak Ridge Energy Center in Kenosha County. We Energies is currently asking the PSC for permission to buy the natural gas plant from developer Invenergy for $1.8 billion while Invenergy awaits PSC approval to build the plant. 

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

We Energies says Microsoft won’t be held to contract terms that conflict with state regulators’ order is a post from Wisconsin Watch, a non-profit investigative news site covering Wisconsin since 2009. Please consider making a contribution to support our journalism.

❌